ICE COLD'S Top Ten Most Controversial Decisions Do You Agree

[ICB]

Lennox Lewis vs Evander Holyfield 1 = Robbery

Ken Norton vs Muhammad Ali 3 = One of the closest fights in history

Pernell Whitaker vs Julio Cesar Chavez = Robbery

Bernard Hopkins vs Jermain Taylor 1 = Very close fight

Michael Spinks vs Larry Holmes 2 = Robbery

Tim Witherspoon vs Larry Holmes = So damn close i can't split them

Jose Luis Ramirez vs Pernell Whitaker 1 = Robbery

Sugar Ray Leonard vs Marvin Hagler = Again so damn close

Sugar Ray Leonard vs Thomas Hearns 2 = Robbery

Oscar Delahoya vs Pernell Whitaker = Close but i feel Whitaker edged it.

[Beanflicker]

I agree with your list, expecially on the Sweet Pea fights. The De La Hoya fight was very close, so although I think Sweet Pea did win the fight, when a fight is very close I won't call it a robbery. But I finally saw the Ramirez fight last night, and that and the Chavez fights were complete robberies IMO.

AUGUSTUS vs BURTON = Robbery
James Toney vs Tiberi = Robbery, James came in out of shape and payed for it
James Toney vs Sam Peter 1 = I thought James schooled Peter, I had him winning 8 rounds to 4.

[VictorCharlie]

ODH vs SMM II
If Lennox v Holy I hadn't been such a bad decision then the second fight would have been a huge controversy. Both the AP press and Ring Magazine had Holyfied as the winner, but this is often left out. Its like it was a makeup for the first decision. There should have been a third fight.

and although it wasn't a decisoin
Meldrick Taylor vs Chavez

[Beanflicker]

and although it wasn't a decisoin
Meldrick Taylor vs Chavez

You can say that again, maybe the most heartbreaking robbery I've ever seen.

[Preme]

Barrera v morales I i thought was bullshit oscar v Ike was close too

[althetruthhindley]

most of Chris Eubanks points wins !!!!!!!!!!!!!
Willie Jorin v Mike Brodie wot the fuck were the judges watching that day ?

[Tito BHB]

Barrera - morales

Toney - Griffin 1 + 2

Toney - peter

Barrera - marquez.. The scores

[ICB]

Oscar vs Tito another controversial fight.

[ICB]

most of Chris Eubanks points wins !!!!!!!!!!!!!
Willie Jorin v Mike Brodie wot the F*** were the judges watching that day ?

You know what i agree with some of that i thought Watson won first fight vs Eubank and i thought Benn should of won rematch and i haven't seen it but Ray Austin fights were mighty close as well by score cards.

[VictorCharlie]

Oscar vs Tito another controversial fight.

damn skippy...can't believe I forgot that one

[Gandalf]

Barrera - morales

Toney - Griffin 1 + 2

Toney - peter

Barrera - marquez.. The scores

Nice list, BHB

Each of those judicial decisions bothered me!!