I spent five painstaking months coming up with this P4P list. I'm Ouma the Daddy.

[Kev]

Calderon above Williams grates me. Who was his 106 lb opponent he won the title from and was he really better than Margarito?

What about his flyweight win over Hugo Cazares? Was he really that much better than Quintana or Phillips?

What about at his win at superflyweight, did it really compare with a win over Winky? No wait....Calderon only put on 3lbs he never went to super flyweight.

And a draw and SD against Rodel Mayol a fighter who was like 25-3, had been knocked out twice and had lost both previous title challenges to such heralded names as Eagle Den Junlephan and Solis and got KO'd in 4 by some guy called Adrian Hernandez, is that really as good as moving up another weight class and dominating a former p4p star in Winky

It seems to me you are actually giving Calderon more credit because a) he is tiny, and b) his punches carry less weight than an anorexic model.

Williams deserves to be above Calderon, who is very lucky to have survived unbeaten in his last two defences against a nobody.