MAB vs Morales: who deserves more praise?

[Howlin Mad Missy]

for me jmm already has a W against pac and as long as the good version of jmm shows up he'll do it again.

edited to add & I think it shows the respect the 3 mexicans had for each others ability that they held off from fighting each other until later in their careers. Always fun to speculate when fighters don't meet at their prime.

[GAME]

Barrera no doubt
Morales quit in the 3rd round still in his 20's . Barrera gritted it out for 12 when he was several years past his best

[donnydarkoIRL]

Entering this fight i was really swingin towards Barrera, i thought that after the original loss to Pac and after the frustration of the loss i thought he'd be well up for it.
I believed that these factors were going to inspire Marco and drive him on to put on a gritty and aggresive performance. However, having watched the fight i had to feel disappointed, not that he lost, but the nature of the loss. The tenacity i had expected was absent, he boxed well no doubt, but he never applied himself sufficiently or tried to dominate Pacquiao in any way. It is this factor I feel, cost him the JMM fight also.
As a result i feel it is time to say goodbye to Marco, its his time to retire.
I'd just like to add; I feel it's a testament to Marco as a fighter that when he got old, tired and nearly shot that he could go the distance against to fighters who are among today's p4p elite and would be among the elite of any era.

[Julius Rain]

Barrera no doubt
Morales quit in the 3rd round still in his 20's . Barrera gritted it out for 12 when he was several years past his best

Morales didn't quit, he just couldn't get up when pac put him down for the last time. There are times when a fighter is dropped, he may look aware and fine but his legs are heavy and are tightening and the brain sustain to much vibration from volume of punches it at times lock downs muscles. it happens more so with the lower half of a fighter, another good example would be jaca, when jmm knock him out he was alert and look fined but couldn't make no effort to get up. Just like how eric couldn't make any effort to get up anymore, If you see when he finally got up after the tenth and the fight is over, the ref had to catch eric from falling again. Morales, i know would never quit if he still had more to give, he just couldn't and he knew it thats why he signal no I can't towards his father.

[donnydarkoIRL]

^
The above is true.
See Julius i couldn last very long without agreein with somethin you said

[Julius Rain]

^
The above is true.
See Julius i couldn last very long without agreein with somethin you said

[Jimanuel Boogustus]

Na i totally disagree. When a fighter nods/ shakes head/ winks at corner you know its his choice to quit. A submission of sorts.

My example would be Ray olivera agianst Hatton

Definately NOT Castillo v Hatton

[donnydarkoIRL]

Na i totally disagree. When a fighter nods/ shakes head/ winks at corner you know its his choice to quit. A submission of sorts.

My example would be Ray olivera agianst Hatton

Definately NOT Castillo v Hatton

Yeah thats a fair point, but i reckon with Erik his shke was more of "i cant fight, im not able."

[Julius Rain]

Na i totally disagree. When a fighter nods/ shakes head/ winks at corner you know its his choice to quit. A submission of sorts.

My example would be Ray olivera agianst Hatton

Definately NOT Castillo v Hatton

no actually he had no choice, if he would of been able to get up do you think the fight would of turned out any different. eric had no choice he knew it thats why he made no effort. a fighting quiting is more like tyson on his stole, if you watch when the fight was done with and eric finally can get up, he almost falls back down but the ref hellps him.

[Jimanuel Boogustus]

Na i totally disagree. When a fighter nods/ shakes head/ winks at corner you know its his choice to quit. A submission of sorts.

My example would be Ray olivera agianst Hatton

Definately NOT Castillo v Hatton

no actually he had no choice, if he would of been able to get up do you think the fight would of turned out any different. eric had no choice he knew it thats why he made no effort. a fighting quiting is more like tyson on his stole, if you watch when the fight was done with and eric finally can get up, he almost falls back down but the ref hellps him.

Na seriously, i see the ref escorting Morales but all good refs do that. Dont know about the 'he almost falls back down' part though

You know what, upon re-watching that fight (without focusing heavily on the fact that Morales was completely shot) if Morales had of held back in that fight, not being so wreckless... He might of conned Manny out of a win.

Couldawouldashoulda

[donnydarkoIRL]

Na i totally disagree. When a fighter nods/ shakes head/ winks at corner you know its his choice to quit. A submission of sorts.

My example would be Ray olivera agianst Hatton

Definately NOT Castillo v Hatton

no actually he had no choice, if he would of been able to get up do you think the fight would of turned out any different. eric had no choice he knew it thats why he made no effort. a fighting quiting is more like tyson on his stole, if you watch when the fight was done with and eric finally can get up, he almost falls back down but the ref hellps him.

Na seriously, i see the ref escorting Morales but all good refs do that. Dont know about the 'he almost falls back down' part though

You know what, upon re-watching that fight (without focusing heavily on the fact that Morales was completely shot) if Morales had of held back in that fight, not being so wreckless... He might of conned Manny out of a win.

Couldawouldashoulda

But then Morales wouldnt have been himself would he?

[Jimanuel Boogustus]

Touche

[donnydarkoIRL]

Morales was, is and always will be the same. Even up a weight against Diaz he went all out, attacking all night long.

[Jimanuel Boogustus]

Morales was, is and always will be the same. Even up a weight against Diaz he went all out, attacking all night long.

Ya i have a saying for Him and Barrera it goes; Barrera was the fighter who loved to box but Morales was the boxer who loved a fight

I havent seen the Diaz fight yet. Did Diaz deserve the win?

[brucelee]

Morales was, is and always will be the same. Even up a weight against Diaz he went all out, attacking all night long.

Ya i have a saying for Him and Barrera it goes; Barrera was the fighter who loved to box but Morales was the boxer who loved a fight

I havent seen the Diaz fight yet. Did Diaz deserve the win?

Let me interrupt your nice discussion with Hitmandonny by answering your question...... definitely Diaz did not deserve the win. Morales was robbed of that important fight.... the way I saw it. Watch it and you will agree with me.