Thread: Our work is done for the month. Saddo's Official P4P List as of April, 2007

Agree if Mayweather beats Oscar then he soars back to the top and imo gets into the 'Sugar Ray Leonard' levels of fame.
What happens if Oscar beats him though? Will he warrant flying straight into the top 10

No way does he get close to SRl YET...He needs more names,some of the guys at 147 would be a good step. If Oscar wins,in a clear and convincing manner and coupled with his other accomplishments plus the fact that he'll be beating a P4P number 1 whom has looked dam near unbeatable thus far,I think Oscar would certainly push for P4P top 3 status easily. I can see ALOT of people arguing for him to be first.

Originally Posted by Smashup

Agree if Mayweather beats Oscar then he soars back to the top and imo gets into the 'Sugar Ray Leonard' levels of fame.
What happens if Oscar beats him though? Will he warrant flying straight into the top 10

Smash oscar will move to number 1 or 2 imo, he has just beat the number one, Pretty boy needs to do a number on mosley aswell as Golden Boy before he becomes that sort of great.

hey wacko is it possible to vote twice? everytime i see the voting poll it just shows the results it doesn't let you vote again, so how could people vote twice

We are all going to have things that we disagree on, and mine is the fact that joe is so high, i think he should be 9th or 10th and thats the highest p4p he should be ranked at.

I think its just right for pac to take spot#1 he has beating the best out there and nobody looks to have a chance of stopping him. I also think if floyd beats oscar worst then bhop did, then I think he'd win back spot 1 but if pac beats jmm pac takes it again and floyd will have to beat a winky to get it back from pac, because pac has beaten p4p fighters in the last few years and floyd hasn't beat any p4p in the last few years so i think an old big name oscar is the only thing that can lead floyd back to spot 1 atleast for a while.

I base my p4p ranking about who beat the best out there, and so far pac has beaten the most p4p fighters. I don't get how floyd will get much credit beating an oscar who doesnt even rank top 20 p4p but i'd give it up to floyd if he does win, but he'll need more better fights to keep the #1 spot.

Originally Posted by the wiz

Originally Posted by amat

STRONGLY disagree with Pacquiao being ahead of Mayweather. If he was 5 months ago that's fine, but he's done nothing to surpass him imo. Mayweather has that spot until he starts fighting bums or loses.

How does Mayweather have that spot? By beating Gatti? I think Mayweather has been fighting bums.

Because Solis, Washed up Morrales, and Larios are such distinguished fighters. Baldomir and Judah are better than them. Morrales in his prime is a different story, but even an older Morrales clearly beat Pacquaio, and Morrales was never even close to as good as Mayweather p4p. P4P is who wins if they weighed the same, and Mayweather wins everytime against Pacquaio. Its not about opponents, popularity, excitement, its about who beats who plain and simple. I hear whole bunch of crap about how can be about a variety of crap, but the p4p list was first brought forth to indicate Robinson was the best fighter in the world if everyone was fighting in the same weight class.

Originally Posted by Taeth

Originally Posted by the wiz

Originally Posted by amat

STRONGLY disagree with Pacquiao being ahead of Mayweather. If he was 5 months ago that's fine, but he's done nothing to surpass him imo. Mayweather has that spot until he starts fighting bums or loses.

How does Mayweather have that spot? By beating Gatti? I think Mayweather has been fighting bums.

Because Solis, Washed up Morrales, and Larios are such distinguished fighters. Baldomir and Judah are better than them. Morrales in his prime is a different story, but even an older Morrales clearly beat Pacquaio, and Morrales was never even close to as good as Mayweather p4p. P4P is who wins if they weighed the same, and Mayweather wins everytime against Pacquaio. Its not about opponents, popularity, excitement, its about who beats who plain and simple. I hear whole bunch of crap about how can be about a variety of crap, but the p4p list was first brought forth to indicate Robinson was the best fighter in the world if everyone was fighting in the same weight class.

pac did lose to em, but to be fair to pac he wasn't the pac of today he wasn't yet prime then but pac ended up whooping all his oppenents worst then pbf can whoop any of his oppenents, pbf was dominated by zab in the first half and he ran all night against baldomir, even celebs walk out the area disgussted at the so called p4p king to be running against a guy with no power and speed.

if you want to talk about who beat who, then pac has beaten more p4p fighters then pbf has, actually pbf hasn't seen a p4p fighter infront of him since weigh drain chico.

Originally Posted by Taeth

I know you are directly responsible for it Wacko, but to the rest of you I am deeply dissapointed in your lack of judgement placing Pacquaio in front of Mayweather. I can't see how somebody with any knowledge of boxing would make such a misguided decision. Mayweather is far better than Pacquaio. I am not saying Pacquaio isn't good, but he isn't on Mayweather's level. Its like having Trinidad ahead of Roy Jones on the p4p list back in the day.

Hang on just one second there Taeth.

No way in hell am I directly responsible for this list.

I put up a poll...the forum voted & by percentages...up went the list. This is the forum's list. It is based on percentages & their opinions...while I might not agree with them...I won't question their knowledge of boxing...nor should anyone question mine.

I don't play that game.

Personally...I think that the list is a bit out of wack (no pun intended) due to the fact that I believe Floyd to be the #1 man, Wright #2, & then Pacquiao #3...but that don't make me any more correct than the next man.

Originally Posted by Taeth

Originally Posted by the wiz

Originally Posted by amat

STRONGLY disagree with Pacquiao being ahead of Mayweather. If he was 5 months ago that's fine, but he's done nothing to surpass him imo. Mayweather has that spot until he starts fighting bums or loses.

How does Mayweather have that spot? By beating Gatti? I think Mayweather has been fighting bums.

Because Solis, Washed up Morrales, and Larios are such distinguished fighters. Baldomir and Judah are better than them. Morrales in his prime is a different story, but even an older Morrales clearly beat Pacquaio, and Morrales was never even close to as good as Mayweather p4p. P4P is who wins if they weighed the same, and Mayweather wins everytime against Pacquaio. Its not about opponents, popularity, excitement, its about who beats who plain and simple. I hear whole bunch of crap about how can be about a variety of crap, but the p4p list was first brought forth to indicate Robinson was the best fighter in the world if everyone was fighting in the same weight class.

Even washed up Morales is better than Baldo and Judah combined.

Good work Wacko. I mean the Cotto one is bizarre to me but the forum voted him in so guess he's gotta be on it.

Originally Posted by wacko3205

Originally Posted by Taeth

I know you are directly responsible for it Wacko, but to the rest of you I am deeply dissapointed in your lack of judgement placing Pacquaio in front of Mayweather. I can't see how somebody with any knowledge of boxing would make such a misguided decision. Mayweather is far better than Pacquaio. I am not saying Pacquaio isn't good, but he isn't on Mayweather's level. Its like having Trinidad ahead of Roy Jones on the p4p list back in the day.

Hang on just one second there Taeth.

No way in hell am I directly responsible for this list.

I put up a poll...the forum voted & by percentages...up went the list. This is the forum's list. It is based on percentages & their opinions...while I might not agree with them...I won't question their knowledge of boxing...nor should anyone question mine.

I don't play that game.

Personally...I think that the list is a bit out of wack (no pun intended) due to the fact that I believe Floyd to be the #1 man, Wright #2, & then Pacquiao #3...but that don't make me any more correct than the next man.

+2840 now thats a fair man.

Originally Posted by wacko3205

Originally Posted by Taeth

I know you are directly responsible for it Wacko, but to the rest of you I am deeply dissapointed in your lack of judgement placing Pacquaio in front of Mayweather. I can't see how somebody with any knowledge of boxing would make such a misguided decision. Mayweather is far better than Pacquaio. I am not saying Pacquaio isn't good, but he isn't on Mayweather's level. Its like having Trinidad ahead of Roy Jones on the p4p list back in the day.

Hang on just one second there Taeth.

No way in hell am I directly responsible for this list.

I put up a poll...the forum voted & by percentages...up went the list. This is the forum's list. It is based on percentages & their opinions...while I might not agree with them...I won't question their knowledge of boxing...nor should anyone question mine.

I don't play that game.

Personally...I think that the list is a bit out of wack (no pun intended) due to the fact that I believe Floyd to be the #1 man, Wright #2, & then Pacquiao #3...but that don't make me any more correct than the next man.

Wacko I mispelled I was meaning to say I know you weren't responsible.

Originally Posted by El Gamo

Originally Posted by zzz

He currently runs a record of 38 fights, 36 wins with 32 knockouts, and 3 losses.

#7 Rafael Marquez. typo?

RAFA MARQUEZ SHOULD BE TOP 3 EASILY!!! i LOVE Cotto but he should not be that high. I alos think PBF fighting Oscar mean keeps him in first place. Pac-Solis does not cut it at all!

My point is, someone should fix the numerical typo. I had to check it a few times, but I'm pretty sure 36 wins and three losses adds up to 39 fights, not 38.

I have no problems with his placement on the list though.

Originally Posted by Julius Rain

Originally Posted by wacko3205

Originally Posted by Taeth

I know you are directly responsible for it Wacko, but to the rest of you I am deeply dissapointed in your lack of judgement placing Pacquaio in front of Mayweather. I can't see how somebody with any knowledge of boxing would make such a misguided decision. Mayweather is far better than Pacquaio. I am not saying Pacquaio isn't good, but he isn't on Mayweather's level. Its like having Trinidad ahead of Roy Jones on the p4p list back in the day.

Hang on just one second there Taeth.

No way in hell am I directly responsible for this list.

I put up a poll...the forum voted & by percentages...up went the list. This is the forum's list. It is based on percentages & their opinions...while I might not agree with them...I won't question their knowledge of boxing...nor should anyone question mine.

I don't play that game.

Personally...I think that the list is a bit out of wack (no pun intended) due to the fact that I believe Floyd to be the #1 man, Wright #2, & then Pacquiao #3...but that don't make me any more correct than the next man.

+2840 now thats a fair man.

back. Cheers.

Originally Posted by Taeth

Originally Posted by wacko3205

Originally Posted by Taeth

I know you are directly responsible for it Wacko, but to the rest of you I am deeply dissapointed in your lack of judgement placing Pacquaio in front of Mayweather. I can't see how somebody with any knowledge of boxing would make such a misguided decision. Mayweather is far better than Pacquaio. I am not saying Pacquaio isn't good, but he isn't on Mayweather's level. Its like having Trinidad ahead of Roy Jones on the p4p list back in the day.

Hang on just one second there Taeth.

No way in hell am I directly responsible for this list.

I put up a poll...the forum voted & by percentages...up went the list. This is the forum's list. It is based on percentages & their opinions...while I might not agree with them...I won't question their knowledge of boxing...nor should anyone question mine.

I don't play that game.

Personally...I think that the list is a bit out of wack (no pun intended) due to the fact that I believe Floyd to be the #1 man, Wright #2, & then Pacquiao #3...but that don't make me any more correct than the next man.

Wacko I mispelled I was meaning to say I know you weren't responsible.

Think nothing of it, babe. Cheers.