Thread: Saddo's Official Pound for Pound List II

Some time ago I set about compiling a pound for pound list taht represented the opinions of the Saddo's community.
That was in early January, so I feel its time to revise the situation.
#(Floyd is deemed retired.)

If all posters could submit their top ten pound for pound list in this thread, I will again quantitatively compile the results in order to compile a community list.

Here's my own.

1. Manny Pacquiao
2. Joe Calzaghe
3. Miguel Angel Cotto
4. Juan Manuel Marquez
5. Israel Vasquez
6. Kelly Pavlik
7. Antonio Margarito
8. Ivan Calderon
9. Kristian Mijares
10.Rafeal Marquez

1. Manny Pacquiao
2. Joe Calzaghe
3. Miguel Angel Cotto
4. Israel Vazquez
5. Kelly Pavilk
6. Juan Manuel Marquez
7. Cristian Mijares
8. Ivan Calderon
9. Rafa Marquez
10.Ulises Solis

This is my list:

1- Manny Pacquiao
2- Miguel Cotto
3- Joe Calzague
4- Kelly Pavlik
5- Isreal Vazquez
6- J M Marquez
7- Ivan Calderon
8- Kristian Mijares
9- Wladimir Klischko
10- Rafael Marquez

Originally Posted by hitmandonny

Some time ago I set about compiling a pound for pound list taht represented the opinions of the Saddo's community.
That was in early January, so I feel its time to revise the situation.
#(Floyd is deemed retired.)

If all posters could submit their top ten pound for pound list in this thread, I will again quantitatively compile the results in order to compile a community list.

Here's my own.

1. Manny Pacquiao
2. Joe Calzaghe
3. Miguel Angel Cotto
4. Juan Manuel Marquez
5. Israel Vasquez
6. Kelly Pavlik
7. Antonio Margarito
8. Ivan Calderon
9. Kristian Mijares
10.Rafeal Marquez

1 Manny Pacquiao
2 Joe Calzaghe
3 Juan Manuel Marquez
4 Miguel Cotto
5 Israel Vasquez
6 Christian Mijares
7 Ivan Calderon
8 Rafael Marquez
9 Bernard Hopkins
10 Kelly Pavlik

Im not that good at P4P list's but Donny Margarito at 7 ?? is mind boggling to me care to explain that one mate ??

1. Pacman
2. Cotto
3. Calzaghe
4. Vasquez
5. Pavlik
6. Hopkins
7. Calderon
8. Hatton
9. Marquez
10. Mijares

1-Manny Pacquiao
2-Miguel Cotto
3-Joe Calzaghe
4-Juan Manuel Marquez
5-Bernard Hopkins
6-Kelly Pavlik
7-Israel Vasquez
8-Ricky Hatton
9-Jorge Linares
10-Andre Berto

I cant believe no one has Hatton in the top 10. I'm not just saying this a as a big fan. But all he done was lose to the best p4p fighter and suddenly he's disappeared. Still number 1 at 140 pounds and a two weight world champ. Baffles me

Originally Posted by leftylee

I cant believe no one has Hatton in the top 10. I'm not just saying this a as a big fan. But all he done was lose to the best p4p fighter and suddenly he's disappeared. Still number 1 at 140 pounds and a two weight world champ. Baffles me

Well he was number 9 or 10 on my list before the Mayweather fight, and he lost that fight in a bad way, and didn't look too good in his comeback fight so he stays just outside the top 10 for now.

Originally Posted by leftylee

I cant believe no one has Hatton in the top 10. I'm not just saying this a as a big fan. But all he done was lose to the best p4p fighter and suddenly he's disappeared. Still number 1 at 140 pounds and a two weight world champ. Baffles me

This is the anti-hatton forum didnt you realise.

Regardless of 43 wins. 2 weight world championships, 4 title belts etc because hatton lost to the greatest p4p fighter in generations he is now a washed up has been.

The fascination with lower weight class fighters on here is nothing short of ridiculous!!

Originally Posted by ICB

Originally Posted by leftylee

I cant believe no one has Hatton in the top 10. I'm not just saying this a as a big fan. But all he done was lose to the best p4p fighter and suddenly he's disappeared. Still number 1 at 140 pounds and a two weight world champ. Baffles me

Well he was number 9 or 10 on my list before the Mayweather fight, and he lost that fight in a bad way, and didn't look too good in his comeback fight so he stays just outside the top 10 for now.

Surley if he beats Paulie, a prime champion he has to come back in the top ten.

Originally Posted by leftylee

I cant believe no one has Hatton in the top 10. I'm not just saying this a as a big fan. But all he done was lose to the best p4p fighter and suddenly he's disappeared. Still number 1 at 140 pounds and a two weight world champ. Baffles me

hattonthehammer has hatton on the list right above Berto lol.

Originally Posted by leftylee

Originally Posted by ICB

Originally Posted by leftylee

I cant believe no one has Hatton in the top 10. I'm not just saying this a as a big fan. But all he done was lose to the best p4p fighter and suddenly he's disappeared. Still number 1 at 140 pounds and a two weight world champ. Baffles me

Well he was number 9 or 10 on my list before the Mayweather fight, and he lost that fight in a bad way, and didn't look too good in his comeback fight so he stays just outside the top 10 for now.

Surley if he beats Paulie, a prime champion he has to come back in the top ten.

If he beats Paulie he may crack my list at number 10.

Originally Posted by hattonthehammer

Originally Posted by leftylee

I cant believe no one has Hatton in the top 10. I'm not just saying this a as a big fan. But all he done was lose to the best p4p fighter and suddenly he's disappeared. Still number 1 at 140 pounds and a two weight world champ. Baffles me

This is the anti-hatton forum didnt you realise.

Regardless of 43 wins. 2 weight world championships, 4 title belts etc because hatton lost to the greatest p4p fighter in generations he is now a washed up has been.

The fascination with lower weight class fighters on here is nothing short of ridiculous!!

I agree, lets take Cristian Mijares for example. He got beat by 3 bums. Hatton only lost lost to P4P best while beating big name fighters in Tzsyu and Castillo. Like Mijares, Hatton has also unified. Is Mijares a two weight world champ ? No. Anyways I dont need to say no more though as I might get a few people moaning.

Originally Posted by hattonthehammer

because hatton lost to the greatest p4p fighter in generations he is now a washed up has been.

No its because he hasnt looked good since beating Tszyu. He needed a completely static target in Urangotang to look half decent for a while.

Thats why he's possibly a has been.

Originally Posted by hattonthehammer

1-Manny Pacquiao
2-Miguel Cotto
3-Joe Calzaghe
4-Juan Manuel Marquez
5-Bernard Hopkins
6-Kelly Pavlik
7-Israel Vasquez
8-Ricky Hatton
9-Jorge Linares
10-Andre Berto

I dont know hattonthehammer , to me is too early for Berto be in the list..................probably later , but not now ..................