OK everyone here debates about peoples record's...Who's is padded,,,,Who avoids top competition...Who should be seeking out better fights ect

It seems everyone here has a different idea on what makes a fighter a true P4P fighter and great Champion...

EG--Some guy's say Joe Calzaghe is a great Champion because of how long he has had the title and the fact he is undefeated...Others say he is only champion and undefeated becaused he fights the least dangerous guy's he can find making his title reign watered down....

Floyd Mayweather Jr gets simular criticizm due to the fact he has not fought names like Cotto,,Hatton,,ect....Yet others praise him for amount of belts he has won

So in everyones opinion what makes a great champion or at least a legit and worthy one....

Is it the guy who has the most defenses of a title reguardless of who it is against or the guy who has quality wins and quality defenses but less amount of successful bouts

Just curious on everyones opinion on which they prefer