McGirt is awful. Just look at the track record he has in recent fights. He frequently sends his fighters into the ring with a bad game plan and even worse he tells them to stick with it when it's not working. I didn't get a chance to see tonight's fight but just based on past fights

-Having Brewster start slow and try to establish the jab against a guy with superior boxing skills and a questionable chin instead of coming out guns blazing
-Having Gatti attempt to box with and fight a tactical fight against Mayweather
-Looking totally lost in Tarver-Hopkins and not having any useful advice for Tarver in the corner
-Malignaggi trying to stand and trade with Cotto way more than he should have

McGirt is completely living off of his work with Tarver leading up to the Roy Jones fights. Other than that I don't think his fighters have won any really big fights and he always tries to impose his style on fighters instead of working on emphasizing each fighter's own strengths