I also believe that Oscar won that fight.lolOriginally Posted by frozensolid_702
I also believe that Oscar won that fight.lolOriginally Posted by frozensolid_702
Ikariam
With all due respect, there is ABSOLUTELY no way in hell Mayweather lost to Oscar. He beat his ass from 8-12 and rocked him twice. I don't like the guys attitude but he's skilled and he beat Oscar.
Alot will be calrified over the coming months. If Mayweather beats Hatton well,which he should,there's no way ANYONE can disute his status as P4P number one(and I'm one of of PBF biggest critics)
Were you scoring the flurries that Oscar was throwing but missing ?? because Mayweather landed more cleaner blows and for certain won the fight no question i had Mayweather ahead by 3 rounds.Originally Posted by brucelee
If PAC earns the top spot by beating MAB then so be it. He's fought all the way from JR fly to Super Feather fighting bigger challenges than floydOriginally Posted by frozensolid_702
No prob bro. Cc backOriginally Posted by brucelee
I'll Cc you later Bruce. 'Cant give you 2 CCs in less than 24hrs.
Know i didn't oscar was past it when they fought and mayweather was in prime i would of like oscar to win but i didn't bet on it and no way oscar was prime age is not always the case i think oscar was a past it but that just me he sure wasn't prime thats all i got to say to you and oscar is not better skill wisae as toney and bernard are and rjj beat them both when they weren't old
I love how frozen thinks that PBF had better wins then RJJ did i find that very funny
Originally Posted by Mr140
As far as their entire resumes throughout their careers........... absolutely.
Jones had a few big names on his, where as Mayweather has a few big ones and a lot of really good ones.
Don't forget that Jones lost to journeyman Glen Johnson and mediocre Antonio Tarver a couple times
I'm not saying that it was Jones's fault, because there wasn't that much out there. But Mayweather has the far better resume............ which equates to better wins overall.
Do yourself a big favor and try not to refer to me later in threads because I will continue to make you look silly and ignorant.
Thanks
I don't think either Mayweather or Jones can say they have a far better resume than the other. It's close either way.
For what it's worth, Roy Jones' domination of James Toney is more impressive than any win on Mayweather's resume to this point.
Jones beat 2 ATG in B Hop and James Toney,in fact he beat Toney's ass easily. And he has more "good fighters" than Floyd on his resume. Tarver,Woods,Ruiz,Hill,Griffin,Macullum,Henshaw etc are better than Baldo,Sharmba,JLC,Hernandez,Chavez,Corrales.
Jones may very well have lost to Johnson and Tarver but that was after he went to HW and beat Ruiz for a portion of the HW crown,which was an amazing feat.
If we are talking the best wins then RJJ no doubt.Originally Posted by frozensolid_702
Mayweather's best wins
Jesus Chavez
Diego Corrales
Jose Luis Castillo
Zab Judah
Carlos Baldomir
Oscar Delahoya
Genaro Hernandez
Angel Manfredy
Carlos Hernandez
Phillip N'dou
DeMarcus Corley
Arturo Gatti
Roy Jones best wins
Thomas Tate
Thulani Malinga
Vinny Pazienza
James Toney
Merqui Sosa
Eric Lucas
Mike McCallum
Montell Griffin
Virgil Hill
Reggie Johnson
Julio Cesar Gonzalez
Glen Kelly
Anthony Hanshaw
John Ruiz
Clinton Woods
And Hill, Hopkins Toney, McCallum are all HOF's im sorry Mayweather has beaten good opposition but he isn't on Jones level quite yet for best wins.
Originally Posted by ICE COLD BOXING
Factor in Jones's losses and add a victory over Hatton (when it happens) and Mayweathers has the better resume
I don't think so forgetting the losses if we are talking best wins then even a win over Hatton would not put him above Jones beating 4 Hall Of Famers.Originally Posted by frozensolid_702
I don't think you can use Jones' losses as the basis for an argument for Mayweather having a better resume. Jones was in his mid-late 30's when he lost to Tarver and Johnson. That's an age that Mayweather has not reached yet.Originally Posted by frozensolid_702
If we're comparing resumes, we should be comparing Jones thru age 30 with Mayweather thru age 30 (his current age). Jones' win over Toney is more impressive than anything Mayweather has done to this point.
There are currently 1 users browsing this thread. (0 members and 1 guests)
Bookmarks