IN THEIR PRIME AT 140, WHO WINS J.C.CHAVEZ OR AARON PRYOR?

[Purist]

JC Chavez....nothing hurt Chavez either! JC would rock his ass!!! I mean Mel Taylor beat on him for 15 pretty full rounds and JCC didn't have a mark on him and Taylor was SWOLE all to hell....anyone who would stand toe to toe with JC would get KILLED

1. Meldrick Taylor wasn't a power puncher
2. Meldrick Taylor wasn't a better boxer then Pryor
3. Meldrick Taylor didn't have as good a chin, heart, will, or determination as Aaron Pryor(and Meldrick had some of the best you could find in any fighter and still couldn't match a 5th what Pryor had)
4. Aaron Pryor wouldn't get hit as much as Taylor did either.

If that was Aaron Pryor punching on JCC from rounds 1 to 5 like Taylor did, the fight would have been stopped or Chavez would have already been out!

[chamiley]

JCC was great but he was certainly beatable, also pryor doesn't get credit for the boxer he was IMO in his prime Pryor was a better boxer and a brawler than JCC.

[atomic bull]

JC Chavez....nothing hurt Chavez either! JC would rock his a**!!! I mean Mel Taylor beat on him for 15 pretty full rounds and JCC didn't have a mark on him and Taylor was SWOLE all to hell....anyone who would stand toe to toe with JC would get KILLED

1. Meldrick Taylor wasn't a power puncher
2. Meldrick Taylor wasn't a better boxer then Pryor
3. Meldrick Taylor didn't have as good a chin, heart, will, or determination as Aaron Pryor(and Meldrick had some of the best you could find in any fighter and still couldn't match a 5th what Pryor had)
4. Aaron Pryor wouldn't get hit as much as Taylor did either.

If that was Aaron Pryor punching on JCC from rounds 1 to 5 like Taylor did, the fight would have been stopped or Chavez would have already been out!

No Taylor wasn't a power puncher, but by the time Taylor fought Chavez he had learned to settle down on his punches more instead of blinding fast pity-pat punches, like Floyd has become more flat footed , plant his feet and really rip his punches, and I think your really stretching it with Pryor being a better boxer than Taylor, you'd get alot of arguements with that.