If old man B-Hop actually defeats JoeCal, could he make a case for #1 P4P?

[ICB]

In answer to the topis question yes it does.

Floyd , Hopkins and Joe are currently in the top 3 and if Hopkins beat joe or vice versa then theyd be number 1 .

Hopkins is number 4 on my list.

Cottos number 4 on mine . Who are ya top 3 then ?

1 Floyd Mayweather
2 Manny Pacquiao
3 Joe Calzaghe
4 Bernard Hopkins
5 Juan Manuel Marquez
6 Miguel Cotto
7 Israel Vasquez
8 Rafael Marquez
9 Ivan Calderon
10 Juan Diaz
11 Kelly Pavlik
12 Winky Wright
13 Ricky Hatton
14 Joan Guzman
15 Jermain Taylor
16 Shane Mosley
17 Mikkel Kessler
18 Christian Mijares
19 Chris John
20 Nonito Donaire

a good list man but don't you think Wlad Klitchsko has a case for top 20 especially if Chris John is in there ??

Wlad is just outside my top 20 and CC back.

[Wacko3205]

In answer to the topis question yes it does.

Floyd , Hopkins and Joe are currently in the top 3 and if Hopkins beat joe or vice versa then theyd be number 1 .

Hopkins is number 4 on my list.

Cottos number 4 on mine . Who are ya top 3 then ?

1 Floyd Mayweather
2 Manny Pacquiao
3 Joe Calzaghe
4 Bernard Hopkins
5 Juan Manuel Marquez
6 Miguel Cotto
7 Israel Vasquez
8 Rafael Marquez
9 Ivan Calderon
10 Juan Diaz
11 Kelly Pavlik
12 Winky Wright
13 Ricky Hatton
14 Joan Guzman
15 Jermain Taylor
16 Shane Mosley
17 Mikkel Kessler
18 Christian Mijares
19 Chris John
20 Nonito Donaire

a good list man but don't you think Wlad Klitchsko has a case for top 20 especially if Chris John is in there ??

Wlad is just outside my top 20 and CC back.

I know that it's your list...but I am curious as to why you have Chris John in there & not Wlad.

The reason that I ask? Wlad's faced a shit load more & has faced far better fighters & convincingly beat them...not like John...who did not convincingly beat Marquez & hasn't fought outside his home turf much...if ever. Can't recall that.

But anyways...I am curious...as hell.

Wlad, IWHO, has done a hell of a lot to warrant being in there...but then again...it is your list.

I have just recently started putting a lot more stock in Wlad...but if I'm honest...it's only because Vit the Klit's outta the picture now.

[Dark Lord Al]

I personally in his prime B-HOP was a better fighter than Calzaghe.
at 40 something im not sure Hopkins has the work rate to stay with Calzaghe. I know in the past ive slagged Calzaghe off , as i really dont like the guy , but he has proved hes a top fighter.
I dont think its an easy fight to pick , but id say with his work rate its 55%-45% in Calzaghe favour.
I' ll be rooting for Hopkins , but i think the winner goes to number 3 in the p4p rankings.

[Jimanuel Boogustus]

I just realised that if Pac beats Marquez, then on paper he beat Barrera, Morales AND Marquez TWICE!

Wow! Hows that for a legacy!

No wonder he wants to fight Light-Welters, the man must think he's Bruce Fukin Lee!

[Jimanuel Boogustus]

Oh yeah, back to the point...

If B-Hop wins, then he has to claim No. 3 spot. Regardless of what happens with Marquez/ Pacquiao

[GAME]

I just realised that if Pac beats Marquez, then on paper he beat Barrera, Morales AND Marquez TWICE!

Wow! Hows that for a legacy!

No wonder he wants to fight Light-Welters, the man must think he's Bruce Fukin Lee!

First Marquez fight was a draw mate

Floyd is still sitting pretty but im not sure a repeat win over Oscar whos lost more than hes won recently will be enough to reatin his status .