If Castillo wouldn't have been robbed in his fight with Mayweather...

How would Maywether and Castillo's career paths altered to the way they have done.

It was a very close fight but i don't think Castillo was robbed i think Mayweather won.

THe problem with Castillo in that fight, and reason why I don't think he won is because Mayweather landed the sharper more effective blows more often. Castillo did catch him more times than anybody else has, but he landed a lot of his punches while they were clinched which for me shouldn't count. There were a few times where I felt Castillo was just punching to land anything instead of using good, technically flawless punches.

First off, I don't think Castillo got robbed.

I scored the fight a draw. When I score a fight even, I don't think either guy can really get robbed, since it's obviously a close fight that could go either way.

However, IF Castillo had won, I don't think things would have changed that much. They would have had an immediate rematch, and Floyd would've beaten him.

I had Castillo winning but it wasn't a robbery but i did like the aggression from Castillo that just about swayed it for me.

i had jlc by a round or 2 in the first fight :-\

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by SweetPea

First off, I don't think Castillo got robbed.

I scored the fight a draw. When I score a fight even, I don't think either guy can really get robbed, since it's obviously a close fight that could go either way.

However, IF Castillo had won, I don't think things would have changed that much. They would have had an immediate rematch, and Floyd would've beaten him.

---

I guess you did not see the punch stats.

Floyd did not do enough to win and they gave him that fight.

i had Castillo winning 115-112

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Danny_G

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by SweetPea

First off, I don't think Castillo got robbed.

I scored the fight a draw. When I score a fight even, I don't think either guy can really get robbed, since it's obviously a close fight that could go either way.

However, IF Castillo had won, I don't think things would have changed that much. They would have had an immediate rematch, and Floyd would've beaten him.

---

I guess you did not see the punch stats.









Floyd did not do enough to win and they gave him that fight.

---

punch stat numbers are a novice way to score a fight..........

they only measure a fighters activity, not effectiveness ;)






hope this helps

well Floyd wasn't very effective against DLH so maybe he shouldn't have won that fight either ::**, and don't start the whole arguement that he clearly won against Oscar cause i had Mayweather winning by a round, but it was mainly cause of the punch numbers, DLH was effective with his punches by moving Mayweather back, especially the jab, it had Mayweather in a ball the entire time he'd throw it, so yea punch stat numbers do play into judging a fight, just they're not the only thing you should take into consideration

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by ElTerribleMorales

well Floyd wasn't very effective against DLH so maybe he shouldn't have won that fight either ::**, and don't start the whole arguement that he clearly won against Oscar cause i had Mayweather winning by a round, but it was mainly cause of the punch numbers, DLH was effective with his punches by moving Mayweather back, especially the jab, it had Mayweather in a ball the entire time he'd throw it, so yea punch stat numbers do play into judging a fight, just they're not the only thing you should take into consideration

---

I thought Oscar missed alot Mayweather landed cleaner harder blows plus landed alot more shots Oscar was ahead after 8 rounds but lost imo all of the later rounds i had it 116-113 if i can remember right but my scorecard was something around there.

i had Mayweather winning by only one round

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by ElTerribleMorales

well Floyd wasn't very effective against DLH so maybe he shouldn't have won that fight either ::**, and don't start the whole arguement that he clearly won against Oscar cause i had Mayweather winning by a round, but it was mainly cause of the punch numbers, DLH was effective with his punches by moving Mayweather back, especially the jab, it had Mayweather in a ball the entire time he'd throw it, so yea punch stat numbers do play into judging a fight, just they're not the only thing you should take into consideration

---

punchstat numbers PLUS effectiveness = an easy fight to score (ala mayweather vs. delahoya ;))

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by ElTerribleMorales

i had Mayweather winning by only one round

---

Did you give Oscar the 12th round ?? because i remember quite a few on here giving him the 12th round.

yea i thought Oscar got the best in the last exchange and IMO won the round, either way i thought the fight was a very close fight

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by ICE COLD BOXING

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by ElTerribleMorales

i had Mayweather winning by only one round

---

Did you give Oscar the 12th round ?? because i remember quite a few on here giving him the 12th round.

---

In my own opinion Oscar needed a knockout to win the Mayweather fight

And if you're not down with that I have two words for you


Prarie Dog

[youtube=625,540]54vtXRI32MQ[/youtube]

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by P.G.H Angel Eyes

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by ICE COLD BOXING

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by ElTerribleMorales

i had Mayweather winning by only one round

---

Did you give Oscar the 12th round ?? because i remember quite a few on here giving him the 12th round.

---

In my own opinion Oscar needed a knockout to win the Mayweather fight

And if you're not down with that I have two words for you


Prarie Dog

[youtube=625,540]54vtXRI32MQ[/youtube]

---

I thought Oscar missed alot Mayweather landed cleaner harder blows plus landed alot more shots Oscar was ahead after 8 rounds but lost imo all of the later rounds i had it 116-113 if i can remember right but my scorecard was something around there.

If they had given that fight to Jose Mayweather would still be the fighter he is today and still on top of the pound for pound list. It just would have taken a bit longer.
Then again maybe we would have found out Floyd Mayweather's mental make up as well. You never know how a fighter can handle his first loss. If his confidence is shot anything could happen :-\

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Punching Princess

If they had given that fight to Jose Mayweather would still be the fighter he is today and still on top of the pound for pound list. It just would have taken a bit longer.
Then again maybe we would have found out Floyd Mayweather's mental make up as well. You never know how a fighter can handle his first loss. If his confidence is shot anything could happen :-\

---

Hmmmmm, I had to read that a few times lol.

we wouldnt have this topic , and floyd wouldve beat him in the reamtch and then in the third fight so perhaps he wouldve been considred more of a legend

Mayweather won the 2nd fight so there's probably have been a trilogy that Mayweather would have probably finished off.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Sugar_Shaw

How would Maywether and Castillo's career paths altered to the way they have done.

---

Being the one human on the planet to land shots & give Mayweather a close fight does not equate to being robbed.