Saddoboxing Official Ratings

[CFH]

I think Gonzalez should drop two spots.

I really want to see Gonzalez - Molitor sometime soon. I think it's a good match for both guys. Molitor doesn't have the power to bother Gonzalez, but I think Gonzalez' power would bother the Canadian.

[Violent Demise]

Nishioka should take Gonzalez old spot at 9th. Gonzalez should drop to 10th. Who ever is at 10th goes into the pool

[Spicoli]

I'd go with Rafa def. in the pool at 126......The question of Gonzalez comes down to the merits and ability of Munroe who holds 10th really,should Jhonny only drop 1 spot and Nishioka in his old spot...he's bumped.I'll plead ignorance on Munroe,dont recall seeing him but on paper going 12 vs. a 3-2?How good is he?Off the top I say Gonzalez only drops 1.

[JazMerkin]

Oh I thought we would have a free spot at 10 if we dropped Jhonny. In that case I change my vote to him dropping 2 places, Munroe hasn't done anything worthy of being dropped, whereas Gonzalez has by getting KO'd.

[CFH]

Oh I thought we would have a free spot at 10 if we dropped Jhonny. In that case I change my vote to him dropping 2 places, Munroe hasn't done anything worthy of being dropped, whereas Gonzalez has by getting KO'd.

That's how I feel as well. Had Gonzalez lost a close decision I would be fine with him only dropping one spot, but he got knocked out in the third round. Whether or not he was ahead after 2 rounds is immaterial in my mind.

[Galaxy]

Oh I thought we would have a free spot at 10 if we dropped Jhonny. In that case I change my vote to him dropping 2 places, Munroe hasn't done anything worthy of being dropped, whereas Gonzalez has by getting KO'd.

That's how I feel as well. Had Gonzalez lost a close decision I would be fine with him only dropping one spot, but he got knocked out in the third round. Whether or not he was ahead after 2 rounds is immaterial in my mind.

Yeah I just realized there wouldn't be a vacancy

current vote 3-3

[JazMerkin]

I'd go with Rafa def. in the pool at 126......The question of Gonzalez comes down to the merits and ability of Munroe who holds 10th really,should Jhonny only drop 1 spot and Nishioka in his old spot...he's bumped.I'll plead ignorance on Munroe,dont recall seeing him but on paper going 12 vs. a 3-2?How good is he?Off the top I say Gonzalez only drops 1.

I've seen a fair bit of his career & I would say he's better than Bernard Dunne who we've ranked, although he has a tendency to box to victories rather than trying to KO people, although he can coast to a UD if the guy is not on his level as in the last fight, but that's no reason that he should be dropped, and his only loss was a pretty shoddy robbery. Looking at it objectively it would seem wrong not to drop a guy who was badly KO'd just because he's a more popular fighter. If it had happened against Juanma or Caballero it might be understandable to drop him just one, but not against a guy who we didn't even have ranked

[killersheep]

Well Super Bantam is hitmanhatton's division, we need to get him to break the tie.

[Spicoli]

Well Super Bantam is hitmanhatton's division, we need to get him to break the tie.

Maybe we should have the same rules applied to the managers .Staying active in here and such.

[Violent Demise]

Well Super Bantam is hitmanhatton's division, we need to get him to break the tie.

I rather not have to read his lame ass reasons on why he thinks Hatton deserves the spot

[Galaxy]

Well Super Bantam is hitmanhatton's division, we need to get him to break the tie.

Maybe we should have the same rules applied to the managers .Staying active in here and such.

Yeah I totally agree, managers should be in here weekly

A reply from BoomBoom to a message I sent in response to Gonzalez dropping 2 spots & John/ Juarez being for the championship:

Hey Galaxy,
Yes and Yes. Gonzalez isnt quite top 10 anymore imo though I think hell be back

Makes the vote 4 for 2 spots, 3 for 1 spot regarding Gonzalez

5-1 for John/ Juarez being for the championship

[killersheep]

Well Super Bantam is hitmanhatton's division, we need to get him to break the tie.

Maybe we should have the same rules applied to the managers .Staying active in here and such.

Yeah I totally agree, managers should be in here weekly

A reply from BoomBoom to a message I sent in response to Gonzalez dropping 2 spots & John/ Juarez being for the championship:

Hey Galaxy,
Yes and Yes. Gonzalez isnt quite top 10 anymore imo though I think hell be back

Makes the vote 4 for 2 spots, 3 for 1 spot regarding Gonzalez

5-1 for John/ Juarez being for the championship

Ok then, works for me.

[killersheep]

Ok updated 122 and 126, fixed the broken link for 108.

Updated Cruiser to show BoomBoom has retired as manager, he will have a vote if we have a tie on anything.

[killersheep]

We have manager openings for Cruiser, Light Heavy and Middle.

If you want a say in the rankings, apply on here, and the current judges will vote if you qualify.

I also think we should start making scouting reports on here.
By this I mean if you are watching a fight on tv and see someone with promise, mention them on here. That way the rest of us can keep an eye out.

[CFH]

We have manager openings for Cruiser, Light Heavy and Middle.

If you want a say in the rankings, apply on here, and the current judges will vote if you qualify.

I also think we should start making scouting reports on here.
By this I mean if you are watching a fight on tv and see someone with promise, mention them on here. That way the rest of us can keep an eye out.

IF no one else steps forward, I'll do MW. I'd rather just focus on one division though.