If Castillo wouldn't have been robbed in his fight with Mayweather...

[Sugar_Shaw]

How would Maywether and Castillo's career paths altered to the way they have done.

[Tysonbruno]

It was a very close fight but i don't think Castillo was robbed i think Mayweather won.

[Taeth]

THe problem with Castillo in that fight, and reason why I don't think he won is because Mayweather landed the sharper more effective blows more often. Castillo did catch him more times than anybody else has, but he landed a lot of his punches while they were clinched which for me shouldn't count. There were a few times where I felt Castillo was just punching to land anything instead of using good, technically flawless punches.

[SweetPea]

First off, I don't think Castillo got robbed.

I scored the fight a draw. When I score a fight even, I don't think either guy can really get robbed, since it's obviously a close fight that could go either way.

However, IF Castillo had won, I don't think things would have changed that much. They would have had an immediate rematch, and Floyd would've beaten him.

[ICB]

I had Castillo winning but it wasn't a robbery but i did like the aggression from Castillo that just about swayed it for me.

[frozensolid_702]

i had jlc by a round or 2 in the first fight

[SigmaMu]

First off, I don't think Castillo got robbed.

I scored the fight a draw. When I score a fight even, I don't think either guy can really get robbed, since it's obviously a close fight that could go either way.

However, IF Castillo had won, I don't think things would have changed that much. They would have had an immediate rematch, and Floyd would've beaten him.

I guess you did not see the punch stats.

Floyd did not do enough to win and they gave him that fight.

[ElTerribleMorales]

i had Castillo winning 115-112

[frozensolid_702]

First off, I don't think Castillo got robbed.

I scored the fight a draw. When I score a fight even, I don't think either guy can really get robbed, since it's obviously a close fight that could go either way.

However, IF Castillo had won, I don't think things would have changed that much. They would have had an immediate rematch, and Floyd would've beaten him.

I guess you did not see the punch stats.









Floyd did not do enough to win and they gave him that fight.

punch stat numbers are a novice way to score a fight..........

they only measure a fighters activity, not effectiveness






hope this helps

[ElTerribleMorales]

well Floyd wasn't very effective against DLH so maybe he shouldn't have won that fight either , and don't start the whole arguement that he clearly won against Oscar cause i had Mayweather winning by a round, but it was mainly cause of the punch numbers, DLH was effective with his punches by moving Mayweather back, especially the jab, it had Mayweather in a ball the entire time he'd throw it, so yea punch stat numbers do play into judging a fight, just they're not the only thing you should take into consideration

[ICB]

well Floyd wasn't very effective against DLH so maybe he shouldn't have won that fight either , and don't start the whole arguement that he clearly won against Oscar cause i had Mayweather winning by a round, but it was mainly cause of the punch numbers, DLH was effective with his punches by moving Mayweather back, especially the jab, it had Mayweather in a ball the entire time he'd throw it, so yea punch stat numbers do play into judging a fight, just they're not the only thing you should take into consideration

I thought Oscar missed alot Mayweather landed cleaner harder blows plus landed alot more shots Oscar was ahead after 8 rounds but lost imo all of the later rounds i had it 116-113 if i can remember right but my scorecard was something around there.

[ElTerribleMorales]

i had Mayweather winning by only one round

[frozensolid_702]

well Floyd wasn't very effective against DLH so maybe he shouldn't have won that fight either , and don't start the whole arguement that he clearly won against Oscar cause i had Mayweather winning by a round, but it was mainly cause of the punch numbers, DLH was effective with his punches by moving Mayweather back, especially the jab, it had Mayweather in a ball the entire time he'd throw it, so yea punch stat numbers do play into judging a fight, just they're not the only thing you should take into consideration

punchstat numbers PLUS effectiveness = an easy fight to score (ala mayweather vs. delahoya )

[ICB]

i had Mayweather winning by only one round

Did you give Oscar the 12th round ?? because i remember quite a few on here giving him the 12th round.

[ElTerribleMorales]

yea i thought Oscar got the best in the last exchange and IMO won the round, either way i thought the fight was a very close fight