who wins a peak mike tyson or lennox lewis

[landmine950]

Well Tucker went 12 rounds with Lewis, and beat Oliver McCall who beat Lewis.
James "Bonecrusher" Smith and Tucker were strictly in safe ,survival mode against Tyson. Anyone will tell you it's almost impossible to KO a guy when he's in a defensive shell.
As for ALI?? ppplleeeeaaassseeeeeee.. If "Plodding & bobbing" Joe Frazier could go 45 rounds with Ali and have a win in 3 close fights
Imagine Mike catching Ali with his left hook....KO! not even close!
It would be a horrible missmatch!
Almost as bad as a beating received by,.. say Vitali Klitschko
if he foolishly tried to fight Nicolai Valuev

[SweetPea]

As for ALI?? ppplleeeeaaassseeeeeee.. If "Plodding & bobbing" Joe Frazier could go 45 rounds with Ali and have a win in 3 close fights
Imagine Mike catching Ali with his left hook....KO! not even close!
It would be a horrible missmatch!

Ok, at this point I assume you're just joking with me. But I'll play along...

First, the Ali who fought Frazier wasn't the prime Ali. Prime, pre-exile Ali wouldn't have lost to Frazier.
Second, if you think Tyson had a better left hook than Frazier, you're nuts.

[landmine950]

Enough with the ALI excuses!!! Not in his prime etc..
And YES! I think every punch Tyson threw is better than ANY punch Frazier (tried) to throw.

Ali in his peak prime was probably ALMOST as good as Trevor Berbick when he fought Tyson...and look what happened to HIM!

What does Muhammad Ali smell like depends..

[SweetPea]

Now who would win between Tyson and Valuev? This is what we're all dying to know, landmine.

[spekterscript]

Now who would win between Tyson and Valuev? This is what we're all dying to know, landmine.

LMAO

[lb4lb]

LETS NOT FORGET LENNOX GOT KNOCKED THE FOOK OUT BY OLIVER MCALL AND HASIM RAHMAN BOTH RIGHT HAND SHOTS TYSON HAD BIGGER RIGHT HAND POWER THAN THESE TWO PUT TOGETHER A PEAK TYSON WOULD HAVE EMBARRASED HIM

Buster Douglas never hit as hard as Lennox ever did either...

[landmine950]

Now who would win between Tyson and Valuev? This is what we're all dying to know, landmine.

I don't think Tyson would beat Valuev.
He's too short to hit him from outside and on the inside he'd look like this, minus 4 inches!!

BUT.. I think Big George would...George had REALLY heavy hands and was VERY VERY strong physically with great core strength.George could club with the caveman.

[SweetPea]

Are there any other heavyweights besides Foreman who could compete with the great Valuev??
Ali? Louis? Butterbean?

[ICB]

Lennox on top of his game that throws 30+ jabs a round wins. And you better believe he'd bring his top game against a prime Tyson.
Lennox takes him in the late rounds when Tyson's power isn't at it's sharpest.

IT's true Lewis WOULD throw 30 jabs a round, so since Tyson would KO his @ss in 30 seconds Lewis would have thrown 5 jabs and landed none.

Here's my logic.....
Larry Holmes...(best skilled big jabbing HW all time?)
vs
Micheal spinks......2 very close fights....

Mike Tyson
vs
Micheal Spinks......90 not even close seconds...

replace the name Larry "the Eastin Assasin"Holmes
with the name Lennox "the Canadian traitor" Lewis.

Remember Tyson against a quite skilled and good sized Trevor Berbick ?(who I picked to win by the way)

case closed..

I don't know if anyone survives,never mind beats a prime Tyson...
except of course ... NICOLAI VALUEV.

yea holmes was about 4 years past his prime when he fought spinks in holmes prime he would of beat tyson imo and berbick had been koed in 1 before tyson fight and plus berbick lost probably every round against holmes if he was lucky he got 2 rounds berbick was never that good plus it doesnt matter if holmes went 15 rounds with spinks twice holmes was past it plus totally different styles holmes was never 1 punch ko artist like tyson nor did he have fear factor on his opponents like tyson did to spinks


don't know if anyone survives,never mind beats a prime Tyson... well average james quick tillis managed to go distance and give tyson a tough fight

[spekterscript]

I am neither a Tyson or Lewis fan. I believe that any "Prime Tyson" vs "Prime Whoever" dreamfights have a built-in problem. Who was Prime Tyson? I am not alone in my belief (http://www.maxboxing.com/Groves/Groves0206a07.asp) (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cus_D%27Amato) that Tyson was at his best prior to the death of his adoptive father and trainer Cus D'Amato. However Tyson was still steam rolling bums at that time. Hard to know how great someone is at his/her prime when they are only fighting club level competition during that period of time. Cus also died before the
Quick Tillis fight. So those who reference Tillis are making the argument that D'Amato was a non-factor when it came to Tyson's performance in the ring. I'm not making a statement either way. I'm pointing out that I have no idea who would win prime vs prime for this very reason. I think that both were truly exceptional fighters and should go down in the top 20 of all time great HWs.

[landmine950]

Are there any other heavyweights besides Foreman who could compete with the great Valuev??
Ali? Louis? Butterbean?

NO







well.... maybe Larry Holmes. If he could deal with the reach issue his jab ,as always, would dominate

[DaxxKahn]

Well Tucker went 12 rounds with Lewis, and beat Oliver McCall who beat Lewis.
James "Bonecrusher" Smith and Tucker were strictly in safe ,survival mode against Tyson. Anyone will tell you it's almost impossible to KO a guy when he's in a defensive shell.
As for ALI?? ppplleeeeaaassseeeeeee.. If "Plodding & bobbing" Joe Frazier could go 45 rounds with Ali and have a win in 3 close fights
Imagine Mike catching Ali with his left hook....KO! not even close!
It would be a horrible missmatch!
Almost as bad as a beating received by,.. say Vitali Klitschko
if he foolishly tried to fight Nicolai Valuev

Are you on Crack.....At least if you say yes there is an excuse for these ramblings about Tyson beating Ali.....Ali was never counted out off his feet...NEVER!!!!! and he fought in the greatest era of heavyweights....

Liston could't not do it,,,,,Shavers could not do it,,,Foreman could not do it.....and TYSON WOULD NOT DO IT!!!!..........Foreman hit harder and so did Shavers

[DaxxKahn]

Now who would win between Tyson and Valuev? This is what we're all dying to know, landmine.

I don't think Tyson would beat Valuev.
He's too short to hit him from outside and on the inside he'd look like this, minus 4 inches!!

BUT.. I think Big George would...George had REALLY heavy hands and was VERY VERY strong physically with great core strength.George could club with the caveman.

Well it's nice to see you give one of the top 10 all time heavyweights a chance against the kid who grew up next to a nuclear power plant ( how else can you explain all that hair ).Big Geroge in his prime would take off Valuev's head.....S*** if Monte Barette ( how ever you spell it) can rock Valuev a Prime Foreman would have left him a dribbling fool in need of a breathing machine

[El Kabong]

Here's my logic.....

There's an oxymoron for you!











Leave it to a fucking canuck to fall in love with a fucking Yehti!


I can't wait til Valuev fights a live body and gets put to sleep........I'll dance on his fucking grave

[matteoz]

Lewis was not in his prime (state of mind & conditioning) for the first Rahman. Lewis had grown overly confident and lazy and side tracked with a movie I think. If you think the above would occur if Lewis ever fought Tyson you are mistaken.

you could use the same exscuse for tyson getting beat of buster douglas and tyson said that after that defeat he only ever fought for the money,but i dont think anyone could of done anything with tyson when he was in his prime.Look at when tyson fought bonecrusher,tucker,razzor ruddock,bruno,gilota,holmes,green,tillis,ribalta ect all similar fighters to lewis he,tyson,managed them all quite well weather it went the distance or not and it also showed that tyson in his day was very capable in going 12 rounds and not just crumbbling after 4, eg the tucker fight and the 2nd ruddock fight also berbick was a lewis type fighter obviously not as good and just look at the distruction of him.AWSOME.lewis no chance.