Originally Posted by body head banger
last night i had a hankering for a fight i havnt seen in a while and i found myself watching roy jones jr- antonio tarver 1 again, and i got half way through and thought u know i dont know why the fight was controversial because i knew roy had inched it by a couple of rounds, and i thought right i'll dedicate myself to scoring the fight myself really find out what went on and i felt it was tricky with the rounds in which tarver would flurry at jones and take my attention off the fact roy had been controlling basically the whole round whether tarver had landed or not, so i decided i would score it by timing how long each fighter is in control in each round, which punches were impressive and how they conncted or how often in a flurry and i felt this was a fair aproach and this is what i got.
Bear in mind that there were no knockdowns or illegal blows in which anyone was penalised or any points deducted.thus all rounds were scored 10-9 in favour of whichever fighter won the round.
Round 1. tarver 10-9
Round 2. Tarver 10-9
Round 3. jones 10-9
Round 4. jones 10-9
Round 5. jones 10-9
Round 6. jones 10-9
Round 7. Tarver 10-9 ( a round in which i believe lederman, and i think also one of the judges gave to roy, pushing him yet further ahead)
Round 8. Tarver 10-9
Round 9. jones 10-9
Round 10. tarver 10-9
Round 11. jones 10-9
Round 12. jones 10-9
roy jones jr :115
Antonio Tarver:113
(body head bangers scorecard :P)
and yet it seemed i gave the 7th to tarver, which i felt i did fairly and roy stil won by a two round margine? but tarver couldnt beleive he lost and the public seemed to think tarver had won also? why? i mean props to tarver at the end of the day he was the better man due to a spectacular ko round 2 of jones in the second fight, and a whitewash in the third. BUT had this strange occurance that roy had apparently lost never been said? i dont feel roy would have had anything to prove to tarver and so would never have rematched him and lost!
And whats more is that because of the fact many people believe that roy didn't deserve the win, they were so busy saying that, that alot of them failed to give props to what a performace it was by roy, and gave too much to tarver who could have whitewashed it from the start had he notlet slip in the third!
has anyone else scored this bout? hohw do you have it or what are your opinions on this.
thanks.
BHB.