Pound 4 Pound..

Printable View

Show 40 post(s) from this thread on one page

08-06-2017, 11:18 PM
imp

Pound 4 Pound..

This P4P title is being thrown around way to often in the media and sometimes on this forum.

Let's get this all cleared up for 2017.

It's August the 6th at 9:25am on a sunny day in London..who is your current top 3 in the P4P list?

(Please be aware that you might have to justify the opponents if your choice is questioned!)

1. Ward.
2. GGG.
3. Crawford.
08-06-2017, 11:25 PM
Batman

Re: Pound 4 Pound..

Quote:

Originally Posted by imp

This P4P title is being thrown around way to often in the media and sometimes on this forum.

Let's get this all cleared up for 2017.

It's August the 6th at 9:25am on a sunny day in London..who is your current top 3 in the P4P list?

(Please be aware that you might have to justify the opponents if your choice is questioned!)

1. Ward.
2. GGG.
3. Crawford.

I'm pretty sure we had this exact thread just a few months ago (I think it was top 10 p4p though) I can't really argue with your top 3 either.

And I'm gunna say it, what about Floyd now that he is out of retirement? is he going to get a look in from anyone?
08-06-2017, 11:52 PM
imp

Re: Pound 4 Pound..

Quote:

Originally Posted by Batman

Quote:

Originally Posted by imp

This P4P title is being thrown around way to often in the media and sometimes on this forum.

Let's get this all cleared up for 2017.

It's August the 6th at 9:25am on a sunny day in London..who is your current top 3 in the P4P list?

(Please be aware that you might have to justify the opponents if your choice is questioned!)

1. Ward.
2. GGG.
3. Crawford.

I'm pretty sure we had this exact thread just a few months ago (I think it was top 10 p4p though) I can't really argue with your top 3 either.

And I'm gunna say it, what about Floyd now that he is out of retirement? is he going to get a look in from anyone?

When you're fighting mma fighters the game is over.

Floyd is done in the sport of boxing.

The only way he can hold onto that P4P title is IF Canelo beats up GGG and calls him out after the fight and they rematch for another ridiculous payday...and Floyd will school him again but will probably loose a few more rounds this time.
08-06-2017, 11:56 PM
Batman

Re: Pound 4 Pound..

Quote:

Originally Posted by imp

Quote:

Originally Posted by Batman

Quote:

Originally Posted by imp

This P4P title is being thrown around way to often in the media and sometimes on this forum.

Let's get this all cleared up for 2017.

It's August the 6th at 9:25am on a sunny day in London..who is your current top 3 in the P4P list?

(Please be aware that you might have to justify the opponents if your choice is questioned!)

1. Ward.
2. GGG.
3. Crawford.

I'm pretty sure we had this exact thread just a few months ago (I think it was top 10 p4p though) I can't really argue with your top 3 either.

And I'm gunna say it, what about Floyd now that he is out of retirement? is he going to get a look in from anyone?

When you're fighting mma fighters the game is over.

Floyd is done in the sport of boxing.

The only way he can hold onto that P4P title is IF Canelo beats up GGG and calls him out after the fight and they rematch for another ridiculous payday...and Floyd will school him again but will probably loose a few more rounds this time.

I'm sure that there are a few who would see it as the return of the messiah, as ludicrous as it is.
08-07-2017, 01:35 AM
Master

After GGG beats Canelo, he should call out Floyd and tell him to fight a real boxer.
08-07-2017, 02:34 AM
imp

Re: Pound 4 Pound..

Quote:

Originally Posted by Master

After GGG beats Canelo, he should call out Floyd and tell him to fight a real boxer.

Come on now.

That ship has sailed.
08-07-2017, 04:27 AM
Ron Swanson

Re: Pound 4 Pound..

All WWs all the time for GGG, let that be the battle cry right Master?

Problem with P4P is do you do it on ability

Rigo
Loma
Crawford
Inoue

Or accomplishment

Ward
Gonzalez
Crawford

Or a mix, and then how do you weight it with more towards what you have done or more towards how good you currently are? All I know for sure is if you are on the list you should be fighting good fighters.
08-07-2017, 05:13 AM
Batman

Re: Pound 4 Pound..

Quote:

Originally Posted by Ron Swanson

All WWs all the time for GGG, let that be the battle cry right Master?

Problem with P4P is do you do it on ability

Rigo
Loma
Crawford
Inoue

Or accomplishment

Ward
Gonzalez
Crawford

Or a mix, and then how do you weight it with more towards what you have done or more towards how good you currently are? All I know for sure is if you are on the list you should be fighting good fighters.

You weight it based on who your favourite fighter is, that's all that P4P is, a list of people favourite boxers
08-07-2017, 05:15 AM
powerpuncher

Re: Pound 4 Pound..

My firm top three now is

Ward
Crawford
Loma
08-07-2017, 11:56 PM
erics44

Re: Pound 4 Pound..

"The Annual forum gay of the year competition" should be renamed

"The Anal lb4lb forum Gay of the year competition"

and the more lb4lb related threads created by the competitor should be considered in the vote
08-08-2017, 09:13 AM
TitoFan

Re: Pound 4 Pound..

GGG, Chocolatito, Crawford.

Too lazy right now to put them into any kind of order, but those are my top three.
08-08-2017, 10:44 AM
ykdadamaja

Re: Pound 4 Pound..

Quote:

Originally Posted by Batman

Quote:

Originally Posted by imp

This P4P title is being thrown around way to often in the media and sometimes on this forum.

Let's get this all cleared up for 2017.

It's August the 6th at 9:25am on a sunny day in London..who is your current top 3 in the P4P list?

(Please be aware that you might have to justify the opponents if your choice is questioned!)

1. Ward.
2. GGG.
3. Crawford.

I'm pretty sure we had this exact thread just a few months ago (I think it was top 10 p4p though) I can't really argue with your top 3 either.

And I'm gunna say it, what about Floyd now that he is out of retirement? is he going to get a look in from anyone?

I started it... see it here.... and my list still stands: http://www.saddoboxing.com/boxingfor...-p4p-list.html

I'm the ONLY poster that got the list RIGHT! :)
1. Andre Ward
2. Gennady Golovkin
3. Terence Crawford
4. Vasily Lomachenko
5. Guillermo Rigondeaux
6. Adonis Stevenson
7. Mikey Garcia
8. Canelo Alvarez
9. Keith Thurman
10. Anthony Joshua

Bite it....
https://www.ringtv.com/ratings/
http://fightnews.com/rankings-2
08-08-2017, 12:22 PM
imp

Re: Pound 4 Pound..

Quote:

Originally Posted by ykdadamaja

Quote:

Originally Posted by Batman

Quote:

Originally Posted by imp

This P4P title is being thrown around way to often in the media and sometimes on this forum.

Let's get this all cleared up for 2017.

It's August the 6th at 9:25am on a sunny day in London..who is your current top 3 in the P4P list?

(Please be aware that you might have to justify the opponents if your choice is questioned!)

1. Ward.
2. GGG.
3. Crawford.

I'm pretty sure we had this exact thread just a few months ago (I think it was top 10 p4p though) I can't really argue with your top 3 either.

And I'm gunna say it, what about Floyd now that he is out of retirement? is he going to get a look in from anyone?

I started it... see it here.... and my list still stands: http://www.saddoboxing.com/boxingfor...-p4p-list.html

I'm the ONLY poster that got the list RIGHT! :)
1. Andre Ward
2. Gennady Golovkin
3. Terence Crawford
4. Vasily Lomachenko
5. Guillermo Rigondeaux
6. Adonis Stevenson
7. Mikey Garcia
8. Canelo Alvarez
9. Keith Thurman
10. Anthony Joshua

Bite it....
https://www.ringtv.com/ratings/
http://fightnews.com/rankings-2

How is Lomachenko in the No.4 spot?!

Stevenson in No.6?!
08-08-2017, 01:02 PM
Batman

Re: Pound 4 Pound..

How can we have a P4P thread and no one mentions Charley Zelenoff
08-08-2017, 01:14 PM
TitoFan

Re: Pound 4 Pound..

Well he lost his chance at p4p recognition when he lost to Deontay Wilder.

Show 40 post(s) from this thread on one page