P4P vs P4P?

[imp]

Think of your top x3 P4P fighters.

Now let those same x3 fight each other in their primes at the same fantasy weights.

Who wins?

My top x3:-

1. Usyk
2. Crawford
3. Inoue

The winner after fighting each other:-

1. Crawford
2. Usyk
3. Inoue

(I’m still unsure about Crawford/Usyk)

[Master]

Show your working out Imp.

How did you come to the order

1. Crawford
2. Usyk
3. Inoue

[erics44]

crawford beats Usyk
usyk beats Inoue
crawford beat usyk

kin el Master, that wasnt hard

[imp]

crawford beats Usyk
usyk beats Inoue
crawford beat usyk

kin el Master, that wasnt hard

This

[Beanz]

The thing is they are never going to fight the same way at different weights and if Inoue carries that power up with him it becomes the great leveller.

[Primo Carnera]

The thing is they are never going to fight the same way at different weights and if Inoue carries that power up with him it becomes the great leveller.

The most important thing about Inoue going up the weights isn’t so much if he carries that power, I would say if he’s got that power he probably will carry it up another weight or two because he’s naturally powerful.
I think it’s more about if he can keep taking the power from opponents as he moves up.
Fucking absolutely wonderful specimen.

[iwng100]

Right now :

1. Inoue
2. Crawford
3. Usyk

After fighting each other if they are shrink/grow at the same size :

The Monster stops Usyk.
Bud embarrass Usyk.
Bivol win by wide UD against Usyk.
Beterbiev put Usyk into the coma.
Other fighters like Tank or Shakur might beat Usyk.
.............................................
Loma wouldn't fight Usyk for obvious reasons.
...............................
...............................
Usyk would beat Ginger though.

[Alpha]

Usyk
Inoue
Crawford

[Master]

Proportionately p4p Inoue would have the power, Crawford the adaptability and Usyk the skill/IQ.

Inoue has probably levelled off at his current weight, Crawford was better at the lower weights and over reaching, Usyk has grown into the division and beating bigger fighters because he is too skilled for them. They are dumb in comparison.

Inoue KO Usyk round 11.
Inoue SD Crawford
Crawford UD Usyk

1. Inoue
2. Crawford
3. Usyk

[erics44]

Proportionately p4p Inoue would have the power, Crawford the adaptability and Usyk the skill/IQ.

Inoue has probably levelled off at his current weight, Crawford was better at the lower weights and over reaching, Usyk has grown into the division and beating bigger fighters because he is too skilled for them. They are dumb in comparison.

Inoue KO Usyk round 11.
Inoue SD Crawford
Crawford UD Usyk

1. Inoue
2. Crawford
3. Usyk

id like this to happen