Ali's legacy had he retired after beating Foreman

[Sleepwalker]

As far as his legacy in boxing is concerned, an immediate retirement after beating Foreman would have been Jordan-like. Going out of top with everyone's last memory of him was out smarting and KO'ing a giant who was considered unbeatable. Even without the Thrilla in Manila on Ali's resume, he still may have been an even bigger legend. He successfully defended his title, but it wasn't in the Ali fashion we were accustomed to in the 60s.

From a financial perspective, he really didn't have to continue fighting even if money was an issue. If his management team had any real business foresight, they would have realized that he would have been able to make millions off his name alone, especially considering his magnetic personality. Did Don King have Ali under contract for x-many fights? Idk

And don't get me started on his health. That's another well established topic on its own.

[X]

Maybe, but I do think the third Frazier fight probably added even more to his legend.

Prior to the Foreman fight (with only one or two exceptions, and those were after his comeback too) he was pretty unbeatable and. Ours do what he liked in the ring.

It was only later that he demonstrated what a great chin and heart he had. I think those things add hugely to his legacy.

[Britkid]

And to further backup X's points; the end of his career made him seem even more human, as there was a real emotional attachment, that perhaps has not been seen in boxing since, to them last few fights, even the tragic ones...

[TitoFan]

Yeah.... the perfect time would've been after the Thrilla in Manila. Closed the cycle on Joe, with a payback victory in what is now regarded one of the best HW championship fights of all time.

[Master]

Ali also beat Spinks so became the first champion to win the title 3 times which I know in not great in the gran scheme of things.

Ali fought on because he felt obliged to all his hanger ons when they should have looked after him and told him to stop.

[brocktonblockbust]

Ali needed to avenge Norton and Frazier. So after Foreman, he should have hung up the gloves.

Ali didn't need Wepner's 306 rabbit punches. Didn't need Shavers' deadly brain damaging bombs, didn't need Ron Lyle, etc.. Poor judgement. Ferdie Pacheco was so disgusted HE QUIT the team.

[johnsebastianmiran]

Between George Foreman and the Thriller in Manila there should have bee no other fights and that includes the third one with Norton. Picture Ali in a Porsche going 80 miles an hour. He should have avoided the last fight with Norton because it a accomplished nothing. This is the same Norton who froze after George's first right hand. This is the Norton who knew whether Shavers and Cooney had their boot laces tied. Ali was definitely old in that fight and there was a great deal of questioning about that scoring in Yankee Stadium. That is what I thought and I am an Ali fan. Foreman and Frazier should have been his last opponents.

[brocktonblockbust]

The light hitting Leon Spinks contributed a lot of brain damage to Ali's condition because he landed something like 400 punches in that first fight

[johnsebastianmiran]

Have you ever noticed that most light punchers are fair body punchers? Retired fighters have always alluded to the fact that it is more merciful to be defeated early by a heavy handed puncher than round after round by a medium to light powered boxer puncher. He is not in there to get hurt but he has to gain respect and if your missing and frustrated it only gives him the opportunity to strike again and again thus his hand is up after the tally. Light punchers work on their skill but there are the few that are lucky like Leon who was exposed by the old man in their rematch. As Ali said, you borrowed my crown and now I have it back. Ali was not a heavy puncher but his judgement in fighting Holmes who was a better puncher with speed than the others out there was piss poor. The rest has been debated to death.

[Master]

Have you ever noticed that most light punchers are fair body punchers? Retired fighters have always alluded to the fact that it is more merciful to be defeated early by a heavy handed puncher than round after round by a medium to light powered boxer puncher. He is not in there to get hurt but he has to gain respect and if your missing and frustrated it only gives him the opportunity to strike again and again thus his hand is up after the tally. Light punchers work on their skill but there are the few that are lucky like Leon who was exposed by the old man in their rematch. As Ali said, you borrowed my crown and now I have it back. Ali was not a heavy puncher but his judgement in fighting Holmes who was a better puncher with speed than the others out there was piss poor. The rest has been debated to death.

Sweat Pea was a very good body puncher so you are right.

[johnsebastianmiran]

I almost forgot about Sweet Pea because the words Defense Master doesn't quite describe his monster skill. The Cuban found out not to make Sweet Pea mad either. He had a punch hidden in his arsenal too. He was fun!

[Master]

I almost forgot about Sweet Pea because the words Defense Master doesn't quite describe his monster skill. The Cuban found out not to make Sweet Pea mad either. He had a punch hidden in his arsenal too. He was fun!

Sweat Pea was losing that fight so had to go for it. It was a brutal knockout.

Ali was not known as a body puncher.

[brocktonblockbust]

Understatement of 2016. I don't even remember one single body punch Ali ever threw. Must've really influenced Holmes cyz HE hardly threw any downstairs either!

[Mr140]

Well to be fair i do not feel his loses in his older years effect him to much. I mean i do not blame Holyfeild when he was 40 and older just would not make much sense. Very few heavyweight quite at the right time the only one i know that did was Lewis he left at the best time he could.

[brocktonblockbust]

Well to be fair i do not feel his loses in his older years effect him to much. I mean i do not blame Holyfeild when he was 40 and older just would not make much sense. Very few heavyweight quite at the right time the only one i know that did was Lewis he left at the best time he could.

The Brockton Blockbuster