Thread: WHO IS MOST OVERATED

i gotta go with calzaghe

Originally Posted by SalTheButcher

i gotta go with calzaghe

Then you just don't fwockin know.

Judah is by far the most overratted out of that bunch...but you refused to list him because you knew that we'd all vote for his ass!

actually i only put the undefeated guys who are considered to be the best

Taylor for me - guess we'll find out in a few weeks

Originally Posted by SalTheButcher

i gotta go with calzaghe

Hell I dont know Joe showed me alot against Lacy but I believe in my Heart of hearts if Joe moves up to light Heavyweight RJJ will take him I think Roy would not fear Joe's power as much, and will capitilaize more when Joe hurt...

This fight Will have an interesting Dynamic to it, if Roy Beats Joe then The Roy hating will stop and he can call it quits and go out on a positive note being once elevated again cause of all Joe's Hype(deserved or not)

If Joe wins than it does nothing for Joe since everyone thinks Roy is damaged goods anyway and should of called it qiuts last year

The Funny thing is No one has a blueprint to defeat Roy!!!Think about it Tarver is just not a good matchup for Roy and Got Lucky with the KO Johnson came in at an extremely good time to press the situation and get Roys ass again while he was still down mentally, now back to Tarver bad matchup again ROy beat Roy the third time He still was beating Tarver to the Punch and was getting to Antonio but would not capatilize on it and settled with just surviving.

Bottom line Roy can and would beat Joe!!

I dont want to take anything away from Glen Johnson!! just piss poor timing for Roy, Glen has just turned into a relentless freak of nature unfortunately for Roy he decided to Revamp himself and have his coming out party the nite of there fight!!!

Hard to choose from that list,right now,would have to say Taylor but I'll look a foll if he beats Winky(yeah right!). Hatton needs time to grow,why is Calzaghe even there and Lil Floyd being there is a disgrace!!

Originally Posted by The Game

Hard to choose from that list,right now,would have to say Taylor but I'll look a foll if he beats Winky(yeah right!). Hatton needs time to grow,why is Calzaghe even there and Lil Floyd being there is a disgrace!!

calzaghe is there cuz his biggest win was against somebody who JUST MAY have been ALL hype

mayweather is there cuz people think he is the greatest ever, and he is not even the greatest alive

Oh so you mean who is over hyped,well Mayweather if you go by the people on this forum,I mean people have him in there with SRR,SRL,Hagerl,Duran-HELLLL NO!! Not yet anyway. Clazghe has fought all the dangers presented to him and he MADE lacey look that bad,I think Jeff is much better than that,it's just Calzaghe is soooo far ahead of everyone else in the division!! Back to Mayweather,yeah,people proclaim him to be greatest fighter ever etc,no way bro.

It's gotta be Hatton. He was on most people's top 5 p4p going into Saturday's fight against someone who was not on anyone's top 20 p4p -- and he was very unimpressive in almost losing. The only other guy on this list that is ranked that high--Mayweather--has only had one really close fight, and it was against another top 10 p4p guy. Hatton wins the overhype contest by virtue of his ranking vs. close match-up against low-ranked fighter ratio.

Taylor is not on the Ring or Saddo's Top 10 p4p list, he's the underdog going into his next fight, and most people think he lost at least the first B-Hop fight, so I don't see how he could be overrated.

I could see the argument for Calzaghe, but despite not facing very good competition, he doesn't really have any negatives against him--no one's made him look bad like Collazo did to Hatton. And most people don't rank him as high p4p as they ranked Ricky.

I don't see anyone giving Floyd real trouble unless he presses the issue and goes up to 154--which still wouldn't show that he was "overrated."

Sorry,I don't mean to sound as if Mayweather is over rated,he dam sure as hell isn't but then you read posts saying he could have beaten Hagler,Hearns Leonrd etc and I don't see it. He is NOT the greatest of all time.....YET!

Originally Posted by The Game

Oh so you mean who is over hyped,well Mayweather if you go by the people on this forum,I mean people have him in there with SRR,SRL,Hagerl,Duran-HELLLL NO!! Not yet anyway. Clazghe has fought all the dangers presented to him and he MADE lacey look that bad,I think Jeff is much better than that,it's just Calzaghe is soooo far ahead of everyone else in the division!! Back to Mayweather,yeah,people proclaim him to be greatest fighter ever etc,no way bro.

Your right, people on this forum are on Floyd like he's SUPERMAN, Zab proved there are no unbeatable fighters around....including Floyd.

people definitley give him more hype then he deserves, and in that sense he is overated


about calzaghe never having toruble, mitchell almost KTFO calzaghe

Originally Posted by SalTheButcher

about calzaghe never having toruble, mitchell almost KTFO calzaghe

Fair enough. The eventual stoppage for Calzaghe was premature to the extreme and HIGHLY questionable as well -- and definitely would not have happened so quickly had the fight taken place elsewhere.

Originally Posted by atomic bull

Originally Posted by The Game

Oh so you mean who is over hyped,well Mayweather if you go by the people on this forum,I mean people have him in there with SRR,SRL,Hagerl,Duran-HELLLL NO!! Not yet anyway. Clazghe has fought all the dangers presented to him and he MADE lacey look that bad,I think Jeff is much better than that,it's just Calzaghe is soooo far ahead of everyone else in the division!! Back to Mayweather,yeah,people proclaim him to be greatest fighter ever etc,no way bro.

Your right, people on this forum are on Floyd like he's SUPERMAN, Zab proved there are no unbeatable fighters around....including Floyd.

you do know that zab lost....so how did he prove nobodies unbeatable?