Top 10 P4P after Pac/Marquez

[gest12645]

How do you have it:
Here's mine:

1. Pac
2. Floyd
3. Martinez
4. Marquez
5. Donaire
6. Wlad
7. Vitali
8. Ward
9. Hopkins
10. Gamboa
special mentions
Bute, Bradley, Cotto, Khan.

it is a bit subjective . What do you think?

[ninjaspy3]

Whew. Good timing on this one for sure.

[ElTerribleMorales]

after Pacquiao's gift against Marquez flip Floyd and Manny and you're good to go, Mayweather in the #1 slot and Pac in #2

[gest12645]

fair enough, so you're saying Floyd is the P4P king? After the Marquez fight, i guess he may have some votes for the spot. Manny is still #1 P4P to me

[ElTerribleMorales]

fair enough, so you're saying Floyd is the P4P king? After the Marquez fight, i guess he may have some votes for the spot. Manny is still #1 P4P to me

most people had Manny up more due to how they beat the shared opponents, well Manny basically lost badly to Marquez on Saturday, Floyd beat him without breaking a sweat, both did it at WW so no excuses and he did it 2 yrs earlier, add in he won his last fight against KO (albeit somewhat controversially) and then well IMO Mayweather jumps back to #1

[Dench]

fair enough, so you're saying Floyd is the P4P king? After the Marquez fight, i guess he may have some votes for the spot. Manny is still #1 P4P to me

most people had Manny up more due to how they beat the shared opponents, well Manny basically lost badly to Marquez on Saturday, Floyd beat him without breaking a sweat, both did it at WW so no excuses and he did it 2 yrs earlier, add in he won his last fight against KO (albeit somewhat controversially) and then well IMO Mayweather jumps back to #1

Its very hard to tell really who's #1 and #2. I placed them now right beside each other at #1. If thats possible, but in my mind they co exist as #1 lb4lb.

The thing is, we cant really use common opponents as the way to measure their rank in lb4lb ratings. If fighter A beats B and B beats C doesnt really mean that A will beat C. The only way to settle this ranking is for the 2 men to fight each other.

If they wont, then people will look into the difficulty of their paths or previous fights. You see in this Pac is way over floyd, having fought several fights with steep competitions, across 8 weight classes -- floyd wasnt able to do that since beating Deigo Corrales.

[Violent Demise]

How do you have it:
Here's mine:

1. Pac
2. Floyd
3. Martinez
4. Marquez
5. Donaire
6. Wlad
7. Vitali
8. Ward
9. Hopkins
10. Gamboa
special mentions
Bute, Bradley, Cotto, Khan.

it is a bit subjective . What do you think?

Quick top 5

1, Floyd Mayweather
2, Juan Manuel Marquez
3, Manny Pacquiao
4, Sergio Martinez
5, Wladimir Klitschko

[shza]

1. Mayweather
2. Martinez
3. Pac
4. Marquez
5. Donaire

I don't know how anyone can have Pac over Mayweather now. He never should have been there in the first place, and wouldn't have been if Floyd hadn't "retired" temporarily.

[Taffturner]

Same for me but audley harrison top instead of pac!!

How do you have it:
Here's mine:

1. Pac
2. Floyd
3. Martinez
4. Marquez
5. Donaire
6. Wlad
7. Vitali
8. Ward
9. Hopkins
10. Gamboa
special mentions
Bute, Bradley, Cotto, Khan.

it is a bit subjective . What do you think?

[Truth]

1)Mayweather
2)Pacquiao
3)Martinez
4)Marquez
5)Ward

[0james0]

If Froch beats Ward, where would that put him?

I can't ever do lists because there are just too many who could get in there.

B-Hop, as much as I don't like him much, still hasn't lost.

Wlad has to be in there really, you can't argue he has not dominated his division the best he could. If anything he should be top 2.

I don't like either fighter, so that's not even any fanboy ism.

[Snakey]

Does Zelenoff move into the top 5 with his win over Floyd Sr ?

[gest12645]

Does Zelenoff move into the top 5 with his win over Floyd Sr ?

First he needs to beat Roger May to be in the top 5. Then we have a superfight - Floyd vs Zelenoff for the P4P crown.

Pacman is obviously on PED , he shouldn't even be ranked

[gest12645]

I seriously doubt it, but if Froch beats Ward, he's def. top 10 P4P.
Ward vs Bute is the real #1 SMW vs #2 SMW