Thread: how would sergio martinez fare against pacquiao/mayweather??

Long time admirer of sergio since his stint in the states. But for the first williams fight and the refereeing in the cintron fight he has pretty much cleaned up 2 divisions in half a dozen or so fights

i honestly now see sergio beating both cotto and margarito which leads me to the question of how well he would fair against the 2 future hall of famers and boxing greats of our time

lets say its catchweight anywhere between 150-152 - how does sergio fair against either fighter??

Originally Posted by HattonTheHammer

Long time admirer of sergio since his stint in the states. But for the first williams fight and the refereeing in the cintron fight he has pretty much cleaned up 2 divisions in half a dozen or so fights

i honestly now see sergio beating both cotto and margarito which leads me to the question of how well he would fair against the 2 future hall of famers and boxing greats of our time

lets say its catchweight anywhere between 150-152 - how does sergio fair against either fighter??

At that weight he'd lose, mainly because he said he can't get below 155 anymore, so at 150 the man would be a corpse. If it was at a catchweight of 155, I think he'd have a chance against Pac, mainly because as he's going up in weight Pac is feeling the weight of some of those shots and Sergio is no mug. Mayweather would be interesting, but I'd think Mayweather would be able to outbox him.

Like BZKFN said I can't see martinez under 155 any more but at MW IMO he beats both....Unlike Mosley if Martinez hurt Mayweather he would not back off he would go in for the kill plus he has 1 punch power and he is damn fast for a 36yr old MW and he uses the ring to his advantage has great foot work and will box with his hands up if he feels as though there is a chance he is going to get caught........At lower weights I can't say but at 160 Martinez beats them both....This guy is not second rate fighter and he deserves his #3 P4P ranking for sure....I actually put him at #2 since Floyd is only a part time fighter these days

Originally Posted by bzkfn

Originally Posted by HattonTheHammer

Long time admirer of sergio since his stint in the states. But for the first williams fight and the refereeing in the cintron fight he has pretty much cleaned up 2 divisions in half a dozen or so fights

i honestly now see sergio beating both cotto and margarito which leads me to the question of how well he would fair against the 2 future hall of famers and boxing greats of our time

lets say its catchweight anywhere between 150-152 - how does sergio fair against either fighter??

At that weight he'd lose, mainly because he said he can't get below 155 anymore, so at 150 the man would be a corpse. If it was at a catchweight of 155, I think he'd have a chance against Pac, mainly because as he's going up in weight Pac is feeling the weight of some of those shots and Sergio is no mug. Mayweather would be interesting, but I'd think Mayweather would be able to outbox him.

At 154 or above he beats Pacquiao. Mayweather would be tough. But, I'll be honest, I think he has a very tough fight in Dzinziruk coming up. Let's see him get by Sergiy first.

I honestly think they both take him, Sergio has shown the ability to land a huge shot like he did on Paul Williams in the first round of their first fight, and the lefthands he landed on PW and Cintron respectively. However Floyd is obviously harder to hit than either of them. Both Pacquiao and Mayweather are faster than him which has been Sergio's biggest advantage, and because of his poorer balance and basics the two of them would have a way to exploit things slower guys can't. Martinez isn't a great boxer, he's a tremendous athlete with good cooditioning and a really awkward style with a lot of speed.

I think Martinez beats them both, as long as it's not below 155. He has some speed, and the one punch power to drop both of them. Both Pac and Floyd don't have enough power to do any real damage to him, and Martinez boxing skills can hang around with both of them. He also has about a 4" height advantage over Pac, and about 2 " on Floyd, and i think he will be too big for both of them.

Originally Posted by MMASUX

I think Martinez beats them both, as long as it's not below 155. He has some speed, and the one punch power to drop both of them. Both Pac and Floyd don't have enough power to do any real damage to him, and Martinez boxing skills can hang around with both of them. He also has about a 4" height advantage over Pac, and about 2 " on Floyd, and i think he will be too big for both of them.

I agree. Because of his size, skill, and unorthodox style, I think Martinez is the only man in boxing who has a good chance of beating Pac or Mayweather.

He's simply too big for them to fight though.

UNLESSS it was at 154. Nothing below that however or it would drain Martinez too much as others have said.

Probably beat both but Floyd stands a better chance.

Just looked at his record, he fought our Richard Willams twice and Adrian Stone, but have no memory of him coming here.

He also lost to Margarito, so that would be a good return.

Great chance that he beats them both at Middleweight (Floyd and Pac never fought beyond 154 )


I'll favor the two @155 and below.

Originally Posted by MMASUX

I think Martinez beats them both, as long as it's not below 155. He has some speed, and the one punch power to drop both of them. Both Pac and Floyd don't have enough power to do any real damage to him, and Martinez boxing skills can hang around with both of them. He also has about a 4" height advantage over Pac, and about 2 " on Floyd, and i think he will be too big for both of them.

How can you say they don't have the power to do real damage to him? Pacquiao badly hurt Margarito, turned Clottey into a punching bag, and dropped Cotto. Floyd made both Oscar De La Hoya and Shane Mosley feel his power. People don't realize that smaller guys can still hurt bigger opponents even if they can't take them out. It's like saying Martinez wouldn't be able to hurt Pavlik because he was a natural 154 pounder or welterweight and Pavlik was a really big middleweight.

I still don't think Martinez for the most part is a big puncher, I think one in a thousand shots he lands might be enough to ko Floyd or Pacman, but the likelihood of him landing one of those punches that neither of these guys see is unlikely.

Originally Posted by Taeth

Originally Posted by MMASUX

I think Martinez beats them both, as long as it's not below 155. He has some speed, and the one punch power to drop both of them. Both Pac and Floyd don't have enough power to do any real damage to him, and Martinez boxing skills can hang around with both of them. He also has about a 4" height advantage over Pac, and about 2 " on Floyd, and i think he will be too big for both of them.

How can you say they don't have the power to do real damage to him? Pacquiao badly hurt Margarito, turned Clottey into a punching bag, and dropped Cotto. Floyd made both Oscar De La Hoya and Shane Mosley feel his power. People don't realize that smaller guys can still hurt bigger opponents even if they can't take them out. It's like saying Martinez wouldn't be able to hurt Pavlik because he was a natural 154 pounder or welterweight and Pavlik was a really big middleweight.

I still don't think Martinez for the most part is a big puncher, I think one in a thousand shots he lands might be enough to ko Floyd or Pacman, but the likelihood of him landing one of those punches that neither of these guys see is unlikely.

I don't believe Pacquiao is big enough to fight the best middleweight in the world. P4P he is better but he is too small for Martinez. He reached his limit at 150, which is why he has opted to go back down to 147 to fight Mosley. His team would sign up to fight Martinez if they had the same confidence you had. Instead, they decided to fight Shane Mosley and I bet Juan Manuel Marquez in his next fight. We can agree on the fact that Shane right now at 147 and Marquez right now at 147 are easier fights for Pacquiao than Sergio Martinez above 155. Right? Anyway, Sergio is #3/4 p4p in the world on most people's lists and Shane isn't even on lists. He isn't a bigger name either.

Floyd fought effectively at 154 against Oscar, which is why I'm hesitant to say that Martinez is too big for him.

Originally Posted by miron_lang

Great chance that he beats them both at Middleweight (Floyd and Pac never fought beyond 154 )


I'll favor the two @155 and below.

I think so too

Originally Posted by :::PSL:::

Originally Posted by miron_lang

Great chance that he beats them both at Middleweight (Floyd and Pac never fought beyond 154 )


I'll favor the two @155 and below.

I think so too

PSL does your sig lady star in any porn and if so can you direct me to it for research purposes?

Originally Posted by Master

Originally Posted by :::PSL:::

Originally Posted by miron_lang

Great chance that he beats them both at Middleweight (Floyd and Pac never fought beyond 154 )


I'll favor the two @155 and below.

I think so too

PSL does your sig lady star in any porn and if so can you direct me to it for research purposes?

Master, your gonna go fuckin blind son, i'm tellin ya. Just go easy on all this porn for the good of your own health, ha.

In response to the thread question, I'd be over the god damn moon if we could actually see an outcome for real, shit, that would make my boxing year, any one of the match-ups will do please.

Originally Posted by Taeth

Originally Posted by MMASUX

I think Martinez beats them both, as long as it's not below 155. He has some speed, and the one punch power to drop both of them. Both Pac and Floyd don't have enough power to do any real damage to him, and Martinez boxing skills can hang around with both of them. He also has about a 4" height advantage over Pac, and about 2 " on Floyd, and i think he will be too big for both of them.

How can you say they don't have the power to do real damage to him? Pacquiao badly hurt Margarito, turned Clottey into a punching bag, and dropped Cotto. Floyd made both Oscar De La Hoya and Shane Mosley feel his power. People don't realize that smaller guys can still hurt bigger opponents even if they can't take them out. It's like saying Martinez wouldn't be able to hurt Pavlik because he was a natural 154 pounder or welterweight and Pavlik was a really big middleweight.

I still don't think Martinez for the most part is a big puncher, I think one in a thousand shots he lands might be enough to ko Floyd or Pacman, but the likelihood of him landing one of those punches that neither of these guys see is unlikely.

Yes pac hurt Margs, whos is a slow come straight forward fighter. We can all agree Clottey didn't come to fight, and he was never hurt in the fight. He just stood there and covered up. And yes he dropped a past his prime Cotto. This is not to take anything away from Pac, he came in and took care of business. Cotto and Clottey probably came in fight night around 155 and margs probably 160. Now come fight night with Martinez he's probably going to be 170 lbs. And from his last few fights Pac is only rehydrating a few pounds, and is struggling to make the limit for that matter. So a 150 lb Pac vs a 170 lb Martinez...i got Martinez any day. just too big for Manny to do any damage. But if anybody was to prove me wrong it would be Pac.