So I was thinking about my p4p list. The longer I watch boxing, the less I like the p4p list. There are a lot of issues with it, especially the problem that a fighter moves up or down disregarding bad decisions. Also, circumstances in a fight (weight difference for example) affect how wins and losses are viewed. I will try to rank from what I see and not what the judges have given fighters.
There are three lists. Those who I believe are elite, those who are great, and those on the cusp of greatness.
Elite
Crawford, Inoue, Usyk
Great
Canelo, Loma, Lopez, GGG, Estrada, Spence
On the cusp
Charlo bros, Tank, Chocolatito, Taylor, Berchelt, Pacquiao
On the outside
M. Garcia (I still think he should be a top fighter but he just doesn’t really fight)
Bookmarks