Inspired by BF.
We've heard it repeated- so and so was called great because they fought in a week era (Wlad, BHop)for example.

But there are fighters who lost...... thus the title(GREAT) eluded them.

My take: Buddy Mcgirt was reduced to being called just a good fighter because he fought in an era of packed talent.
Julio Cesar Chavez
Pernell Whitaker
Edwin Rosario
Meldrick Taylor
Livingston Bramble
Simon Brown
Some Buddy fought some here he didn't. These were a few names that Buddy had to contend with at welter. How would the so-called Great JMM or Pac had done in Buddy's era?


How would JMM or Pac had faired in Roberto Duran's era?
I think Pac destroys the fighters that Duran faced at ,(LW).

Duran was great indeed at LW but for those here who love mythical matchups: you really think Floyd would have lost to DeJesus or Buchanan?