Should Taylor be #1 P4P if he beats Winky?

[albsur2006]

If he beats Winky, I think that Taylor should be #1 P4P. Two wins over Hopkins and one over Wright should catapult him up the list. PBF did beat Judah, and even though I think he still is the best boxer out there, I don't think that he has done enough in terms of competition to warrant being #1 P4P. He should be a close #2. But Taylor winning is a big if, I still see him KOing Winky though.

[amat]

Yes. That's just my opinion but if he does....yes. Time to give the guy some credit. I know a lot hate how he beat B-Hop....but he did win and he hasn't gotten his due imo. If he takes this one, or even makes it close, then he's got to get his credit.

[killersheep]

Personally I would have him at number 2 right behind PAC-MAN
I need to see PAC - Larios before I move Taylor to number 1

and it also would depend on how convincingly Taylor beat Wright.

[LBSCFC]

i agree. he will be in top 2. pacmans the man for me at the mo still

[Purist]

HELL NO!!! He aint come close to dominating the Middleweight division. Wright dominated 154 for YEARS and then cemented it with a move up and beat Trinidad. Winky deserves his spot at number 2. People like Barerra and Pacquiao deserve number 1 p4p before Jermain even cracks the top 5!

[clean]

Personally I would have him at number 2 right behind PAC-MAN
I need to see PAC - Larios before I move Taylor to number 1

and it also would depend on how convincingly Taylor beat Wright.

cc. It depends how impressive Taylor would look. I can't see him passing Mayweather for the top spot unless he puts on some miracle type performance. A convincing win though will get him top 3.

[AC-Cobra]

No way you can move him in front of Mayweather in the top 3 (however you have em ranked). Consider, if he wins, hes undefeated 1 weight champ whos beat an old B-Hop (but B-Hop never the less to give him credit) and Winky. As much as I moan about Floyds recent flight selection, hes also undefeated , was a LEGIT champ at 2 weights and beat Castillo, Coralles, Casamayor, Judah among other good fighters. Id put him 4th if he wins, but only because I have a soft spot for Calderon who I have ranked 4th at the mo. Winky doesnt drop out the top 5.

[killersheep]

Personally I would have him at number 2 right behind PAC-MAN
I need to see PAC - Larios before I move Taylor to number 1

and it also would depend on how convincingly Taylor beat Wright.

cc. It depends how impressive Taylor would look. I can't see him passing Mayweather for the top spot unless he puts on some miracle type performance. A convincing win though will get him top 3.

The only reason I put him in front of Mayweather is his willingness to fight, I think that fight pickin snobbery will be Mayweather's downfall.

[TyBuff]

When he wins I think he is top 5 easy. How he wins will determine where in the top 5.

[Quelynn]

No way you can move him in front of Mayweather in the top 3 (however you have em ranked). Consider, if he wins, hes undefeated 1 weight champ whos beat an old B-Hop (but B-Hop never the less to give him credit) and Winky. As much as I moan about Floyds recent flight selection, hes also undefeated , was a LEGIT champ at 2 weights and beat Castillo, Coralles, Casamayor, Judah among other good fighters. Id put him 4th if he wins, but only because I have a soft spot for Calderon who I have ranked 4th at the mo. Winky doesnt drop out the top 5.

PBF hasnt fought Casamayor,whats gives you the idea he beat him?

[superlyrical]

#1 hmmmm dunno...top 3? yes

[bigragu]

If he beats Winky, I think that Taylor should be #1 P4P. Two wins over Hopkins and one over Wright should catapult him up the list. PBF did beat Judah, and even though I think he still is the best boxer out there, I don't think that he has done enough in terms of competition to warrant being #1 P4P. He should be a close #2. But Taylor winning is a big if, I still see him KOing Winky though.

PBF is #1 hands down....I'd give Taylor the #2 p4p if he beat Winky.....but that ain't goin to happen.....

[sillent killer]

I don't think Taylor will win,but if that happen I would put him #3 on my list. Yes he does have two close wins over B-HOP,IMO he lost first fight,second fight was close I could see going eather way. Anyway if he beats Winky big time,I will give him respect but will not consider him P4P #1.

[VictorCharlie]

if he wins convincinlgy he would just barely make it in the top 5

[Taeth]

I don't think so until Mayweather has a close fight against somebody.