So what's the problem?? If you want not to include JMM then we'll erase JMM from the list... So among the 3 boxers (Shane, Floyd and Cotto), I consider Shane @144 as the most dangerous opponent for PAC at this stage... Floyd @143 is next and Cotto @143 is the least dangerous... You got a problem with my list (opinion) then show me your list or voice out your opposing opinion... This is a democratic boxing discussion board... You're free to post your opinion as long as it is within the forum rules...
.
You are correct sir.
Boxing is bizarre
I don't think there's any other sport where a win or a loss (big wins or big losses) can be analyzed and dissected and denigrated to such an extent as boxing. Was he shot, did he get old overnight, was he never any good. I guess its because fighters fight so rarely.
I mean look at Jeff Lacy. I know Calzaghe fans get annoyed when people (many of whom picked Lacy) downgrade Calzaghe's win by saying Lacy was never any good but how can you look at Calzaghe-Lacy, Calzaghe-Kessler and Calzaghe-Hopkins and not think Lacy was overrated all the time? Its not so much a hit at Joe.
That was all nonsense. I'm drinking for the first time in a few weeks and rambling.
There's nothing democratic about this boxing forum. Saddo rules with an iron fist and the Moderators are little more than his henchmen and cronies. It's a cult of personality, not a democracy. Edit: That was sarcastic, though there's really nothing overly democratic about any forum I've been on, including this one.
As for your question, I would have PBF, Mosley, then Cotto in that order as the biggest threats to Pac at any weight.
Last edited by CFH; 06-04-2009 at 02:28 AM.
With PBF, I don't think the weight matters provided it isn't below 140/142. For Cotto and to a slightly lesser extent Mosley, I think that anything south of 147 is a major problem. I'd have both fights pretty much as pick'ems at 147, though I think Pac would theoretically have an easier time with Cotto than with Mosley.
Madison Square Garden, New York, New York, United States
2007-11-10
Shane Mosley 146¼
vs
Miguel Angel Cotto 146¼
That's well within the normal parameters of the weight class. It's basically weighing 147, the contracted weight for the fight. A fighter isn't going to weigh in exactly at whatever the contracted weight is all the time, to think they would is preposterous. There's a huge difference between that and 144/145.
link -->
Pacquiao on Erroneous Press Release: "Not Too Fast Mr. Mosley"
MANILA—Boxing’s No. 1 pound-for-pound best fighter Manny Pacquiao was surprised and flattered over the enterprising reports which came out in the media that a fight with “Sugar” Shane Mosley has been forged Wednesday. Apparently, a press release from a group associated with Mosley, the Entertainers and Athletes Group (EAG), came up with the story that Pacquiao agreed to fight the current WBA welterweight champion Mosley on Oct. 17.
“It’s funny that I am the last man to know about this supposed fight. I know everyone wants to fight me and I have said I will fight anyone, including Mosley. But I have not heard from my promoter or have seen any contract or fight detail. So, there is no fight yet,” said Pacquiao.
“I am flattered that even the great “Sugar” Shane Mosley is now going after me by any means. I am not closing the door on any negotiations, though, and I trust my promotional and training team to make the best decision for me,” added Pacquiao, almost a month after knocking out consensus 140-pound champion Ricky Hatton of England in only two rounds..
“For sure, my next match will be on June 18 to 21 and it will be against some of the best darters in the world,” said Pacquiao, who is bankrolling the $100,000 “Pacmania II Darts Tournament” in Burbank, California. “We have tried to invite Ricky Hatton to play a friendly match of darts with me, complete with a prize fund, but I guess he is still on vacation, according to his handlers. I hope he can still make it, so we can do a big side event.”
Top darters from all over America and other countries have already signified their intention of joining the event, one of the biggest darts competitions in years. Pacquiao, an avid darter, will compete with the likes of Brad Wethington, Scott Kirchner, Rob Heckman, Chris White, Ray Carver, Scotty Burnett, Nico Depaynos and Gary Mawson, among others.
Pacquiao is set to arrive in Los Angeles next week along with his family for a much-needed vacation. He will also fly out to New York to receive the 2008 Fighter of the Year award from the prestigious Boxing Writers Association of America on June 12 and attend the Miguel Cotto-Joshua Clottey Madison Square Garden fight the day after.
Filipino Rodel Mayol, now managed by Pacquiao, will be in the undercard. He challenges WBO light flyweight champion Ivan Calderon.
“I am not blaming people for coming up with ideas to lure me to fight them. I have said it before and I will say it again, I will not run away from a great fight. Floyd Mayweather is even using reverse psychology, saying he will not agree to fight me for a 50-50 purse. Of course everyone wants to fight me,” said Pacquiao.
“We will make the announcement at a proper time and a proper place after all the fight details have been discussed,” said the 30-year-old Pacquiao, a six-division champion who has won titles in the 112-pound flyweight division all the way to victories in other weight classes and over Oscar Dela Hoya at 147 pounds last December.
Pacquiao is still considering and choosing among a star-studded cast of would-be opponents including Mosley, Mayweather, who is facing Juan Manuel Marquez in July, Cotto, and a host of others.
nobody at 147 has fought anyone as fast as pacquiao
But the question remains does manny have the power to take out these elite fighters in their primes. No way in a million years can pac match cotto/mayweather for power.
Pacquiao likes his opponents to walk on to shots and mosley is way too clever to ever get drawn into the sort of slugfest hatton tried and failed and is too fast and quick to get hit as often as dela hoya did.
Mosley in 12
one dangerous horrible bloke
Mosley need not worry about Mayweather, he just needs to keep doing what he does best and the big PPV will come. If Mosley gots the guts to go down to a catch weight and take a 60/40 split then surely Pacquiao would accept that, Manny would have a lot to gain. Although I like Mosley i'll have to say that he was wrong when he said his loss to Cotto could have gone either way, he lost it. I can see why Mosley is trying to speed up the process (because of his age) but he needs to make sure he doesn't go to extreme with this catch weight otherwise he's gonna end up in Pacquiao's viper pit. Another reason Mosley need not worry about Mayweather is because he may end up with a loss come July 18.
There are currently 1 users browsing this thread. (0 members and 1 guests)
Bookmarks