Thread: Who could beat Kell Brook?

Originally Posted by erics44

Mods can we change the title of the thread please

Haha

Originally Posted by FinitoElDinamita

Originally Posted by Silkeyjoe

Originally Posted by erics44

a lot of love for brook in this thread

not too long ago on this very forum I was having a very nice chat with someone about brooks credentials, probably only a couple of fights ago

it was specifically about how berto v
brook would turn out


obviously the person I was debating with was suggesting that Berto would run away with it, brook would be stopped fairly easily


looks a bit daft that now doesnt it



the first carston jones fight was
Brooks worst performance by a long
way

in the second jones wasn't anywhere near him, yeah he had a good couple of rounds but still came nowhere near winning any round
and was looking very unsteady from
early on

I reckon Berton would still smoke him. He lost to Karas Soto but was fighting with one arm for most of the fight. Berto has speed and power.
Brook hasnt fought anyonne of
Bertos level and Senchenko isnt really a step up.

Precisely. Id pick Berto as well. People keep shitting on this guy but he knows how to dig deep and has
proved himself in seesaw battles.
ORtiz fight could have easily gone his way and he took Guerrero to hell and back with one eye closed. And as you mentioned, he fought Karass neck and neck with one arm so we definitely know what he's capable of
under adversity.


It wasn't long ago when Berto was the pampered fighter with a padded record and I can't believe he's been through so much in short period of
time..


Brook is in that position now. He needs to show that he can hold his own even in a grueling fight against an elite opposition and until he does
that, there's no reason why anybody
should pick him over a proven warrior like Berto.

This sechenko fight is fuckin weak. He's actually taking a step back from Jones' level..

I agree the senchenko fight was abit of let down but how is this a step down from Jones. Jones is shocking, he had the fight of his life in his first fight with brook but was exposed easily in the second fight.

Kell does need to prove himself though.

Does anyone know why he changed his ring name to Special K rather than the special one??

Originally Posted by Fettled_Man

Originally Posted by FinitoElDinamita

Originally Posted by Silkeyjoe

Originally Posted by erics44

a lot of love for brook in this thread

not too long ago on this very forum I was having a very nice chat with someone about brooks credentials, probably only a couple of fights ago

it was specifically about how berto v
brook would turn out


obviously the person I was debating with was suggesting that Berto would run away with it, brook would be stopped fairly easily


looks a bit daft that now doesnt it



the first carston jones fight was
Brooks worst performance by a long
way

in the second jones wasn't anywhere near him, yeah he had a good couple of rounds but still came nowhere near winning any round
and was looking very unsteady from
early on

I reckon Berton would still smoke him. He lost to Karas Soto but was fighting with one arm for most of the fight. Berto has speed and power.
Brook hasnt fought anyonne of
Bertos level and Senchenko isnt really a step up.

Precisely. Id pick Berto as well. People keep shitting on this guy but he knows how to dig deep and has
proved himself in seesaw battles.
ORtiz fight could have easily gone his way and he took Guerrero to hell and back with one eye closed. And as you mentioned, he fought Karass neck and neck with one arm so we definitely know what he's capable of
under adversity.


It wasn't long ago when Berto was the pampered fighter with a padded record and I can't believe he's been through so much in short period of
time..


Brook is in that position now. He needs to show that he can hold his own even in a grueling fight against an elite opposition and until he does
that, there's no reason why anybody
should pick him over a proven warrior like Berto.

This sechenko fight is fuckin weak. He's actually taking a step back from Jones' level..

I agree the senchenko fight was abit of let down but how is this a step down from Jones. Jones is shocking, he had the fight of his life in his first fight with brook but was exposed easily in the second fight.

Kell does need to prove himself though.

Does anyone know why he changed his ring name to Special K rather than the special one??

Yes he changed his name from the special one to - Special K because he fights more like a packet of cereal , than a blessed fighter.