Thread: Joe Calzaghe now no. 3 in Ring Mag's latest P4P rankings

Joe Calzaghe now no. 3 in Ring Mag's latest P4P rankings

what a joke



guess golden boy wants to get involved with calzaghe

I think no. 3 P4P ranking is just right for Joe... His performance against B-Hop doesn't merit any higher ranking than no. 3 ...

.

Originally Posted by SaddoBoxer

I think no. 3 P4P ranking is just right for Joe... His performance against B-Hop doesn't merit any higher ranking than no. 3 ...

.

it doesnt merit anywhere near top 10

Originally Posted by SalTheButcher

Originally Posted by SaddoBoxer

I think no. 3 P4P ranking is just right for Joe... His performance against B-Hop doesn't merit any higher ranking than no. 3 ...

.

it doesnt merit anywhere near top 10

Joe was previously ranked no.5 and since he "beat" (?) BHop (previously ranked no. 4), it should be normal that Joe jumped above BHop... No. 4 or at most no. 3 is OK...

Of course, I respect your opinion that Joe doesn't really belong in the top 10 P4P... This one is Ring Mag's rankings...

.

Originally Posted by SalTheButcher

what a joke



guess golden boy wants to get involved with calzaghe

Yeah. Floyd at top spot, that is. That's why no credible fan regards the Ring highly anymore. It has become so partisan and subjective. Floyd at number 1? Fukking BS.

Originally Posted by JLAQ

Originally Posted by SalTheButcher

what a joke



guess golden boy wants to get involved with calzaghe

Yeah. Floyd at top spot, that is. That's why no credible fan regards the Ring highly anymore. It has become so partisan and subjective. Floyd at number 1? Fukking BS.

Then who do you consider as no. 1 P4P ?

.

Originally Posted by SaddoBoxer

Originally Posted by JLAQ

Originally Posted by SalTheButcher

what a joke



guess golden boy wants to get involved with calzaghe

Yeah. Floyd at top spot, that is. That's why no credible fan regards the Ring highly anymore. It has become so partisan and subjective. Floyd at number 1? Fukking BS.

Then who do you consider as no. 1 P4P ?

.

Either the British Bomber or the Man from Manila.

Originally Posted by JLAQ

Originally Posted by SaddoBoxer

Originally Posted by JLAQ

Yeah. Floyd at top spot, that is. That's why no credible fan regards the Ring highly anymore. It has become so partisan and subjective. Floyd at number 1? Fukking BS.

Then who do you consider as no. 1 P4P ?

.

Either the British Bomber or the Man from Manila.

PAC has a claim to that no. 1 spot but Joe... no way...

But anyone can make his own P4P list...

.

Floyd is easily the most gifted fighter today. I do consider him #1 P4P but he should be dropped soon because of his inactivity and his unwillingness to fight the better fighters in his division. I could just imagine how crazy this forum would get if he was ever knocked out of the top spot.

Other than what I just said, to get back on topic, I think Joe should be #4 right behind Juan Manuel Marquez. That's just my opinion...

So who deserves to be ahead of Calzaghe besides Floyd and Pac? JMM? He just lost to Pac. Hopkins? Obviously not, Calzaghe just beat him. Vazquez? He got stopped just three fights ago.

Calzaghe is where he should be at #3 IMO.

Originally Posted by caleoh12

Other than what I just said, to get back on topic, I think Joe should be #4 right behind Juan Manuel Marquez. That's just my opinion...

JMM just lost to Pac (controversial I know, but thats the official ruling). Calzaghe just beat Bhop. How can JMM be ahead of Calzaghe? P4P rankings are very compeditive, if you lose a fight you drop down.

He should be #2.

1. PBF
2. Joe
3. Paq
4. JM Marquez
5. BHOP

I got Joe at number 5.