How about Hagler vs RJJ ?

[Taeth]

I am going to correct my statement because Roy wouldn't destroy Hagler, but he would win by a larger margin. I can't see Hagler beating Toney either.

[Preme]

I think roy would of beaten him pretty bad tbh...

I doubt he would of stopped him, i think it would of been a backfoot type of win for Roy, using his skills, speed and footwork to take it to a pretty one sided UD

[LegendBoxing65]

tooooooooooooooooooooo much speed hagler would get hit too many times..and yea marvin was as tough as they come and impossible to hurt with one punch..

but roy had just as much if not more power than hagler..and he'd hit hagler with too many punches and stop him late 10 or 11 maybe even 12..but hagler gets stopped

the funny thing about this is hagler beat a roy jones in 1977 by tko..but the roy we're speaking of stops him...

Hagler beat Roy Jones father in 1977.

[headson]

roy wins
no explanation

[headson]

roy wins
no explanation

[LegendBoxing65]

well I am not sure it is that easy with Roy winning. Hagler was a great fighter. I think Hagler is one of the best ever no doubt. The only complaint I have about him is how he fought all the welterweights moving up like Hearns, Leonard,Duran and would not move up and test himself against a bigger guy like they did. He should have taken on Michael Spinks. Just to do what those guys did. That is why I think Hearns, Leonard and Duran tested themselves more.

[ICB]

well I am not sure it is that easy with Roy winning. Hagler was a great fighter. I think Hagler is one of the best ever no doubt. The only complaint I have about him is how he fought all the welterweights moving up like Hearns, Leonard,Duran and would not move up and test himself against a bigger guy like they did. He should have taken on Michael Spinks. Just to do what those guys did. That is why I think Hearns, Leonard and Duran tested themselves more.

Quite a bit Hagler would have to move up though 2 weight divisions to fight Spinks.

[LegendBoxing65]

well I am not sure it is that easy with Roy winning. Hagler was a great fighter. I think Hagler is one of the best ever no doubt. The only complaint I have about him is how he fought all the welterweights moving up like Hearns, Leonard,Duran and would not move up and test himself against a bigger guy like they did. He should have taken on Michael Spinks. Just to do what those guys did. That is why I think Hearns, Leonard and Duran tested themselves more.

Quite a bit Hagler would have to move up though 2 weight divisions to fight Spinks.

yeah it would have been alot 15 pounds, but Hearns and Leonard moved up 13 to fight Marvin and Duran moved up 25 so I thought Marvin should have done it. Just to test his boxing skills and not his strength. I always thought he talked a little tough with them, and didn't do the same with Spinks. Spinks would have been tough for Marvin to beat. Spinks was 6 21/2 and had the Spinks Jinx.

[LegendBoxing65]

well I am not sure it is that easy with Roy winning. Hagler was a great fighter. I think Hagler is one of the best ever no doubt. The only complaint I have about him is how he fought all the welterweights moving up like Hearns, Leonard,Duran and would not move up and test himself against a bigger guy like they did. He should have taken on Michael Spinks. Just to do what those guys did. That is why I think Hearns, Leonard and Duran tested themselves more.

Quite a bit Hagler would have to move up though 2 weight divisions to fight Spinks.

yeah it would have been alot 15 pounds, but Hearns and Leonard moved up 13 to fight Marvin and Duran moved up 25 so I thought Marvin should have done it. Just to test his boxing skills and not his strength. I always thought he talked a little tough with them, and didn't do the same with Spinks. Spinks would have been tough for Marvin to beat. Spinks was 6 21/2 and had the Spinks Jinx.

[ICB]

Well if he could carry the weight well Hagler would stop Spinks.

[Bomp]

Good matchup. IMO a relentless pressure fighter like Hagler is exactly the type of fighter which could beat Roy. Who wins depends entirely at what weight though. If they fight at 165 or less I'd pick Hagler, over that weight Roy would just be able to keep him off to win a decision.

[LegendBoxing65]

Well if he could carry the weight well Hagler would stop Spinks.

Think so? I have a hard time figuring this fight out. If Hagler could take Spinks punch I think he could stop him also. Would have been nice to see him try.

[ChuckNorris]

I would go with RJJ UD

[ICB]

Well if he could carry the weight well Hagler would stop Spinks.

Think so? I have a hard time figuring this fight out. If Hagler could take Spinks punch I think he could stop him also. Would have been nice to see him try.

Spinks unorthdox style would give Hagler trouble but Hagler would win imo.

[Ring Rat]

hagler would lose a close match. or even maybe by mid to late knockout

roy jones at his best.. was a freak of nature