The Greatest of All Time in each individual division

[BIG H]

CC - for the lists people - interesting stuff

[The Whirlwind]

LIGHTWELTER= RICKY HATTON
WELTERWEIGHT = PRETTY BOY FLOYD
LIGHTHEAVY WEIGHT = JOE CALZAGHE
CRUISERWEIGHT = BILLY CONN
HEAVYWEIGHT= JOHN RUIZ

[Poweraxe]

holy shnikeys someone just said Sven Ottke

yeah sorry mate, but i think he was a very underated defensive fighter. Yes he was gifted a few decisions but he basicly did rule that division. I would have said Joe C but he's not retired yet and when he does he will defo be the best of all time in that division.

[BIG H]

holy shnikeys someone just said Sven Ottke

yeah sorry mate, but i think he was a very underated defensive fighter. Yes he was gifted a few decisions but he basicly did rule that division. I would have said Joe C but he's not retired yet and when he does he will defo be the best of all time in that division.

Ruled the divsion hahahahahaha

I must've missed all those big unification bouts

[raleights]

only regional pride could make someone mention Sven Ottke in this thread...

[Poweraxe]

holy shnikeys someone just said Sven Ottke

yeah sorry mate, but i think he was a very underated defensive fighter. Yes he was gifted a few decisions but he basicly did rule that division. I would have said Joe C but he's not retired yet and when he does he will defo be the best of all time in that division.

Ruled the divsion hahahahahaha

I must've missed all those big unification bouts

hey come on man, the guy had 21 straight defences, retired undefeated aqnd he did have a unification match with Byron Mitchell. I just can't see anyone at that divsion who accomplished more that's all.

[raleights]

He actually lost the fight against Mitchell and received the gift decision, pretty much common knowledge. Then went on to avoiding Joe C. (another unification). To each his own though

[Poweraxe]

i know man, thats why i said he was gifted decisions ( i mean he never fought outta germany did he?) i dont love the guy or anything, but he's retired now and has the best record on paper.

[The Whirlwind]

Lewis was BIGGER than anyone Ali ever fought, he had hellacious power, and he used his size as well if not better than Ali.

What about Ernie Terrell? An inch taller than Lewis at 6'6".

[BIG H]

Bump

[LBSCFC]

I did this about a year ago, but I thought it would be interesting as it looks at different weights to the usual ones we always talk about

I haven't included every single division just the ones I consider to be the main ones.

See what you think and what your opinions are.


Flyweight - Jimmy Wilde

Bantamweight - Carlos Zarate

Featherweight - Wille Pepp

Superfeather - Alexis Arguello

Lightweight - Roberto Duran

Lightwelter - Aaron Pryor

Welterweight - Sugar Ray Robinson

Middleweight - Marvin Hagler

Light Heavyweight - Roy Jones

Cruiserweight - Evander Holyfiled

Heavyweight - Muhammad Ali

Flyweight - Jimmy Wilde

Bantamweight - Carlos Zarate

Featherweight - Sandy Saddler

Super Featherweight - Julio Cesar Chavez

Lighweight - Roberto Duran

Light Welter - Aaron Pryor

Welter - S R Robinson (his absolute peak)

Light Middle - Thomas Hearns (Thought that was his best weight)

Middleweight - Carlos Monzon

Super Middle - Roy Jones

Light Heavyweight - Ezzard Charles

Cruiserweight - Carlos De Leon - only joking theres only one as thats the real deal

heavyweight - Muhammad Ali (pips Louis due to the competition he fought)

[landmine950]

As always the ALI teabaggers are out in force.

[amat]

As always the ALI teabaggers are out in force.

Where? He ruled the division fighting EVERYONE and beating all of them in the strongest period in HW history.

[landmine950]

As always the ALI teabaggers are out in force.

Where? He ruled the division fighting EVERYONE and beating all of them in the strongest period in HW history.

Sorry I couldn'y understand what you were saying.....Please try and stop licking ALI's nuts while your talking...

Lost to norton,fraizer,spinks,holmes,berbick
Dude.. he lost to a guy who only had 6 wins!!!! and a loss!! its a joke!!!

CAN you imagine if a top heavy today wanted to fight a 6-1 guy!?
and then claim its a big deal!!? three time world champion!! whooooo!
I dunno if ALI is in the top 10 all time heavyweights...
Please don't argue with me...just go back to licking his nuts.

[amat]

As always the ALI teabaggers are out in force.

Where? He ruled the division fighting EVERYONE and beating all of them in the strongest period in HW history.

Sorry I couldn'y understand what you were saying.....Please try and stop licking ALI's nuts while your talking...

Lost to norton,fraizer,spinks,holmes,berbick
Dude.. he lost to a guy who only had 6 wins!!!! and a loss!! its a joke!!!

CAN you imagine if a top heavy today wanted to fight a 6-1 guy!?
and then claim its a big deal!!? three time world champion!! whooooo!
I dunno if ALI is in the top 10 all time heavyweights...
Please don't argue with me...just go back to licking his nuts.

Honestly, I don't know if you're joking or not. For your sake I hope you are.

Sugar Ray Robinson fought a guy with 2 wins in 65. What a bum that guy was
Duran fought a guy with 6 wins towards the end of his career. What a jobber Roberto was

Hell, I'd rather see a washed up heavy fight then a guy win a belt from an old John Ruiz and then defend against Beck, Barret and McCline.