Thread: Your Scorecards on Controversial/Close Decisions

DLH- Trinidad: 115-114 De La Hoya

• DLH rounds: 2, 3, 5, 6, 7, 9
• Trinidad rounds: 4, 8, 10-12
• Even: 1

DLH-Whitaker: 113-113

DLH-Quartey: 115-112 Quartey

• I don't remember the R-B-R of the first 5, but I know I had it 3-2 Quartey after 5. Rounds 6-9 for Quartey, round 10 to DLH, round 11 to Quartey, round 12 for DLH (10 to

Quartey-Forrest: Quartey 97-93 (I think)

Corrales-Cassamayor II: 114-113 Corrales

Bowe-Holyfield II: 115-115 Even

Lennox-Holyfield II: 115-113 Lewis

Morales-Pacman I: 116-112 or 115-113 Morales. Whatever Harold Lederman had, I was one round off of his.

Pacman-Marquez I: I had Pacquiao slightly ahead, I don't remember the score

Mayweather-Castillo I: 115-112 Mayweather. Castillo did nothing in the first 5 rounds.

Whitaker-Ramirez I: 116-112 Whitaker

Whitaker-Chavez: 116-112 Whitaker

Nelson-Fenech I : 117-111 Fenech

Camacho-Rosario: 116-113 Rosario

Hagler-Antuerfermo: I had it 116-112 Hagler after 12, and then my copy gets all messed up at the start of the 13th round.

Hagler-Duran: 146-140 Hagler. One of the most overrated "close" fights ever.

Cotto-Mosley: 115-113 Cotto

Holmes-Witherspoon: 115-114 Witherspoon.

Holmes-Spinx I: 144-141 Spinks

Holmes-Spinx II: 144-141 Holmes

Foreman-Stewart: 94-93 Foreman

Foreman-Briggs: 116-112 Foreman

Ali-Shavers: 144-141 Shavers

Taylor-Hopkins I: 114-114

Toney-Mccallum I: 116-112 Toney

Toney-Mccallum II: 114-113 McCallum

Toney-Peter I: 115-112 Toney

Roy Jones-Tarver I : 115-113 Jones

Pedroza-Laporte: Laporte via DQ

SweetPea used to have a very good thread where once a week everyone would post and explain their scorecard for a particular controversial fight. Very popular thread I wouldn't mind seeing it make a return.

Mayweather-Castillo I: 115-112 Mayweather. Castillo did nothing in the first 5 rounds.

No, but in the other 7...............

I don't have near that many but what I do have/remember

Taylor - Hopkins I: 114-114
Whitaker - Chavez: 117-111 Whitaker
Hopkins - Calzaghe: 114-113 Hopkins
Collazo - Hatton: 114-113 Hatton
Marquez - Pacquiao: 114-113 Marquez
Dawson - Johnson: 115-113 Johnson
Wright - Taylor: 116-112 Wright

Originally Posted by Kel

Mayweather-Castillo I: 115-112 Mayweather. Castillo did nothing in the first 5 rounds.

No, but in the other 7...............

In the other 7, Castillo took 4, Mayweather 2, and one even.

Originally Posted by Thread Stealer

Originally Posted by Kel

Mayweather-Castillo I: 115-112 Mayweather. Castillo did nothing in the first 5 rounds.

No, but in the other 7...............

In the other 7, Castillo took 4, Mayweather 2, and one even.

Not at all, Floyd lost by 1 or 2 points. Castillo landed many more punches.

Of course if your a Floyd fan your gonna echo all the shit he comes out with.

George Foreman couldn't pronounce Castillo's name. He kept calling him "Castell". WTF

Originally Posted by SE7EN

George Foreman couldn't pronounce Castillo's name. He kept calling him "Castell". WTF

Big George always makes me laugh Is he still on the panel at HBO? I'm always watching Setanta these days

Originally Posted by Kel

Originally Posted by Thread Stealer

Originally Posted by Kel

No, but in the other 7...............

In the other 7, Castillo took 4, Mayweather 2, and one even.

Not at all, Floyd lost by 1 or 2 points. Castillo landed many more punches.

Of course if your a Floyd fan your gonna echo all the shit he comes out with.

Do you have a scorecard for rounds 6-12, or are you being a complete hypocrite in that you just echo what people who dont like Mayweather have said, and haven't even seen the fight. Im guessing the latter.

Originally Posted by p4pking

Originally Posted by Kel

Originally Posted by Thread Stealer

In the other 7, Castillo took 4, Mayweather 2, and one even.

Not at all, Floyd lost by 1 or 2 points. Castillo landed many more punches.

Of course if your a Floyd fan your gonna echo all the shit he comes out with.

Do you have a scorecard for rounds 6-12, or are you being a complete hypocrite in that you just echo what people who dont like Mayweather have said, and haven't even seen the fight. Im guessing the latter.

For a start, if you talk to me like that I just think your a wanker. So you can just fuck off

I had Castillo 116-112 In 1st Mayweather fight.I think his body work was really over looked by the judges.It's been a while but I see I had round 7 even.....I hate even rounds.Points deducted in the 8th & 10th.Hey,this was on 4-20...hehe

edit...man I must had a "rough" night,I actually had the 8th even 9-9 with the deduction,another even round (I think the 10 point must system can be flawed)

Originally Posted by SE7EN

George Foreman couldn't pronounce Castillo's name. He kept calling him "Castell". WTF

You should watch Cotto-Malignaggi. Foreman pronounced Paulie's last name at least 10 different ways over the course of the fight.

The Mayweather-Ndou fight was another good one. "Ndou" gave George all types of problems.

Originally Posted by Kel

Originally Posted by Thread Stealer

Originally Posted by Kel

No, but in the other 7...............

In the other 7, Castillo took 4, Mayweather 2, and one even.

Not at all, Floyd lost by 1 or 2 points. Castillo landed many more punches.

Of course if your a Floyd fan your gonna echo all the shit he comes out with.

I don't buy that Compubox crap. Castillo didn't land nearly as much as it that meaningless system or the commentators said he did. Castillo did some good bodywork, but even when he came on stronger in the latter rounds, he was missing a whole lot. As is often the case with Compubox, neither guy landed as much as it said they did.

It was a close fight that could've gone either way.

Originally Posted by Thread Stealer

DLH- Trinidad: 115-114 De La Hoya

• DLH rounds: 2, 3, 5, 6, 7, 9
• Trinidad rounds: 4, 8, 10-12
• Even: 1

DLH-Whitaker: 113-113

DLH-Quartey: 115-112 Quartey

• I don't remember the R-B-R of the first 5, but I know I had it 3-2 Quartey after 5. Rounds 6-9 for Quartey, round 10 to DLH, round 11 to Quartey, round 12 for DLH (10 to

Quartey-Forrest: Quartey 97-93 (I think)

Corrales-Cassamayor II: 114-113 Corrales

Bowe-Holyfield II: 115-115 Even

Lennox-Holyfield II: 115-113 Lewis

Morales-Pacman I: 116-112 or 115-113 Morales. Whatever Harold Lederman had, I was one round off of his.

Pacman-Marquez I: I had Pacquiao slightly ahead, I don't remember the score

Mayweather-Castillo I: 115-112 Mayweather. Castillo did nothing in the first 5 rounds.

Whitaker-Ramirez I: 116-112 Whitaker

Whitaker-Chavez: 116-112 Whitaker

Nelson-Fenech I : 117-111 Fenech

Camacho-Rosario: 116-113 Rosario

Hagler-Antuerfermo: I had it 116-112 Hagler after 12, and then my copy gets all messed up at the start of the 13th round.

Hagler-Duran: 146-140 Hagler. One of the most overrated "close" fights ever.

Cotto-Mosley: 115-113 Cotto

Holmes-Witherspoon: 115-114 Witherspoon.

Holmes-Spinx I: 144-141 Spinks

Holmes-Spinx II: 144-141 Holmes

Foreman-Stewart: 94-93 Foreman

Foreman-Briggs: 116-112 Foreman

Ali-Shavers: 144-141 Shavers

Taylor-Hopkins I: 114-114

Toney-Mccallum I: 116-112 Toney

Toney-Mccallum II: 114-113 McCallum

Toney-Peter I: 115-112 Toney

Roy Jones-Tarver I : 115-113 Jones

Pedroza-Laporte: Laporte via DQ

Cant remember my exact card but I remeber who I think won

DLH- Trinidad: Trinidad
DLH-Whitaker: Whitaker
DLH-Quartey: De La Hoya
Quartey-Forrest: Quartey
Corrales-Cassamayor II: Chico
Bowe-Holyfield II: Holyfield
Lennox-Holyfield II: Lewis
Morales-Pacman I: Morales
Pacman-Marquez I: Marquez
Mayweather-Castillo I: Castillo
Whitaker-Ramirez I: Whitaker
Whitaker-Chavez: Whitaker
Cotto-Mosley: Cotto
Foreman-Briggs: Briggs
Taylor-Hopkins I: Taylor
Toney-Peter I: Toney
Roy Jones-Tarver I : Jones

Originally Posted by GAME

Originally Posted by Thread Stealer

DLH- Trinidad: 115-114 De La Hoya

• DLH rounds: 2, 3, 5, 6, 7, 9
• Trinidad rounds: 4, 8, 10-12
• Even: 1

DLH-Whitaker: 113-113

DLH-Quartey: 115-112 Quartey

• I don't remember the R-B-R of the first 5, but I know I had it 3-2 Quartey after 5. Rounds 6-9 for Quartey, round 10 to DLH, round 11 to Quartey, round 12 for DLH (10 to

Quartey-Forrest: Quartey 97-93 (I think)

Corrales-Cassamayor II: 114-113 Corrales

Bowe-Holyfield II: 115-115 Even

Lennox-Holyfield II: 115-113 Lewis

Morales-Pacman I: 116-112 or 115-113 Morales. Whatever Harold Lederman had, I was one round off of his.

Pacman-Marquez I: I had Pacquiao slightly ahead, I don't remember the score

Mayweather-Castillo I: 115-112 Mayweather. Castillo did nothing in the first 5 rounds.

Whitaker-Ramirez I: 116-112 Whitaker

Whitaker-Chavez: 116-112 Whitaker

Nelson-Fenech I : 117-111 Fenech

Camacho-Rosario: 116-113 Rosario

Hagler-Antuerfermo: I had it 116-112 Hagler after 12, and then my copy gets all messed up at the start of the 13th round.

Hagler-Duran: 146-140 Hagler. One of the most overrated "close" fights ever.

Cotto-Mosley: 115-113 Cotto

Holmes-Witherspoon: 115-114 Witherspoon.

Holmes-Spinx I: 144-141 Spinks

Holmes-Spinx II: 144-141 Holmes

Foreman-Stewart: 94-93 Foreman

Foreman-Briggs: 116-112 Foreman

Ali-Shavers: 144-141 Shavers

Taylor-Hopkins I: 114-114

Toney-Mccallum I: 116-112 Toney

Toney-Mccallum II: 114-113 McCallum

Toney-Peter I: 115-112 Toney

Roy Jones-Tarver I : 115-113 Jones

Pedroza-Laporte: Laporte via DQ

Cant remember my exact card but I remeber who I think won

DLH- Trinidad: Trinidad
DLH-Whitaker: Whitaker
DLH-Quartey: De La Hoya
Quartey-Forrest: Quartey
Corrales-Cassamayor II: Chico
Bowe-Holyfield II: Holyfield
Lennox-Holyfield II: Lewis
Morales-Pacman I: Morales
Pacman-Marquez I: Marquez
Mayweather-Castillo I: Castillo
Whitaker-Ramirez I: Whitaker
Whitaker-Chavez: Whitaker
Cotto-Mosley: Cotto
Foreman-Briggs: Briggs
Taylor-Hopkins I: Taylor
Toney-Peter I: Toney
Roy Jones-Tarver I : Jones

Interesting...you felt Briggs legitimately beat Foreman?