Thread: Using this criteria Who's ranked higher all time?

In-ring Performance
Achievements
Dominance
Mainstream Appeal


Marvin Hagler, BHop, RJJ, JCalzaghe, Antonio Tarver, Eubank, SRL, james toney, Sweet pea...

in ring performance
1-Leonard
2-Hagler
3-Jones Jr

Acheivements
1-Hagler
2-Leonard
3-Calzaghe

Dominance
1-Hagler
2-Leonard
3-Calzaghe

Mainstream appeal
1-Jones Jr
2-Eubank
3-Hagler

Originally Posted by JonesJrMayweather

In-ring Performance
Achievements
Dominance
Mainstream Appeal


Marvin Hagler, BHop, RJJ, JCalzaghe, Antonio Tarver, Eubank, SRL, james toney, Sweet pea...

Calzaghe - Eubank were never undisputed champion in their prime , so they dont count . ( I take it Eubank was put in as a joke ?)

I think Hagler is the most famous dominant champion , but its hard to say anything against SWEATPEA , hmmmm this is a tough one.
RJJ was the most talented all rounder.

EUBANK talked about in the same company of Toney, RJJ , Ray Leonard , SWEATPEA , Hagler , that is the funniest thing i have ever heard lol.

Originally Posted by Dark Lord Al

Originally Posted by JonesJrMayweather

In-ring Performance
Achievements
Dominance
Mainstream Appeal


Marvin Hagler, BHop, RJJ, JCalzaghe, Antonio Tarver, Eubank, SRL, james toney, Sweet pea...

Calzaghe - Eubank were never undisputed champion in their prime , so they dont count . ( I take it Eubank was put in as a joke ?)

I think Hagler is the most famous dominant champion , but its hard to say anything against SWEATPEA , hmmmm this is a tough one.
RJJ was the most talented all rounder.

EUBANK talked about in the same company of Toney, RJJ , Ray Leonard , SWEATPEA , Hagler , that is the funniest thing i have ever heard lol.

why exactly, because he never fought out of britain, not exactly his fault that the US didnt wanna know of eubank, benn and watson

Prime Eubank beats a prime Toney.....there i said it

Prime Toney beats anyone you care to mention (bar Superman)

As regards to the topic of this thread, i'd put Hagler at #1 for the majority of those criteria hence I'd have to say Hagler.

Originally Posted by hattonthehammer

Originally Posted by Dark Lord Al

Originally Posted by JonesJrMayweather

In-ring Performance
Achievements
Dominance
Mainstream Appeal


Marvin Hagler, BHop, RJJ, JCalzaghe, Antonio Tarver, Eubank, SRL, james toney, Sweet pea...

Calzaghe - Eubank were never undisputed champion in their prime , so they dont count . ( I take it Eubank was put in as a joke ?)

I think Hagler is the most famous dominant champion , but its hard to say anything against SWEATPEA , hmmmm this is a tough one.
RJJ was the most talented all rounder.

EUBANK talked about in the same company of Toney, RJJ , Ray Leonard , SWEATPEA , Hagler , that is the funniest thing i have ever heard lol.

why exactly, because he never fought out of britain, not exactly his fault that the US didnt wanna know of eubank, benn and watson

Prime Eubank beats a prime Toney.....there i said it

If thats your thoughts then its cool , but personally I think a guy who cant beat Dan Schommer , or Ray Close , isnt beating Toney.
By the way im aware Eubank got the verdict in both those fights.

Originally Posted by Dark Lord Al

Originally Posted by hattonthehammer

Originally Posted by Dark Lord Al

Calzaghe - Eubank were never undisputed champion in their prime , so they dont count . ( I take it Eubank was put in as a joke ?)

I think Hagler is the most famous dominant champion , but its hard to say anything against SWEATPEA , hmmmm this is a tough one.
RJJ was the most talented all rounder.

EUBANK talked about in the same company of Toney, RJJ , Ray Leonard , SWEATPEA , Hagler , that is the funniest thing i have ever heard lol.

why exactly, because he never fought out of britain, not exactly his fault that the US didnt wanna know of eubank, benn and watson

Prime Eubank beats a prime Toney.....there i said it

If thats your thoughts then its cool , but personally I think a guy who cant beat Dan Schommer , or Ray Close , isnt beating Toney.
By the way im aware Eubank got the verdict in both those fights.

understandably mate, but my argument being eubank beat what was put infront of him time and time again. Nothing you can do if the big fights dont come your way but to suggest for that reason he doesnt deserve to get a mention is a tad harsh

Originally Posted by Jimboogie

Prime Toney beats anyone you care to mention (bar Superman)

As regards to the topic of this thread, i'd put Hagler at #1 for the majority of those criteria hence I'd have to say Hagler.

anyone in the know how (not the moronic media who dont shutup about ali) will tell you the 2 sugar rays were the greatest fighters of all time.

Leonards record doesnt do him justice, for years he was 100% unbeatable and unable to fight against

Originally Posted by hattonthehammer

in ring performance
1-Leonard
2-Hagler
3-Jones Jr

Acheivements
1-Hagler
2-Leonard
3-Calzaghe

Dominance
1-Hagler
2-Leonard
3-Calzaghe

Mainstream appeal
1-Jones Jr
2-Eubank
3-Hagler

I believe Roy was more dominant than any of them and in ring performance roy rarely lost a round..and mainstream is a toss up between SRL,ROY,...Achievements is where its a bit "iffy" because roy achieved so much, but during a time where there was much more to achieve.


Guess I'd say Roy, then Hag or leonard, followed by BHOP...

Originally Posted by JonesJrMayweather

Originally Posted by hattonthehammer

in ring performance
1-Leonard
2-Hagler
3-Jones Jr

Acheivements
1-Hagler
2-Leonard
3-Calzaghe

Dominance
1-Hagler
2-Leonard
3-Calzaghe

Mainstream appeal
1-Jones Jr
2-Eubank
3-Hagler

I believe Roy was more dominant than any of them and in ring performance roy rarely lost a round..and mainstream is a toss up between SRL,ROY,...Achievements is where its a bit "iffy" because roy achieved so much, but during a time where there was much more to achieve.


Guess I'd say Roy, then Hag or leonard, followed by BHOP...

calzaghes NEVER being beat surely ranks as the most remarkable achievement of them all??

Originally Posted by JonesJrMayweather

Originally Posted by hattonthehammer

in ring performance
1-Leonard
2-Hagler
3-Jones Jr

Acheivements
1-Hagler
2-Leonard
3-Calzaghe

Dominance
1-Hagler
2-Leonard
3-Calzaghe

Mainstream appeal
1-Jones Jr
2-Eubank
3-Hagler

I believe Roy was more dominant than any of them and in ring performance roy rarely lost a round..and mainstream is a toss up between SRL,ROY,...Achievements is where its a bit "iffy" because roy achieved so much, but during a time where there was much more to achieve.


Guess I'd say Roy, then Hag or leonard, followed by BHOP...

Sorry mate but how the hell can you have Calzaghe ahead of RJJ in achievements? RJJ won world titles in Middle,super middle,light heavy and heavy??

I'd go with Hagler and Sweetpea for fulfilling the 1st 3 criteria and Leonard for filling the last one with mainstream appeal.

Sweetpea in his prime didn't lose a fight, the 1st Ramirez fight was a robbery for Pernell and I don't count that as a lost. Hagler did lose 2 fights, but that was when he was still green, when he became champ it was just pure domination against great competition and when he lost it was against a Leonard who did pitty pat punches in a bigger ring, bigger gloves, and a catchweight fight against an inactive Hagler.

Originally Posted by skel1983

Originally Posted by JonesJrMayweather

Originally Posted by hattonthehammer

in ring performance
1-Leonard
2-Hagler
3-Jones Jr

Acheivements
1-Hagler
2-Leonard
3-Calzaghe

Dominance
1-Hagler
2-Leonard
3-Calzaghe

Mainstream appeal
1-Jones Jr
2-Eubank
3-Hagler

I believe Roy was more dominant than any of them and in ring performance roy rarely lost a round..and mainstream is a toss up between SRL,ROY,...Achievements is where its a bit "iffy" because roy achieved so much, but during a time where there was much more to achieve.


Guess I'd say Roy, then Hag or leonard, followed by BHOP...

Sorry mate but how the hell can you have Calzaghe ahead of RJJ in achievements? RJJ won world titles in Middle,super middle,light heavy and heavy??

Was that for hitmanhatton or me?

Originally Posted by JonesJrMayweather

Originally Posted by skel1983

Originally Posted by JonesJrMayweather

I believe Roy was more dominant than any of them and in ring performance roy rarely lost a round..and mainstream is a toss up between SRL,ROY,...Achievements is where its a bit "iffy" because roy achieved so much, but during a time where there was much more to achieve.


Guess I'd say Roy, then Hag or leonard, followed by BHOP...

Sorry mate but how the hell can you have Calzaghe ahead of RJJ in achievements? RJJ won world titles in Middle,super middle,light heavy and heavy??

Was that for hitmanhatton or me?

Not you lol I think it's safe to say you wouldn't rank Calzaghe ahead of RJJ in anything.

It was for Hammer.

Originally Posted by JonesJrMayweather

In-ring Performance
Achievements
Dominance
Mainstream Appeal


Marvin Hagler, BHop, RJJ, JCalzaghe, Antonio Tarver, Eubank, SRL, james toney, Sweet pea...

In Ring Performance
SRL- His fights w Duran, Hearns, Hagler alone dwarf the comp of everyone on the list but PW

Achievements-
SRL we have to go by quality of opp, amount of titles etc

Dominance
Hagler absolutely ruled the MW division and beat his opp silly

Mainstream appeal-
SRL this guy in the 80's was DLH, Pacquiao, and everyone else on the list rolled into one...Those who don't realize the popularity of Leonard in his hey day are too young to have been around back then...He was the face of Boxing after Ali retired