Cotto or froch?

[Hulk]

Ward might be better than floyd?? I think so. I don't think any super middle of any era in boxing history could beat him.

This is lunacy.

Roy Jones or James Toney at 168 would have handled Ward.

Andre Ward is very very good and a spoiler when he needs to be, but he's not an all time great by any means.

He could become one I suppose, but thats a long ways off.

As to the original thread question, Cotto by far. He's fought the best and he's beaten the best he's retired more men than social security !

[Dropanuke]

Ward might be better than floyd?? I think so. I don't think any super middle of any era in boxing history could beat him.

This is lunacy.

Roy Jones or James Toney at 168 would have handled Ward.

Andre Ward is very very good and a spoiler when he needs to be, but he's not an all time great by any means.

He could become one I suppose, but thats a long ways off.

As to the original thread question, Cotto by far. He's fought the best and he's beaten the best he's retired more men than social security !

Apollo creed lol

[rjj tszyu]

Hmmm. I never really thought about these 2 in the same sentence before. I'd say they are both very tough and share that quality evenly. As for boxing ability I've got to go Cotto, This is by no means any knock on Froch who is a great fighter!

[Dropanuke]

Why you ask?
Cos Leonard wouldnt last and I hate ward.

[p4pking]

Leonard was a welterweight Ward isn't anywhere near as athletic as Floyd, he is a very smart technical fighter but has to resort to roughhouse tactics all to often to be put in the same class. Toney or Jones jr would've beaten Ward no doubt in my mind, I think Calzaghe would've stood a great chance to also. I respect that Ward is great but he's crap to watch imo.

[erics44]

Leonard was a welterweight Ward isn't anywhere near as athletic as Floyd, he is a very smart technical fighter but has to resort to roughhouse tactics all to often to be put in the same class. Toney or Jones jr would've beaten Ward no doubt in my mind, I think Calzaghe would've stood a great chance to also. I respect that Ward is great but he's crap to watch imo.

calzaghe is the best supermiddle weight in history