Using this criteria Who's ranked higher all time?

[DaxxKahn]

In-ring Performance
Achievements
Dominance
Mainstream Appeal


Marvin Hagler, BHop, RJJ, JCalzaghe, Antonio Tarver, Eubank, SRL, james toney, Sweet pea...

In Ring Performance
SRL- His fights w Duran, Hearns, Hagler alone dwarf the comp of everyone on the list but PW

Achievements-
SRL we have to go by quality of opp, amount of titles etc...Leonard beat Benitez, Duran, Hearns, Hagler, I mean these guys are in the top 25 ATG P4P...He won titles at 147, 154, 160, 168, 175

Dominance
Hagler absolutely ruled the MW division and beat his opp silly

Mainstream appeal-
SRL this guy in the 80's was DLH, Pacquiao, and everyone else on the list rolled into one...Those who don't realize the popularity of Leonard in his hey day are too young to have been around back then...He was the face of Boxing after Ali retired

\Leonard is the top of this list....Not saying the best fighter of them all but still using the criteria he dominated....Tarver and Eubank dont even belong in the company of the others

[JazMerkin]

Ok, all of these are in order

In-ring Performance

Sugar Ray Leonard
Pernell Whitaker
Roy Jones Jr
Marvin Hagler
Bernard Hopkins
James Toney
Joe Calzaghe
Antonio Tarver
Chris Eubank

Achievements

Roy Jones Jr
Sugar Ray Leonard
Bernard Hopkins
Pernell Whitaker
Marvin Hagler
Joe Calzaghe
James Toney
Antonio Tarver
Chris Eubank

Dominance

Marvin Hagler
Pernell Whitaker
Roy Jones Jr
Bernard Hopkins
Sugar Ray Leonard
Joe Calzaghe
James Toney
Antonio Tarver

Mainstream Appeal

Sugar Ray Leonard (& it's not even close here)
Marvin Hagler
Roy Jones Jr
Chris Eubank (only in UK)
Bernard Hopkins
Antonio Tarver
James Toney
Joe Calzaghe
Pernell Whitaker

On the last one, it's Leonard in a far out lead, followed by Hagler, who's closely followed by Jones than the rest are all a similar level.

[DaxxKahn]

Ok, all of these are in order

In-ring Performance

Sugar Ray Leonard
Pernell Whitaker
Roy Jones Jr
Marvin Hagler
Bernard Hopkins
James Toney
Joe Calzaghe
Antonio Tarver
Chris Eubank

Achievements

Roy Jones Jr
Sugar Ray Leonard
Bernard Hopkins
Pernell Whitaker
Marvin Hagler
Joe Calzaghe
James Toney
Antonio Tarver
Chris Eubank

Dominance

Marvin Hagler
Pernell Whitaker
Roy Jones Jr
Bernard Hopkins
Sugar Ray Leonard
Joe Calzaghe
James Toney
Antonio Tarver

Mainstream Appeal

Sugar Ray Leonard (& it's not even close here)
Marvin Hagler
Roy Jones Jr
Chris Eubank (only in UK)
Bernard Hopkins
Antonio Tarver
James Toney
Joe Calzaghe
Pernell Whitaker

On the last one, it's Leonard in a far out lead, followed by Hagler, who's closely followed by Jones than the rest are all a similar level.

You really think Pernell was more Dominate then Jones was?

[JazMerkin]

Ok, all of these are in order

In-ring Performance

Sugar Ray Leonard
Pernell Whitaker
Roy Jones Jr
Marvin Hagler
Bernard Hopkins
James Toney
Joe Calzaghe
Antonio Tarver
Chris Eubank

Achievements

Roy Jones Jr
Sugar Ray Leonard
Bernard Hopkins
Pernell Whitaker
Marvin Hagler
Joe Calzaghe
James Toney
Antonio Tarver
Chris Eubank

Dominance

Marvin Hagler
Pernell Whitaker
Roy Jones Jr
Bernard Hopkins
Sugar Ray Leonard
Joe Calzaghe
James Toney
Antonio Tarver

Mainstream Appeal

Sugar Ray Leonard (& it's not even close here)
Marvin Hagler
Roy Jones Jr
Chris Eubank (only in UK)
Bernard Hopkins
Antonio Tarver
James Toney
Joe Calzaghe
Pernell Whitaker

On the last one, it's Leonard in a far out lead, followed by Hagler, who's closely followed by Jones than the rest are all a similar level.

You really think Pernell was more Dominate then Jones was?

He maybe didn't dominate his opponents as much, but I felt his opposition was better & he did properly dominate the Lightweight & Welterweight division imo. Jones swept through to LHW, but I felt his opposition was too hideous at times there, which is what swayed me. Maybe opposition shouldn't come under dominance, but it's the same reason I have Calzaghe under Leonard despite him dominating SMW for so many years.

[DaxxKahn]

Ok, all of these are in order

In-ring Performance

Sugar Ray Leonard
Pernell Whitaker
Roy Jones Jr
Marvin Hagler
Bernard Hopkins
James Toney
Joe Calzaghe
Antonio Tarver
Chris Eubank

Achievements

Roy Jones Jr
Sugar Ray Leonard
Bernard Hopkins
Pernell Whitaker
Marvin Hagler
Joe Calzaghe
James Toney
Antonio Tarver
Chris Eubank

Dominance

Marvin Hagler
Pernell Whitaker
Roy Jones Jr
Bernard Hopkins
Sugar Ray Leonard
Joe Calzaghe
James Toney
Antonio Tarver

Mainstream Appeal

Sugar Ray Leonard (& it's not even close here)
Marvin Hagler
Roy Jones Jr
Chris Eubank (only in UK)
Bernard Hopkins
Antonio Tarver
James Toney
Joe Calzaghe
Pernell Whitaker

On the last one, it's Leonard in a far out lead, followed by Hagler, who's closely followed by Jones than the rest are all a similar level.

You really think Pernell was more Dominate then Jones was?

He maybe didn't dominate his opponents as much, but I felt his opposition was better & he did properly dominate the Lightweight & Welterweight division imo. Jones swept through to LHW, but I felt his opposition was too hideous at times there, which is what swayed me. Maybe opposition shouldn't come under dominance, but it's the same reason I have Calzaghe under Leonard despite him dominating SMW for so many years.

Fair call and one I agree with 100%

[Scrap]

X2