Thread: Toney v Eubank & Benn

Having seen more of Toney at Middleweight and Super Middleweight i think he would of beat both my fellow brits, Benn i think he would of comfortably beat, Eubank was an akward customer but i think Toney would of had both there numbers, what do you guys think??

Beat Benn Close?

Beat Eubank - No Way


The more I watch Benn, the more I dont rate him less, he was a warrior, and had great fights, and a massive heart, but he wasnt majorly great...

Eubank would have beat James...Benn would be the PERFECT opponent for James and Nigel would have been outboxed badly

I think Eubank in his day was about as good as you get. After the Watson fight he wasn't the same fighter he was before. I reckon he would have been too good for Toney. Unsure about Benn v Toney though as it could have gone either way. Why did Toney never face either of them, anyone know?

i agree with some other poster

Benn - I think Toney would win this , it would be a bit like Iran barkley vs Toney

Eubank - Would be close

Originally Posted by thegreatsd

I think Eubank in his day was about as good as you get. After the Watson fight he wasn't the same fighter he was before. I reckon he would have been too good for Toney. Unsure about Benn v Toney though as it could have gone either way. Why did Toney never face either of them, anyone know?

Hard to say, but i think it's similar to the Calzaghe saga now, risk for reward, i think there was alot of foghts for Eubank and Benn never made RJJ Nunn etc etc.
It is a pity.

Yup, damn shame

benn would have a punchers chance against toney

i would of loved to of seen hagler vs benn that would of been a real war