Floyd Mayweather Jr Vs Some Of The Great Superfeatherweights

[ICB]

Mayweather was amazing at Superfeatherweight he also had much more exciting style at Superfeatherweight being boxing/puncher but how would he fare against some of the best Superfeatherweights ??



I'll create the match ups you tell me who wins and why.


Floyd Mayweather Jr vs Alexis Arguello = Mayweather by close decision.

Floyd Mayweather Jr vs Azumah Nelson = Mayweather by close decision.

Floyd Mayweather Jr vs Erik Morales = Mayweather by close decision.

Floyd Mayweather Jr vs MAB = Mayweather by close decision.

Floyd Mayweather Jr vs Manny Pacquiao = Mayweather by wide UD.

Floyd Mayweather Jr vs Oscar De La Hoya = Mayweather by UD.

Floyd Mayweather Jr vs Joel Casamayor = Mayweather by UD.

Floyd Mayweather Jr vs Roger Mayweather = Mayweather Jr by 6th round KO.

Floyd Mayweather Jr vs Wilfredo Gomez = Mayweather by Late TKO.

Floyd Mayweather Jr vs Juan Manuel Marquez = Mayweather by close decision.

Floyd Mayweather Jr vs Julio Cesar Chavez = Mayweather by wide UD.

Floyd Mayweather Jr vs Hector Camacho = Mayweather by UD.

Floyd Mayweather Jr vs Joan Guzman = Mayweather by UD.


What would Mayweather's record look like had he fought these opponents ??


I could honestly see Mayweather going undefeated he was that good at Superfeatherweight. I mean guys like Morales, Barrera, Gomez, wern't as good at Superfeatherweight i know people may think im being very biased but i honestly believe Mayweather was almost unbeatable at Superfeatherweight.

[ICB]

No replies yet ?? i created this thread so we could get some good debating going on here i know alot of people are going to disagree but come and make your points.

[Fenster]

I'd give you 500/1 Floyd beats all those fighters.

If he fought ALL those guys, i'd bet he loses at least 4/5 times.

[ICB]

I'd give you 500/1 Floyd beats all those fighters.

If he fought ALL those guys, i'd bet he loses at least 4/5 times.

Who do you think he loses too ??

[Fenster]

I'd give you 500/1 Floyd beats all those fighters.

If he fought ALL those guys, i'd bet he loses at least 4/5 times.

Who do you think he loses too ??

Could be any of them. You can break it down however you like BUT...

..the superb level of form ALL those guys have achieved would make it a MIRACLE for ONE man to defeat the lot.

[CutMeMick]

Not really comment on the fights but more of the title of this thread reads as follows:
Title: Floyd Mayweather Jr Vs Alltime Great Superfeatherweights

The red area reads All-Time Great, and either I must be missing something here but since when are these guys all time great Super Feathers?

Floyd Mayweather Jr vs Roger Mayweather = Mayweather Jr by 6th round KO.
Floyd Mayweather Jr vs Hector Camacho = Mayweather by UD.
Floyd Mayweather Jr vs Joan Guzman = Mayweather by UD.

[Tysonbruno]

Mayweather was amazing at Superfeatherweight he also had much more exciting style at Superfeatherweight being boxing/puncher but how would he fare against some of the best Superfeatherweights ??



I'll create the match ups you tell me who wins and why.


Floyd Mayweather Jr vs Alexis Arguello = Mayweather by close decision.

Floyd Mayweather Jr vs Azumah Nelson = Mayweather by close decision.

Floyd Mayweather Jr vs Erik Morales = Mayweather by close decision.

Floyd Mayweather Jr vs MAB = Mayweather by close decision.

Floyd Mayweather Jr vs Manny Pacquiao = Mayweather by wide UD.

Floyd Mayweather Jr vs Oscar De La Hoya = Mayweather by UD.

Floyd Mayweather Jr vs Joel Casamayor = Mayweather by UD.

Floyd Mayweather Jr vs Roger Mayweather = Mayweather Jr by 6th round KO.

Floyd Mayweather Jr vs Wilfredo Gomez = Mayweather by Late TKO.

Floyd Mayweather Jr vs Juan Manuel Marquez = Mayweather by close decision.

Floyd Mayweather Jr vs Julio Cesar Chavez = Mayweather by wide UD.

Floyd Mayweather Jr vs Hector Camacho = Mayweather by UD.

Floyd Mayweather Jr vs Joan Guzman = Mayweather by UD.


What would Mayweather's record look like had he fought these opponents ??


I could honestly see Mayweather going undefeated he was that good at Superfeatherweight. I mean guys like Morales, Barrera, Gomez, wern't as good at Superfeatherweight i know people may think im being very biased but i honestly believe Mayweather was almost unbeatable at Superfeatherweight.

I would agree with this Barrera,Morales,Marquez and Pac would'nt have been able to touch Mayweather at 130lbs

[ICB]

Not really comment on the fights but more of the title of this thread reads as follows:
Title: Floyd Mayweather Jr Vs Alltime Great Superfeatherweights

The red area reads All-Time Great, and either I must be missing something here but since when are these guys all time great Super Feathers?

Floyd Mayweather Jr vs Roger Mayweather = Mayweather Jr by 6th round KO.
Floyd Mayweather Jr vs Hector Camacho = Mayweather by UD.
Floyd Mayweather Jr vs Joan Guzman = Mayweather by UD.

My mistake i worded it wrong i will change it.

But lets hear your opinion on the fights.

[BoomBoom]

Floyd Mayweather Jr vs Alexis Arguello = Mayweather by close decision.

Floyd Mayweather Jr vs Azumah Nelson = Mayweather by close decision.

Floyd Mayweather Jr vs Erik Morales = Mayweather by close decision.

Floyd Mayweather Jr vs MAB = Barrera by close decision.

Floyd Mayweather Jr vs Manny Pacquiao = Pacquiao by close UD.

Floyd Mayweather Jr vs Oscar De La Hoya = ODLH by SD or MD.

Floyd Mayweather Jr vs Joel Casamayor = Mayweather by UD.

Floyd Mayweather Jr vs Roger Mayweather = Mayweather Jr by 6th round KO.

Floyd Mayweather Jr vs Wilfredo Gomez = Mayweather by TKO.

Floyd Mayweather Jr vs Juan Manuel Marquez = Marquez by close decision.

Floyd Mayweather Jr vs Julio Cesar Chavez = Chavez by UD.

Floyd Mayweather Jr vs Hector Camacho = Mayweather by UD.

Floyd Mayweather Jr vs Joan Guzman = Mayweather by UD.

[THE THIRD MAN]

Mayweather was amazing at Superfeatherweight he also had much more exciting style at Superfeatherweight being boxing/puncher but how would he fare against some of the best Superfeatherweights ??



I'll create the match ups you tell me who wins and why.


Floyd Mayweather Jr vs Alexis Arguello = Mayweather by close decision.

Floyd Mayweather Jr vs Azumah Nelson = Mayweather by close decision.

Floyd Mayweather Jr vs Erik Morales = Mayweather by close decision.

Floyd Mayweather Jr vs MAB = Mayweather by close decision.

Floyd Mayweather Jr vs Manny Pacquiao = Mayweather by wide UD.

Floyd Mayweather Jr vs Oscar De La Hoya = Mayweather by UD.

Floyd Mayweather Jr vs Joel Casamayor = Mayweather by UD.

Floyd Mayweather Jr vs Roger Mayweather = Mayweather Jr by 6th round KO.

Floyd Mayweather Jr vs Wilfredo Gomez = Mayweather by Late TKO.

Floyd Mayweather Jr vs Juan Manuel Marquez = Mayweather by close decision.

Floyd Mayweather Jr vs Julio Cesar Chavez = Mayweather by wide UD.

Floyd Mayweather Jr vs Hector Camacho = Mayweather by UD.

Floyd Mayweather Jr vs Joan Guzman = Mayweather by UD.


What would Mayweather's record look like had he fought these opponents ??


I could honestly see Mayweather going undefeated he was that good at Superfeatherweight. I mean guys like Morales, Barrera, Gomez, wern't as good at Superfeatherweight i know people may think im being very biased but i honestly believe Mayweather was almost unbeatable at Superfeatherweight.

I have Mayweather winning all of these with question marks agaisnt Arguello, Nelson and Gomez.
I give a prime Azumah Nelson the best chance of beating PBF, the Professor was a tough fighter and just as clever as PBF. Arguello was tall and had wonderful skills plus a wicked left hook. Gomez had massive power in both hands and i would argue that PBF would have stopped him. Would love to know your reasoning for a PBF KO win ICE? I give PBF a UD over Gomez.
Oddly enough a mid 80's Camacho would have given Floyd some trouble, we tend to forget that Camacho was very good early in his career and really has only been beaten by the elite.

[ICB]

Mayweather was amazing at Superfeatherweight he also had much more exciting style at Superfeatherweight being boxing/puncher but how would he fare against some of the best Superfeatherweights ??



I'll create the match ups you tell me who wins and why.


Floyd Mayweather Jr vs Alexis Arguello = Mayweather by close decision.

Floyd Mayweather Jr vs Azumah Nelson = Mayweather by close decision.

Floyd Mayweather Jr vs Erik Morales = Mayweather by close decision.

Floyd Mayweather Jr vs MAB = Mayweather by close decision.

Floyd Mayweather Jr vs Manny Pacquiao = Mayweather by wide UD.

Floyd Mayweather Jr vs Oscar De La Hoya = Mayweather by UD.

Floyd Mayweather Jr vs Joel Casamayor = Mayweather by UD.

Floyd Mayweather Jr vs Roger Mayweather = Mayweather Jr by 6th round KO.

Floyd Mayweather Jr vs Wilfredo Gomez = Mayweather by Late TKO.

Floyd Mayweather Jr vs Juan Manuel Marquez = Mayweather by close decision.

Floyd Mayweather Jr vs Julio Cesar Chavez = Mayweather by wide UD.

Floyd Mayweather Jr vs Hector Camacho = Mayweather by UD.

Floyd Mayweather Jr vs Joan Guzman = Mayweather by UD.


What would Mayweather's record look like had he fought these opponents ??


I could honestly see Mayweather going undefeated he was that good at Superfeatherweight. I mean guys like Morales, Barrera, Gomez, wern't as good at Superfeatherweight i know people may think im being very biased but i honestly believe Mayweather was almost unbeatable at Superfeatherweight.

I have Mayweather winning all of these with question marks agaisnt Arguello, Nelson and Gomez.
I give a prime Azumah Nelson the best chance of beating PBF, the Professor was a tough fighter and just as clever as PBF. Arguello was tall and had wonderful skills plus a wicked left hook. Gomez had massive power in both hands and i would argue that PBF would have stopped him. Would love to know your reasoning for a PBF KO win ICE? I give PBF a UD over Gomez.
Oddly enough a mid 80's Camacho would have given Floyd some trouble, we tend to forget that Camacho was very good early in his career and really has only been beaten by the elite.

Gomez wern't as good at Superfeatherweight he was stopped in 9 by Alfredo Layne who was 13-5 fighter. TKO win for Mayweather isn't out of the question.

[Violent Demise]

Joan Guzman is great at 130? Based on what? Soto and Barrios are good fighters, but beating them does not make you great

[ICB]

Joan Guzman is great at 130? Based on what? Soto and Barrios are good fighters, but beating them does not make you great

I mean skill wise he is great, these match ups just popped up into my head first.

[THE THIRD MAN]

Mayweather was amazing at Superfeatherweight he also had much more exciting style at Superfeatherweight being boxing/puncher but how would he fare against some of the best Superfeatherweights ??



I'll create the match ups you tell me who wins and why.


Floyd Mayweather Jr vs Alexis Arguello = Mayweather by close decision.

Floyd Mayweather Jr vs Azumah Nelson = Mayweather by close decision.

Floyd Mayweather Jr vs Erik Morales = Mayweather by close decision.

Floyd Mayweather Jr vs MAB = Mayweather by close decision.

Floyd Mayweather Jr vs Manny Pacquiao = Mayweather by wide UD.

Floyd Mayweather Jr vs Oscar De La Hoya = Mayweather by UD.

Floyd Mayweather Jr vs Joel Casamayor = Mayweather by UD.

Floyd Mayweather Jr vs Roger Mayweather = Mayweather Jr by 6th round KO.

Floyd Mayweather Jr vs Wilfredo Gomez = Mayweather by Late TKO.

Floyd Mayweather Jr vs Juan Manuel Marquez = Mayweather by close decision.

Floyd Mayweather Jr vs Julio Cesar Chavez = Mayweather by wide UD.

Floyd Mayweather Jr vs Hector Camacho = Mayweather by UD.

Floyd Mayweather Jr vs Joan Guzman = Mayweather by UD.


What would Mayweather's record look like had he fought these opponents ??


I could honestly see Mayweather going undefeated he was that good at Superfeatherweight. I mean guys like Morales, Barrera, Gomez, wern't as good at Superfeatherweight i know people may think im being very biased but i honestly believe Mayweather was almost unbeatable at Superfeatherweight.

I have Mayweather winning all of these with question marks agaisnt Arguello, Nelson and Gomez.
I give a prime Azumah Nelson the best chance of beating PBF, the Professor was a tough fighter and just as clever as PBF. Arguello was tall and had wonderful skills plus a wicked left hook. Gomez had massive power in both hands and i would argue that PBF would have stopped him. Would love to know your reasoning for a PBF KO win ICE? I give PBF a UD over Gomez.
Oddly enough a mid 80's Camacho would have given Floyd some trouble, we tend to forget that Camacho was very good early in his career and really has only been beaten by the elite.

Gomez wern't as good at Superfeatherweight he was stopped in 9 by Alfredo Layne who was 13-5 fighter. TKO win for Mayweather isn't out of the question.

My Bad, got confused with super bantam and super feather, yep Gomez would go down at Super Feather against PBF.

[DIOS DOMINICANO]

Here is one outside opinion..for discussion:

MIKE CASEY'S ALL-TIME TOP 20

01. Alexis Arguello (Nicaragua)


02. Julio Cesar Chavez (Mexico)


03. Kid Chocolate (Cuba)


04. Sandy Saddler (USA)


05. Floyd Mayweather Jnr (USA)


06. Azumah Nelson (Ghana)


07. Alfredo Escalera (Puerto Rico)


08. Tod Morgan (USA)


09. Johnny Dundee (USA)


10. Flash Elorde (Philippines)


11. Samuel Serrano (Puerto Rico)


12. Bobby Chacon (USA)


13. Cornelius Boza Edwards (England)


14. Brian Mitchell (South Africa)


15. Tony Lopez (USA)


16. Wilfredo Gomez (Puerto Rico)


17. Benny Bass (USA)


18. Rafael (Bazooka) Limon (Mexico)


19. Rocky Lockridge (USA)


20. Hiroshi Kobayashi (Japan)