Yes its close. I would take Donaire. Again partly because subjective stuff plays some part in my P4P, I just think Donaire's a better fighter. Considering they both have good resumes but not great ones I would rank Donaire higher.

Does anybody solely do P4P on resume? I know its the main part but still.

Not to say I even do P4P.

I'm sure somebody will bring up Winky with Paul. I'm not sure how great that win is under the circumstances. Tarver's a bit iffy too. They're good, not great IMO.