Does RJJ make the top 10 P4P if he wins???

[gudnite vienna]

with his fight with Calzaghe comming up soon, where would you place him if he beats Joe

[kingfrnk]

i dont know or really care. i just want him to win

[gudnite vienna]

well i doubt he will

[ICB]

Yes no question IMO.

[Pugilistic]

In my opinion yes.

[Lance Uppercut]

I think Roy will win, and yes, he deserves to placed somewhere back in the hight top 10 Lb4Lb.


I think Roy will pull this one off due to how hard of a time that Joe had with B-Hop.

[richard (mossley)]

No of course not. For RJJ to win, this would have to mean a serious deteriation in Calzaghes talents. Meaning RJJ is still nowhere near top 10 P4P.
A RJJ win would be the upset of the decade so far.

[Lance Uppercut]

If you knock off #2 pound 4 pound, no matter the circumstances, you deserve at least a #10 pound for pound spot.

[ICB]

No of course not. For RJJ to win, this would have to mean a serious deteriation in Calzaghes talents. Meaning RJJ is still nowhere near top 10 P4P.
A RJJ win would be the upset of the decade so far.

Upset of the decade please......

[Kel]

If you knock off #2 pound 4 pound, no matter the circumstances, you deserve at least a #10 pound for pound spot.

So who gets knocked off from the top 10 list because Roy wins? It depends on what the top 10 current P4P fighters do aswell surely?

[ICB]

If you knock off #2 pound 4 pound, no matter the circumstances, you deserve at least a #10 pound for pound spot.

So who gets knocked off from the top 10 list because Roy wins? It depends on what the top 10 current P4P fighters do aswell surely?

P4P list's do my head in personally, all i know is if RJJ wins. He would seal the deal on his legacy, and he would retire one of the best fighters of all time. Plus it would be one of the best achievements for an almost 40 year old.

[Kel]

If you knock off #2 pound 4 pound, no matter the circumstances, you deserve at least a #10 pound for pound spot.

So who gets knocked off from the top 10 list because Roy wins? It depends on what the top 10 current P4P fighters do aswell surely?

P4P list's do my head in personally, all i know is if RJJ wins. He would seal the deal on his legacy, and he would retire one of the best fighters of all time. Plus it would be one of the best achievements for an almost 40 year old.

Same here lol. It would be a great win though as Joe is more of his old self than Roy is (well thats an obvious statement I know) so a RJJ win is far more impressive than a Calzaghe win.

[rjj tszyu]

I was thinking about this the other day. If Roy wins he probably will go into the Rings top 10 p4p fighters and I think I would have to agree because if it was someone like Jermain Taylor who is still quite young that beat Joe he would go into the top 10 so why not Roy?

[CutMeMick]

Here's my current P4P list.

Pac
JMM
Joe
Izzy
Hopkins
Margarito
Pav
Mijares
Rafa
Cotto

If RJJ won I would drop Cotto from the list and place RJJ at #10.

[kingfrnk]

No of course not. For RJJ to win, this would have to mean a serious deteriation in Calzaghes talents. Meaning RJJ is still nowhere near top 10 P4P.
A RJJ win would be the upset of the decade so far.

get off of joes sack before you get pregnant. and upset of the decade boi stop i think you need to watch more fighters than calzaghe