Let's define a Robbery...

[imp]

Let's Stop crying Robbery..

Too much moaning about last nights fight when the corrupt judge made the mistake in the wide scores but not the choice of opponent.

Do you consider any of these recent fights a robbery?

Pac vs Bradley 1?
Pac vs Horn?
Ward vs Kovalev 1?
Degale vs Jack?!

In all your saddo experience as a fan or boxer, what fights have you seen that has been a complete and utter robbery that have left you completely disgusted.

Give me a breakdown of your definition of what makes a robbery in a boxing match.

[GaMo]

Erislandy Lara vs Paul Williams

Nicolas Walters vs Jason Sosa

Joel Casamayor vs Jose Santa Cruz

Evander Holyfield vs Lennox Lewis 1

Bernard Hopkins vs Jermain Taylor 1

[Master]

Canelo having 10 rounds won against GGG is corrupt.

The fight between GGG and Canelo was close I had it 8-4 but it could be 7-5. That is close not a robbery.

[Batman]

Canelo having 10 rounds won against GGG is corrupt.

The fight between GGG and Canelo was close I had it 8-4 but it could be 7-5. That is close not a robbery.

Completely agree, the actual result is not a robbery it is the scorecard of Adelaide Byrd that is the problem.

It is the fact that people have been calling her out for her bullshit cards for over 10 years and nothing has been done.

It is the fact that fighters try to get her removed from their fights as a judge

It is the fact that Abel Sanchez raised the issue before the fight yet this still happened

It is the fact that the NSAC have defended her and said she 'Had an off night'

It is the fact that Oscar says 'She has been scoring fights accurately for years and the only winner of the night was boxing

I'm not one to scream robbery when a decision doesn't go how I want but it pisses me off when someone is as blatantly corrupt as her.

[Dia bando]

Canelo having 10 rounds won against GGG is corrupt.

The fight between GGG and Canelo was close I had it 8-4 but it could be 7-5. That is close not a robbery.

My point on robbery in Vagas GGG had a cat in hells chance of getting a points win it was stacked against him the ginger monster was made out to be something he was not.!
The build up was in my eyes very much Canelo and GGG was playing the understudy in a rematch GGG will catch him and hurt him Canelo punches had very little affect on GGG simple.
Vagas is a bad place to get a fair decision plenty of bad ones,! it was a City built by mobsters and it remains corrupt I was pissed off because I new it would be a screw job.

[imp]

Canelo having 10 rounds won against GGG is corrupt.

The fight between GGG and Canelo was close I had it 8-4 but it could be 7-5. That is close not a robbery.

I agree on the 7-5...it was close.

(Would add rep but doesn't seem to work on mobile view!)

[Master]

Canelo having 10 rounds won against GGG is corrupt.

The fight between GGG and Canelo was close I had it 8-4 but it could be 7-5. That is close not a robbery.

I agree on the 7-5...it was close.

(Would add rep but doesn't seem to work on mobile view!)

Looking at the official scores that Batman put on here all 3 judges had Canelo winning the first 2 and the last 3 rounds. So that does make the fight close.

The fact that the corrupt judge had Canelo winning every round from 8 to 12 is a joke. the other 2 judges had GGG winning 8 and 9.

[Nameless]

I think that there is a fine line between a controversy and a robbery, a dubious decision and a really bad decision. A fine line, but a line nonetheless.

I can accept very well that sometimees, a judge will give all the tight rounds to one of the two boxers, even though I strongly disagree. Fine.


But when a judge makes a TOTAL miscalculation by such a wide margin as 118-110, it's absolutely scancalous. Canelo was nowhere near to "perhaps win". If we're VERY generous to Alvarez, losing 115-113 is acceptable. A draw? pretty dubious but let's call it a dubious decision. 118-110? I can't believe I've ever seen such score for that fight.

[erics44]

Let's Stop crying Robbery..

Too much moaning about last nights fight when the corrupt judge made the mistake in the wide scores but not the choice of opponent.

Do you consider any of these recent fights a robbery?

Pac vs Bradley 1?
Pac vs Horn?
Ward vs Kovalev 1?
Degale vs Jack?!

In all your saddo experience as a fan or boxer, what fights have you seen that has been a complete and utter robbery that have left you completely disgusted.

Give me a breakdown of your definition of what makes a robbery in a boxing match.

Pac vs Bradley 1? - I didn't agree with the result
Pac vs Horn? - I wouldn't argue with this one
Ward vs Kovalev 1? - a little fortunate to go to ward, more like a draw
Degale vs Jack?! - the correct result, six rounds each easy