Thread: If the judges were conspiring to cheat Winky...

If Winky truely got cheated, how come Taylor didn't get the win. THe judge who scored the fight a draw could have gave Taylor just one more round to satisfly the Taylor supportive crowd.

Sounds like a conspiracy to me.

I realize nobody is caring about this point, but I think its a good one. If Taylor is such the HBO darling, how come he didn't get the win?

I mentioned this point earlier
People on this forum are crying over spilt milk, complaining how Winky never won because Taylor is a HBO fighter. Just a desperate attempt to drag him down, when the reality is that the fight was indeed close and a draw was actually a good decision.

Posted by tuckwopat

I realize nobody is caring about this point, but I think its a good one. If Taylor is such the HBO darling, how come he didn't get the win?

Because getting a draw is already a win for him, he keeps his crown and have his pride intact. They just can't stomach giving him the fight where he was clearly outboxed, cornered and battered.

Originally Posted by spade

Posted by tuckwopat

I realize nobody is caring about this point, but I think its a good one. If Taylor is such the HBO darling, how come he didn't get the win?

Because getting a draw is already a win for him, he keeps his crown and have his pride intact. They just can't stomach giving him the fight where he was clearly outboxed, cornered and battered.

So what your are saying is that, between the handful of minutes that the fight ended and that they called the scores that: some shifty HBO executive met with the three judges to allign their scores into a draw? Why a draw, why didn't they just give him one more point and he would have won the fight and had a perfect record at the end.

I think Winky was boxing better than Taylor, but by no means did he batter him. It takes a wide imagination to think that either fighter was battered. Taylor easily gave as much has he got.

Originally Posted by tuckwopat

If Winky truely got cheated, how come Taylor didn't get the win. THe judge who scored the fight a draw could have gave Taylor just one more round to satisfly the Taylor supportive crowd.

Sounds like a conspiracy to me.

It wasn't a conspiracy, it was just a bad decision imo.

Originally Posted by SecondRoundKO

Originally Posted by tuckwopat

If Winky truely got cheated, how come Taylor didn't get the win. THe judge who scored the fight a draw could have gave Taylor just one more round to satisfly the Taylor supportive crowd.

Sounds like a conspiracy to me.

It wasn't a conspiracy, it was just a bad decision imo.

If all three judges would have had Winky winning, that would have been bad. I think if you look at the general consensus of this board, half the people either think Taylor won or draw, or that Winky won. Seems like a splint opinion on the topic, which makes the decision look pretty good.

Originally Posted by tuckwopat

Originally Posted by SecondRoundKO

Originally Posted by tuckwopat

If Winky truely got cheated, how come Taylor didn't get the win. THe judge who scored the fight a draw could have gave Taylor just one more round to satisfly the Taylor supportive crowd.

Sounds like a conspiracy to me.

It wasn't a conspiracy, it was just a bad decision imo.

If all three judges would have had Winky winning, that would have been bad. I think if you look at the general consensus of this board, half the people either think Taylor won or draw, or that Winky won. Seems like a splint opinion on the topic, which makes the decision look pretty good.

Which is why I put imo

hahaha its just funny
the last couple of big fights
have led to so much points of discussion
its rather nice if ya ask me

Originally Posted by The_One77

I mentioned this point earlier
People on this forum are crying over spilt milk, complaining how Winky never won because Taylor is a HBO fighter. Just a desperate attempt to drag him down, when the reality is that the fight was indeed close and a draw was actually a good decision.

He is an HBO fighter & not only do commentators tend to favor them...so do the scores.

Originally Posted by wacko3205

Originally Posted by The_One77

I mentioned this point earlier
People on this forum are crying over spilt milk, complaining how Winky never won because Taylor is a HBO fighter. Just a desperate attempt to drag him down, when the reality is that the fight was indeed close and a draw was actually a good decision.

He is an HBO fighter & not only do commentators tend to favor them...so do the scores.

DLH was an HBO fighter who had the commentators on his nutts too. Didn't exactly help him with Tito or the Mosley rematch did it

They gave the 12th to Taylor which ensured a draw!!!

If they hadn't then Winky would have won a MD as he was ahead on two judges scorecards going into the 12th.

Originally Posted by SecondRoundKO

Originally Posted by tuckwopat

If Winky truely got cheated, how come Taylor didn't get the win. THe judge who scored the fight a draw could have gave Taylor just one more round to satisfly the Taylor supportive crowd.

Sounds like a conspiracy to me.

It wasn't a conspiracy, it was just a bad decision imo.

it was a bad decision, i only wish winky could have left no doubt in those senile judges minds by absolutely dominating those last 2 rounds....

i had him winning, but to take the belts you should never leave anything in doubt in the minds of dubious decision makers....

I gave Taylor the 12th and my scorecard had it even as well.

Originally Posted by Starr

They gave the 12th to Taylor which ensured a draw!!!

If they hadn't then Winky would have won a MD as he was ahead on two judges scorecards going into the 12th.

One judge actually gave Winky the 12th. I didn't deserrve it, but he got it.

F*ck Gary Shaw. He said because of this fight he's never promoting in Memphis again, as if the fans had anything to do with it. And the judges weren't even from Memphis. They're acting like sore losers when they didn't even lose. He can go to hell.