Quote Originally Posted by Mr140
Look i am not question there greatness Cut all i am saying is what i think would happen if they fought Joe at SM.
Not Questioning....

Quote Originally Posted by Mr140
Khan i did not say there were not special but i think Joe could have a shot to beat them and if you disagree o well.

You did not say they were not special fighters at those weights...Is this not your post I just copied?...from page 3 of this thread?....

I think people think of Roy Jones as a Ali of 168 and he only had a few fights there and Tony was good not unbeatable. I think Joe would have a chance to beat both of them lets not forget that a past it prime Joe made Kess look like a fool I doubt past it Roy or Tony could. Who knows Hell i will go with Joe to win i not following the coward i think Joe can pull off a win against both not like i can be proved wrong so what the hell

You said Calzaghe was past his prime and made Kessler look like a fool last night?....You are the only one who thinks Kessler looked like a fool because Kessler looked DAMN!!! good and made a DAMN!!! good account of himself.....

Then you go on to say Toney or Jones could not beat Kessler in the same fashion....
Quote Originally Posted by Mr140
And Roy and Tony were in different weight classes for most of there careers just depends on how you look at who they beat and when they did it and what weight class they were at. Do i think Joe could go up as much weight as Roy and Tony did and still win i am not sure if he could. But at SM i think Joe has a good shot to win and do not think i am putting Roy and Tony down i am not Khan just talking about if they fought Joe what i think would happen thats it. So just thought i clear up anything you might of misunderstood what i was trying to say.

I answered a question that was stated in the beginning of the thread...Do I think Calzaghe could have beaten Roy Jones JR at 168 the answer is NO!! Period!!!!

Your not putting down Jones or Toney yet you stated several times Jones did not accomplish much at 168 and why does everyone think so highly of him at that weight...not in 1 post not in 2 post but almost every post up until the one where Mick said to question them is Absurd.....

PAY ATTENTION TO WHAT YOU POST!!!!

Don't say you never said Jones was not great at SMW..when you stated he did not even spend enough time there to be considered a top SMW...

And I stated clearly in several threads that be it Calzaghe, Toney, Barkley, or the three bears...I have never seen a better fighter at 168 lbs then Roy Jones....At 169 Roy Jones was absolute perfection...Not a single flaw in his game...He could fight with his hands behind his back practically...His speed, his power and his ring generalship was something to marvel at.....I did not ask you to agree...I don't need you to agree...it is not just my opinion...

I also stated several times on the boards that Calzaghe is the best SMW champion to ever hold the title...The length of his reign and defenses speak for themselves...I spoke of Jones as a whole!! His skill at 168 can be compared to that of a WW Ray Robinson or Prime ALI....


Point out one fight at 168 he showed any flaws in his game?...Show me where any fighter at 168 even gave the hint he was beatable while facing him?...One guy who hurt him?...even stunned him?.....Hell we will go with an easy one....show me one fighter he faced at SMW that managed to land more then 2 combos in a row on him.....