Re: Should Taylor be #1 P4P if he beats Winky?
Quote:
Originally Posted by albsur2006
If he beats Winky, I think that Taylor should be #1 P4P. Two wins over Hopkins and one over Wright should catapult him up the list. PBF did beat Judah, and even though I think he still is the best boxer out there, I don't think that he has done enough in terms of competition to warrant being #1 P4P. He should be a close #2. But Taylor winning is a big if, I still see him KOing Winky though.
If Taylor beats Wright (which I expect him to do) than he should be #3 on the P4P list. Behind Mayweather and Pac.
Re: Should Taylor be #1 P4P if he beats Winky?
Re: Should Taylor be #1 P4P if he beats Winky?
Quote:
Originally Posted by Starr
What abour Barerra?
Number 4. Where he belongs
Re: Should Taylor be #1 P4P if he beats Winky?
If Taylor wins,he should be number 3 I think,if Winky wins,he consolidates number 1 place.
Re: Should Taylor be #1 P4P if he beats Winky?
I think if Taylor wins he has one big shout to be #1 and i think he will overtake Winky however just cannot see anyone overtaking Floyd.
Re: Should Taylor be #1 P4P if he beats Winky?
He would have a fair shout at being number 1, but i dont think he wil win............winky wil win a UD n move to number 1, replacing pbf
Re: Should Taylor be #1 P4P if he beats Winky?
Quote:
Originally Posted by AC-Cobra
No way you can move him in front of Mayweather in the top 3 (however you have em ranked). Consider, if he wins, hes undefeated 1 weight champ whos beat an old B-Hop (but B-Hop never the less to give him credit) and Winky. As much as I moan about Floyds recent flight selection, hes also undefeated , was a LEGIT champ at 2 weights and beat Castillo, Coralles, Casamayor, Judah among other good fighters. Id put him 4th if he wins, but only because I have a soft spot for Calderon who I have ranked 4th at the mo. Winky doesnt drop out the top 5.
When did Floyd fight Casamayor?
Re: Should Taylor be #1 P4P if he beats Winky?
Quote:
Originally Posted by raleights
Quote:
Originally Posted by AC-Cobra
No way you can move him in front of Mayweather in the top 3 (however you have em ranked). Consider, if he wins, hes undefeated 1 weight champ whos beat an old B-Hop (but B-Hop never the less to give him credit) and Winky. As much as I moan about Floyds recent flight selection, hes also undefeated , was a LEGIT champ at 2 weights and beat Castillo, Coralles, Casamayor, Judah among other good fighters. Id put him 4th if he wins, but only because I have a soft spot for Calderon who I have ranked 4th at the mo. Winky doesnt drop out the top 5.
When did Floyd fight Casamayor?
he didnt
Re: Should Taylor be #1 P4P if he beats Winky?
If Taylor wins maybe put him at #2, if Winky wins put him ahead of PBF, he argueably belongs there anyway.
Re: Should Taylor be #1 P4P if he beats Winky?
Quote:
Originally Posted by Quelynn
Quote:
Originally Posted by AC-Cobra
No way you can move him in front of Mayweather in the top 3 (however you have em ranked). Consider, if he wins, hes undefeated 1 weight champ whos beat an old B-Hop (but B-Hop never the less to give him credit) and Winky. As much as I moan about Floyds recent flight selection, hes also undefeated , was a LEGIT champ at 2 weights and beat Castillo, Coralles, Casamayor, Judah among other good fighters. Id put him 4th if he wins, but only because I have a soft spot for Calderon who I have ranked 4th at the mo. Winky doesnt drop out the top 5.
PBF hasnt fought Casamayor,whats gives you the idea he beat him????
Quote:
Originally Posted by raleights
Quote:
Originally Posted by AC-Cobra
No way you can move him in front of Mayweather in the top 3 (however you have em ranked). Consider, if he wins, hes undefeated 1 weight champ whos beat an old B-Hop (but B-Hop never the less to give him credit) and Winky. As much as I moan about Floyds recent flight selection, hes also undefeated , was a LEGIT champ at 2 weights and beat Castillo, Coralles, Casamayor, Judah among other good fighters. Id put him 4th if he wins, but only because I have a soft spot for Calderon who I have ranked 4th at the mo. Winky doesnt drop out the top 5.
When did Floyd fight Casamayor?
Quote:
Originally Posted by LBSCFC
Quote:
Originally Posted by raleights
Quote:
Originally Posted by AC-Cobra
No way you can move him in front of Mayweather in the top 3 (however you have em ranked). Consider, if he wins, hes undefeated 1 weight champ whos beat an old B-Hop (but B-Hop never the less to give him credit) and Winky. As much as I moan about Floyds recent flight selection, hes also undefeated , was a LEGIT champ at 2 weights and beat Castillo, Coralles, Casamayor, Judah among other good fighters. Id put him 4th if he wins, but only because I have a soft spot for Calderon who I have ranked 4th at the mo. Winky doesnt drop out the top 5.
When did Floyd fight Casamayor?
he didnt
Of course you're all right. I must of just typed Casamayor as a reflex thing after going on all my rants supporting Diego at the weekend.
Sorry guys, Ill remember to read through my post next time :P
Re: Should Taylor be #1 P4P if he beats Winky?
you had me going all over the internet looking for the pbf/casamayor fight
fucker! :)
Re: Should Taylor be #1 P4P if he beats Winky?
Quote:
Originally Posted by raleights
you had me going all over the internet looking for the pbf/casamayor fight
fucker! :)
;D
Sorry mate, CC for the effort and the misplaced trust lol. (and of course to try and help you balance em out)
Re: Should Taylor be #1 P4P if he beats Winky?
Quote:
Originally Posted by Violent Demise
Quote:
Originally Posted by Starr
What abour Barerra?
Number 4. Where he belongs
Barrera has more longevity than any other cative fighter today . Winky is his closest rival but I dont believe hes won as many superfights as Marco and he hasnt conquered 3 divisions. Barrera made his name moving up weights and beating the best. Winky has been beating guys smaller than him . Floyd would be deserving of a number 3 spot cuz hes unbeaten and moving through the weights . Pac would be around 4 but even if Taylor beats Winky he barely makes top 5
Re: Should Taylor be #1 P4P if he beats Winky?
Ok people p4p doesnt work like this. If you beat mayweather then you dont get the number 1 spot. You have to prove yourself worthy...you could just have one good night against a good fighter and then never do anything good again. You have to earn it and you dont earn it by beating one top 5 p4p fighter.
Re: Should Taylor be #1 P4P if he beats Winky?
I suppose Talyor would have beaten two arguable number 1 p4p fighters back to back . first B- Hop then Winky
