Thread: PBF, Don't retire just yet

Don't deprive us of seeing PBF - Cotto - Hatton, since you were all 140 I was clamoring for this fights. Win or Lose against Oscar, these fights would still be very interesting.

I couldn't give a shit about those two fights... Cotto still has to beat either Paul Williams or Margaritto after Judah before I would prefer to see him fight PBF than Mosley or WRight.

Originally Posted by Taeth

I couldn't give a S*** about those two fights... Cotto still has to beat either Paul Williams or Margaritto after Judah before I would prefer to see him fight PBF than Mosley or WRight.

I've been saying this for the longest...and NO one agreed.
CC

id be RINGSIDE for pbf vs hatton!

Originally Posted by Mintymen

Don't deprive us of seeing PBF - Cotto - Hatton, since you were all 140 I was clamoring for this fights. Win or Lose against Oscar, these fights would still be very interesting.

no he won't just yet because there's still mosely who beat de la hoya and then winky who beat mosely simply put this, both are legitimate threat in his p4p status. and if he waits long enough for cotto to reach his prime they could still meet. along the way of meeting a prime cotto he could take hatton as a tune up fight then he can establish a right reason of retiring because there's no more great fighters to fight to motivate him, fans will understand and might go down as the ultimate undisputed no.1 p4p champ in this era. wait if he's nuts enough he might opt to go down to 135-140 and pacman might issue a challenge, crazy but pac is the number 2 after all and a great threat to his status the most. at 135-140 depends on how his body copes up this might be a spectacular fight although both of them are handicapped. floyd endangered of weight drain and pac maybe at 135-140 is too much for his body to take might become sluggish and can't take hard punches on that weight. we'll never know.. oh well forget the last part about floyd vs pac i'm just crazy today.

He won't fight Hatton if he gets sparked by Castillo or Cotto if he get layed out by Judah.. but if Hatton and Cotto do a better job of Castillo and Judah than he did then there is good reason and money to fight.

Originally Posted by Hairdoo

He won't fight Hatton if he gets sparked by Castillo or Cotto if he get layed out by Judah.. but if Hatton and Cotto do a better job of Castillo and Judah than he did then there is good reason and money to fight.

thats why i want hatton to beat castillo

and cotto deserves to beat judah

Anyone who think PBF will be fighting Winky is dreaming
Winky is a middle / supermiddle now and Floyd may be good but he aint beating a big smooth boxer like Winky , no way in a million years !!!!
i think if after Oscar he fights Mosley he gets outpointed to.

Originally Posted by Mintymen

Don't deprive us of seeing PBF - Cotto - Hatton, since you were all 140 I was clamoring for this fights. Win or Lose against Oscar, these fights would still be very interesting.

Yep, since before Hatton beat Tszyu I've been absolutely dying to see him fight floyd or Cotto, I think because of the 140 connection all 3 are still paddling in the same pool.

Originally Posted by Mintymen

Don't deprive us of seeing PBF - Cotto - Hatton, since you were all 140 I was clamoring for this fights. Win or Lose against Oscar, these fights would still be very interesting.

Don't forget Mosley

Originally Posted by Puya

Originally Posted by Mintymen

Don't deprive us of seeing PBF - Cotto - Hatton, since you were all 140 I was clamoring for this fights. Win or Lose against Oscar, these fights would still be very interesting.

Don't forget Mosley

how about TITO?

I strongly believe that if Tito could make 154 (I have serious doubts that he can) he would be a HUGE player. He was pretty damn close to unbeatable at that weight. As long as he stays away from the middleweights like JT or Winky, he can beat anyone of the current 154 and 147 guys.

Of course, realistically this will probably never happen. He probably can't make 154 anymore and he has not fought for almost 2 years now, so he will most likely not be the same..

Originally Posted by althetruthhindley

Anyone who think PBF will be fighting Winky is dreaming
Winky is a middle / supermiddle now and Floyd may be good but he aint beating a big smooth boxer like Winky , no way in a million years !!!!
i think if after Oscar he fights Mosley he gets outpointed to.

Supermiddle? He looked tiny against JT!

Originally Posted by althetruthhindley

Anyone who think PBF will be fighting Winky is dreaming
Winky is a middle / supermiddle now and Floyd may be good but he aint beating a big smooth boxer like Winky , no way in a million years !!!!
i think if after Oscar he fights Mosley he gets outpointed to.

I say its closer than some think... Winky is a good sized Middleweight, but speed is a huge factor here, and so is Winky's age. Mayweather is a much smarter fighter than Mosley, and I could easily see him beating Winky.

Originally Posted by The Rookie Fan

I strongly believe that if Tito could make 154 (I have serious doubts that he can) he would be a HUGE player.  He was pretty damn close to unbeatable at that weight.  As long as he stays away from the middleweights like JT or Winky, he can beat anyone of the current 154 and 147 guys. 

Of course, realistically this will probably never happen.  He probably can't make 154 anymore and he has not fought for almost 2 years now, so he will most likely not be the same..

and he barely fought his last fight  get it?  :P