Manny Pacquiao vs. Roy Jones Jr, who ranks higher all-time?

[VG_Addict]

Both have insane athleticism, and both did things in the sport that nobody has done before or since. But who ranks higher on the ATG list?

[Primo Carnera]

Roy Jones Jr.

[Master]

Roy Jones is the best pound for pound boxer I have seen in my life time. Better than sweat pea, PAC man, loma, JCC etc

[Spicoli]

Manny . Competition is consistently insane as is longevity. Think he's a more fundamentally sound fighter. Has been planked under a half dozen times. Roy takes the explosiveness all time reflex phenom title though.

[NoSavingByTheBell]

very tough question.... did RJJs aura get tainted when he got KOed too much at the end? SHould we consider that part? Whereas Pac opnly got sparked that one time.... Pac maybe had better competition...... no not maybe, definitely.... I cant decide, really. RJJ going up to heavy and winning...

I'll go with RJJ, but it was a very tough call, and Im not sure 100%.

[Master]

very tough question.... did RJJs aura get tainted when he got KOed too much at the end? SHould we consider that part? Whereas Pac opnly got sparked that one time.... Pac maybe had better competition...... no not maybe, definitely.... I cant decide, really. RJJ going up to heavy and winning...

I'll go with RJJ, but it was a very tough call, and Im not sure 100%.

Anything after the ko by Tarver does not take away the brilliance of Roy Jones. He beat prime Toney, Hopkins, cleaned up light heavyweight and beat 1 heavyweight titlist.