Where Is Floyd Mayweather Ranked In All Time Listings Now He Has Retired?

[Tysonbruno]

I think he has to be top 15

[BoxingGorilla]

I think he has to be top 15

I was going to say top 25.

[gudnite vienna]

hard to say... i will say this he could of been top 10 without doubt if he would of continued fighting for about another 3 years and beat everyone he could of.

[CutMeMick]

Just taking at shot at it I would say 25-35...
Somewhere around there.

[Thread Stealer]

I think very highly of Floyd as a boxer, but top 15 is too high IMO.

I'll need some more time to compare different fighters and read some more, but I'm guessing right now he's in the 40s.

[GRBOXINGFAN]

Top 20, but he'll fight again.

[Dark Lord Al]

Top 20
But could be higher

[Thread Stealer]

I wonder when he'll un-retire.

I had thought it was a publicity stunt/negotiating ploy for the rematch with DLH, but the 90 day deadline is getting pretty close and GBP says the Sept 20 date is scrapped and they're doing a Sept 13 PPV card instead.

I say Cotto beats Margarito and then if he fights DLH in December and wins.

HBO will offer a huge payday at a bored Mayweather, who misses the attention and realizes he's not as popular as he had hoped, and comes back.

[SE7EN]

top 20

[killersheep]

I'm thinking around 30ish, talent wise he's up in my top 5, but his competition drops him down on my list.

[Put Em' Up]

Just taking at shot at it I would say 25-35...
Somewhere around there.

I was thinking the same thing. Yes he was a great fighters and yes he was skilled but there have been a lot more guys who accomplished more then he did. Level of competition, era they reigned and so on that deserve the nod above Floyd. There are also a lot of guys that were more skilled then Floyd (Sorry all you PBF fans).

[CutMeMick]

Just taking at shot at it I would say 25-35...
Somewhere around there.

I was thinking the same thing. Yes he was a great fighters and yes he was skilled but there have been a lot more guys who accomplished more then he did. Level of competition, era they reigned and so on that deserve the nod above Floyd. There are also a lot of guys that were more skilled then Floyd (Sorry all you PBF fans).

I agree, and my comment is just taking a shot at it.
Who knows might be higher, might be lower. I was just shooting for a number.

[SigmaMu]

I think he has to be top 15

I was going to say top 25.

I was going to check the bottom of my shoe, ahhhh... there it is.

[bambamdaddio]

A deffo top 20 for me at this stage, but I think as with any of the greats, legendary status becomes clearer to view & assess in retrospect, say at least a 5 to 10 year period after there last fight.....

[Tins06]

Top 20-25's....But if he sticks around and takes out Cotta he'll shoot right up if you ask me.

I think Mayweather needs to learn he doesn't decide how good he is.

We do.