Is James Toney Really Finished ?

[ICB]

I was just looking at an old thread i made, and i was saying James Toney should retire. Because im a big fan of his, and this was just after his fight with Danny Batchelder.

But then he comesback with a decent performance against Hasim Rahman, but then he has another sub-par peformance against Fres Oquendo. Who isn't a bad fighter IMO, and that kind of style has troubled James Toney in the past, see the Terry McGroom fight.

So is he really finished ? he seems to go through these bad patches, of strugging against lower class opposition. But i think he has one good one left in him, if he's next opponent is chosen carefully. A fighter that stands right in front of him with no movement, allowing him to rattle off his counters.