Cotto vs Mayweather who does everyone think is ACTUALLY better?!

[cockey cockney]

i dont necesarily mean who would win this fight becuase everyone knows in boxing one punch can win or lose a fight. I mean after all the hate for PBF i wonder if this means they actaully think Cotto is the better boxer. Im voting for PBF straight up becuase i feel he is more rounded defensively and more accurate. Thoughts??

[shza]

There's not really any question is there? PBF is recognized by every major industry publication and website as the #1 P4P fighter in the world. Cotto isn't.

[LEGION]

PBF is the better boxer.

[The Rookie Fan]

Oh come on, this is silly. Of course PBF is better. The question is can Cotto beat him. It is not always the same.

P.S. We have yet to see the best of Cotto.

[Deanrw]

Ahh. I voted Cotto but interpreted the question wrong. Mayweather is much more skilled and the better boxer. That does not always translate to a win though.

My vote went to Cotto by accident, as I do think he can take Mayweather. More skilled fighters lose all the time, you only have to look back to Taylor/Pavlik to see that it can happen.

[leftylee]

Mayweather without doubt

[Mar]

Right now mayweather is clearly the best there is nothing can be said of what he does in the ring. None of these current opponets bring anything new or anything that poses a threat to floyd. The only thing that will beat floyd is time and age.

[CFH]

Mayweather and its not even close

[cockey cockney]

yeah i know it seems very obvious. But in the UK especially you hear soooo many people saying things like he doesnt fight he runs, etc etc. And there are some and ino its only a few Cotto fans who slate Mayweather for being overated! The question is aimed at those really, just checking boxing hasnt lost its mind more then anything!

[Tysonbruno]

MAYWEATHER ALL THE WAY BABY!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

[Irish Rover]

Dont know why anybody would hate either boxer. Sure as a person Floyd comes across as a dick but both him and Cotto are very good boxers and are what this sport needs.


I love both guys. I think Mayweather is the better boxer but a Cotto fight would be no walk over whatsoever....thats what makes it so mouthwatering

[The Fightfan]

This is a very good topic.You do have to look at what Mayweather did to Judah than what Cotto did to Judah.It is clear enough that Cotto does have a great chance at beating Floyd.Better than Hatton did anyway.If Mayweather does do his thing and a take brief break and Cotto keeps fighting.Mayweather would be rusty enough for Cotto to beat him.So if I'm Floyd I have an easy tune-up for the build up of a huge fight with Cotto by next summer.

[Kel]

Floyd is the better fighter but that doesnt mean Cotto could not beat him.

[Violent Demise]

yeah i know it seems very obvious. But in the UK especially you hear soooo many people saying things like he doesnt fight he runs, etc etc. And there are some and ino its only a few Cotto fans who slate Mayweather for being overated! The question is aimed at those really, just checking boxing hasnt lost its mind more then anything!

A lot of people in the UK don't really know much about boxing.

[shza]

But in the UK especially you hear soooo many people saying things like he doesnt fight he runs, etc etc.

They're not still saying that over there now, are they?