Seth Rogan; Funny or just Funny looking?

[CutMeMick]

I think Knocked Up & Superbad were brilliant...
Both top notch comdedy...

Pineapple Express not so much funny, it had it's moments.

[Kev]

I think Knocked Up & Superbad were brilliant...
Both top notch comdedy...

Pineapple Express not so much funny, it had it's moments.

You seen Zack and Miri make a porno Mick?

It's hilarious, literally laugh out loud funny, best comedy of the year for me.

It helps obviously that I live for porn

[Preme]

It seems this guy is being billed as the next funny guy, last stint have films have all meant to be funny, Superbad, knocked up, pinapple express and Zack and Miri make a porno.

After seeing the last one i have started to think this guy is just a chubby curly headed fuck who is NOT even close to being funny. I thought first time around he was funny in superbad, but i think it was just the film was fucking awsome and he blended in. Knocked up was ok i gues, but again he was shit. Pinapple express was so-so and zack and mirii i liked, just thought the parts that he was in were shit.

guy gets more and more lame the more i see him.

He was more in the background in the 40 Year Old Virgin, but when I saw him in Knocked Up I was completely bored with him. On the cover he's making this goofy face as if that alone is enough to make us laugh. In that movie and everywhere I've seen him since he seems to be trying to be funny rather than being funny. I just don't get him in the least. I don't think it's a generational thing, because there's newer guys who have come along I find funny. That chubby guy in Superbad, I like him. The guy is just filled with anti-funny. My laugh boner gets soft when he comes onscreen.

pretty much how i feel, but going by some of thing things mick and others have said i think he clearly is funny, or he can write funny, but he is a shit actor.