When he cant even dominate the middleweight division. I thought P4P means your skill level translates to beating up bigger guys than you like what Mayweather, Marquez, DelaHoya, Duran and Pacquiao did in their boxing career moved up in weight and dominate. I would consider Canelo a P4P guy if he beats a top supermiddlweight I guess and this applies to Golovkin too even I am biased towards him since he is one of my current faves right now.