Quote Originally Posted by leftylee View Post
Quote Originally Posted by kingfrnk View Post
Quote Originally Posted by leftylee View Post

Kosta was P4P number 2 when Hatton fought him
i get wat ur saying lefty but thats in the past and doesnt count anymore. and after Mayweather he wasnt on the list anymore. it all depends on wat you have done lately.
I diagree completely. P4P list are based on what you've done throughout your career, not recently. If it was recently wouldn't David Haye be top 10 P4P ?

Remember when Floyd Mayweather Jr was P4P number 1 not so long ago?

Well I remember people saying ahh Ricky Hatton is a 140 pounder and ODLH is past it, Carlos Baldomir is one dimensional etc (They are all true btw), Pac should be number 1.

Well people used his wins over Chavez, Castillo, Corrales etc to say he deserves number 1 as he had great wins from years ago.

You can't base P4P lists over recent perofrmances, it's what they've done THROUGHOUT there whole career since they became pro.
so because Hatton beat Kosta and then lost to PBF and then beat Paulie he should be ahead of Vic.