If Floyd can beat Khan and Pac, I will say he is an ATG

[brocktonblockbust]

But if he fights bums, cherry-picked and vacuum-packed for freshness, then he is a GOAT.

[El Kabong]

Have to consider him a great because he has beaten everyone he has fought. Now I don't think he's "The Greatest" because I don't think his era was all that amazing, but he made challenges for himself where he could...he also took the risk away from a few fights but whatever the man has performed in the ring and that's all you can ask for.

[g3org3]

Khan is all risk and no reward if they do fight I'm putting a bet on khan to win on points

[Master]

Floyd is a great fighter and I hate him. If Floyd fought Cotto and Manny that would be exciting.

[Dark Lord Al]

But if he fights bums, cherry-picked and vacuum-packed for freshness, then he is a GOAT.

I really do not care for floyd , however if he if didn't box again he is an ATG and the finest fighter for many years. He should be mentioned in the same breath as Srr and SRL , he is that good . Let us not forget Ray Leonard had been beaten several times by the time he reach his mid thirties , floyd has nothing to prove he has already done enough to be an ATG. I will repeat I do not care for him as a person , but let's not let hatred get in the way of achievement .

[imp]

Floyd is a great fighter and I hate him. If Floyd fought Cotto and Manny that would be exciting.

Cotto should fight manny at 154.

[Master]

Floyd is a great fighter and I hate him. If Floyd fought Cotto and Manny that would be exciting.

Cotto should fight manny at 154.

Manny will never go up to 154lb after Margarito and he is considering moving down to 140lb so doubt it.

Could see Floyd try and take the middleweight title from Cotto - not GGG.

[mikeeod]

Floyd is already an ATG. I don't know how much a win over Manny would do for his standing at this point. Back in 09-11, that win is much more impressive. GGG win would impress me and put Floyd in my top ten. Had he beaten prime Williams, Wright, Kostya, Shane, Margarito, Cotto and Manny, even 3 of those guys, he's in my top 5. Not saying he sucked them or it was all his fault, just saying that is what it would've take to get him there in my rankings.